Reviews of Mignon Steak describe a mix of experiences, with many praising well cooked signature steaks, flavorful fries, and tasty soups and desserts, though a few meals are noted as overcooked, underseasoned, or cold. The ambiance is frequently highlighted as cozy and inviting or luxurious, with fans of the old town setting and the bar area reporting a warm vibe and strong cocktails. Service is a major talking point, described as excellent, attentive, and friendly by many, while some visits mention slow timing, uneven attentiveness, or temperature issues in the dining room. Value and pricing are mixed too, with table d'hote options and some meals seen as good value, while portions or certain dishes may feel small or overpriced to others. Overall, Mignon Steak appears to provide a memorable night out with high points for food and atmosphere, but experiences vary, suggesting it is worth trying with reasonable expectations around service speed and consistency.
I had a great experience at Mignon Steak Vieux-Montréal, overall. The service was attentive, & the atmosphere was on point. We sat in the Negroni Room, which was cozy with low lighting & great music. The food was enjoyable, for the most part. The onion soup was solid, & the mac & cheese stood out-it was cheesy & had a nice crunch from the breadcrumbs, which made it a little different from the usual versions I've had. Also had green peas. Definitely worth trying. As for the steak frites, the sirloin cut was tasty, but I'd recommend asking for the sauce on the side. While the sauce was flavorful, it completely covered the steak & masked its natural taste. The fries were a fun surprise-they were almost identical to McDonald's fries in both smell & taste, which I actually thought was kind of cool. That said, the biggest letdown was the steak being served cold. It's such a shame because steak is always best sizzling, & you'd expect that at a restaurant like this. It threw off the dish for me a bit, which was disappointing. All in all, the service, food, & vibes made it a good spot to visit. A little more attention to the details would make it even better.
Mignon Steak in Old Port is my go-to for group events, & it never disappoints! The group menu 75 is absolutely to die for, with incredible flavors. The service is always impeccable, & the atmosphere is simply fantastic-elegant yet welcoming. Both the Negroni Room & the main dining area are perfectly suited for any occasion. Highly recommended-this place is a gem! --------- Mignon Steak dans le Vieux-Port est mon endroit préféré pour organiser des événements de groupe, & je n'ai jamais été déçu! Le menu de groupe 75 est absolument incroyable, avec des saveurs incroyables. Le service est toujours impeccable, & l'atmosphère est tout simplement fantastique-élégante & conviviale. La Negroni Room ainsi que la salle à manger principale sont parfaites pour toutes les occasions. Je recommande à 100 %-ce restaurant est une perle rare!
Dec 30, 2024
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
The espresso martini was the best we ever had. Outstanding cocktails & service. Wine expert was someone to remember! Extremely passionate & knowledgeable about their craft (wine, whiskey, etc.) & dollar oysters. Delicious, affordable & fresh. Overall thank you! Highly recommend.
My wife & I had dinner at Mignon Steak Vieux-Montréal, & unfortunately, our experience was far from satisfactory. Despite making a reservation at a steakhouse, we were bizarrely asked if we were vegetarians upon arrival. This felt out of place & left us wondering why that was necessary information when we'd clearly chosen a steakhouse. The service continued to disappoint. When we asked for salt for our fries, the waiter condescendingly asked if we had tasted them first - incredibly patronizing. We also ordered a side of mushrooms & onions, which was forgotten & only brought out well after our meals had been served. As a result, I had to watch my dinner get cold while waiting for the side dish. Adding insult to injury, we couldn't help but notice that the waiter was far more attentive to the table next to us, frequently checking on them & ensuring their dishes arrived in the order they preferred. This stark contrast in service made our experience even more frustrating. Though we were offered a free dessert as compensation, we declined, expecting that the mishandled side dish would be removed from our bill in lieu of the dessert. Unfortunately, it wasn't, which was a disappointing end to an already subpar dining experience. The entire evening felt condescending & strange, & we left feeling very unimpressed. We would not recommend this restaurant to others based on our experience.
Very nice little restaurant. Food was very good, the staff friendly & welcoming, atmosphere is good as well, the place feels nice & cozy. I would definitely recommend this place.
Very cozy place I really enjoyed the mignon Steak (their special dish) & our server Herminie made our night more special with her exceptional service! I Definitely recommend this place.
Nous avons souper semaine passée au Mignon Steak, nourriture très bonne (steak-frites, saumon & tartare) & cocktails exceptionnels ! Le service était très bien & les serveurs Joséphine & Sam très agréables. Je recommande fortement !!
Apr 5, 2024
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Went to Mignon a week ago & the service & the food was amazing! The menu is super simple & straight to the point! Really love the ambiance of this place super casual with a fine dining feel! Highly recommend going to Mignon for any occasion!!
This place was amazing!! The service was great & the food was sooo delicious. We ordered the steak frites, chocolate mousse, & cheesecake. I would 100% recommend this place & return.
