Mignon Steak

Renzo

4.0

Got the Table d'Hôte menu & a couple of wine glasses, the soup starter was very tasty & interesting, it was a cauliflour & leek cream soup. The steak frites was definitely the best course with the fries being absolutely insane. The steak was savory & the sauce was delicious. The dessert was not the best since they ran out of Creme Brulée. Very vibey, the food did take a lot of time between courses.

Jan 17, 2026

on Google

David

1.0

I went in because the place looked quant & inviting.
Lesson to self…read reviews!
This was probably one of the worst meals I've paid 50+ bucks for…no way that was fillet mignon!…toughest piece of meat ever…was actually wondering if it was mutton!…& I'm sure the sauce was a can of some kind of campbells soup…& if I wanted McDonald's fries…(at least McDonald's serves them hot) I would have went to McDonald's.
The salad….come on! Put some effort into it.

Jan 9, 2026

on Google

Anthony

2.0

Had a 1700 reservation for 6. First, if its cold out stay away, we had to keep our jackets on because everytime someone comes into the restaurant or leaves there is a very healthy breeze of cold air that comes in. It is not pleasant.
There was an issue with the temperature of almost all our dishes, the onion soups were sent back because they were warm at best & when we got them back it was barely better. Beef tartare was good , Mac & Cheese was tiny & soupy. The fries were good, of the four steaks ordered all were overcooked & 1 was tough. The house sauce is delicious. The mussels were good but the portion is lacking compared to similar places such as Lemeac, Holder & Brasserie Bernard. The salmon dish was well cooked & tasty.
As my reviews of of other restaurants can attest, I am not super critical of most restaurants i go to. This unfortunately was not a good experience. Quality was lacking on many fronts tonight. The experience was underwhelming at best. Maybe it was an off night.

Dec 25, 2025

on Google

Mohammadali

5.0

Staff were super polite & friendly, steak was well made & service was really good. Definitely suggest the soup, it was wonderful!!
Had a great experience!

Sep 21, 2025

on Google

Janelle

2.0

We went here for my partner's birthday dinner & tried the set. Steak was drowing in sauce which overpowered it abit too much & it was too rich that we got tired of it pretty quickly. I noted on my reservation that this was a birthday celebration & requested for candles during our dessert as a surprise for my boyfriend & never had it - could have let us know if it wasnt available. Honestly was pretty disappointed at that but we didnt let it ruin our night. As we paid, I tipped 10$ on card as I was hoping to tip the rest in cash - we basically maxed out our credit card for the day. The guy basically told us with a passive aggressive tone that'for next time, 15% is the minimum because at this point, were only receiving 5%'. His attitude totally ruined our night & ended up not leaving the cash tip as planned. Additionally, the soup of the day had nuts & no one specified this to us when we ordered - thankfully it was just a mild reaction afterwards but best if informed in advance. We will definitely not be recommending this restaurant to the guests that we have as we both work in the Tourism industry.

Sep 11, 2025

on Google

Colin

5.0

Got the $50 deal with soup or salad, steak & fries, & a dessert. Wife liked the salad, I liked the carrot/turnip soup , steaks cooked perfectly & fries were great. Curious about their poutine…

May 26, 2025

on Google

Roland

5.0

We came here to celebrate a friend's birthday here, & the food, server, & ambiance did not disappoint. We were seated in the lower level which had a dim-lighting, cozy vibe. We ordered the table d'hôte which included soup/salad, steak & fries, & dessert. Absolutely delicious & worth it! Our server Antoine was attentive & regularly checked in with us. A good place to check out & eat in Old Montreal.

Mar 31, 2025

on Google

Barrington

4.0

Absolutely amazing time at this place. Our waiter was lively & informative, the atmosphere was welcoming but not boring, & the food was delicious.

The sweet potato soup is definitely on my top 5 list of best soups. Real cream was used, & that's a sign of a good soup.

The cream puff for dessert was was like creamy air covered in decadent chocolate. Worth the table d'hote just for this.

Now for the one negative thing I have to say about here. While my steak was cooked to perfection & flavourful, I am not used to having McCain style fries with a higher end steak frites. Especially in Montreal of all places, you would expect fresh fries? But maybe that's just me.

Worth a visit, & I will definitely go back. Especially after trying my friend's rack of lamb.

Feb 25, 2025

on Google

Guillaume

3.0

I had a great experience at Mignon Steak Vieux-Montréal, overall. The service was attentive, & the atmosphere was on point. We sat in the Negroni Room, which was cozy with low lighting & great music. The food was enjoyable, for the most part. The onion soup was solid, & the mac & cheese stood out-it was cheesy & had a nice crunch from the breadcrumbs, which made it a little different from the usual versions I've had. Also had green peas. Definitely worth trying. As for the steak frites, the sirloin cut was tasty, but I'd recommend asking for the sauce on the side. While the sauce was flavorful, it completely covered the steak & masked its natural taste. The fries were a fun surprise-they were almost identical to McDonald's fries in both smell & taste, which I actually thought was kind of cool. That said, the biggest letdown was the steak being served cold. It's such a shame because steak is always best sizzling, & you'd expect that at a restaurant like this. It threw off the dish for me a bit, which was disappointing. All in all, the service, food, & vibes made it a good spot to visit. A little more attention to the details would make it even better.

Dec 30, 2024

on Google

Florence

5.0

Herminie's service was great, she was very sweet! The food was to die for, I swear my friends & I were scrapping the plates with their fries... which were perfect by the way. Don't hesitate & have a seat at one of their tables 👌 Oh & order the soup! It's at least as good as the fries.

Apr 20, 2024

on Google

Michau

5.0

Nous avons souper semaine passée au Mignon Steak, nourriture très bonne (steak-frites, saumon & tartare) & cocktails exceptionnels ! Le service était très bien & les serveurs Joséphine & Sam très agréables. Je recommande fortement !!

Apr 5, 2024

on Google

Gabriella

5.0

Amazing food amazing service & the atmosphere is cozy & classy. Best cream of mushroom soup I've ever had! & the lychee martini was incredible! They also have a great selection.

Feb 18, 2024

on Google