Italian Restaurants in Downtown

(1446)

Downtown, Golden Square Mile

Italian Seafood/Fish Grill Pizza Pasta

Mentioned in: La Medusa: The Beauty of Italy

Review Summary

La Medusa comes across as a warmly welcoming Italian spot in downtown Montreal, offering fresh, well prepared dishes that cover pasta, seafood, pizza and antipasti, plus a strong wine list. Reviews consistently note friendly, attentive service and a lively, family friendly ambiance that suits pre or post game outings near Centre Bell. The food is described as authentic Italian and often excellent, with many praising the pizza crust, the pasta textures and flavorful sauces, though a few mentions call out a risotto that is too salty or prices that can be high. Some moments of slower service or busy nights are acknowledged, but the overall tone points to a reliable favorite worth returning to, including interest in private dining spaces for celebrations. Overall the place is regarded as one of the top Italian options in the area, delivering consistent flavors, helpful staff, and an atmosphere that makes diners feel at home in the city.View restaurant profile

Il Focolaio

Located next to the SENS HØTEL

(967)

Downtown

Pizza Italian Café Salads

Mentioned in: The Best Pizza in Montreal The Best Wood-Fired Neapolitan Style Pizzas in Montreal View More

Review Summary

Il Focolaio offers wood fired, thin crust pizzas with a vast range of toppings and a menu that balances classic Italian staples with inventive options, all baked to perfection in a real Italian oven. The crust is consistently crisp and flavorful, the ingredients are fresh, and gluten free crust and lactose free cheese options are appreciated by many diners. The service is repeatedly described as fast, friendly and attentive, with staff making guests feel welcome and cared for even during busy periods. The atmosphere is lively yet cozy, making it a great spot for casual dinners, family nights or a quick bite after visiting nearby sights, and the location downtown Montreal adds to its appeal. Desserts like tiramisu and cannoli are frequently praised, and the wine and beer selection complements the meals well. Overall, this spot is widely regarded as one of the best pizza places in town, a must visit for pizza lovers, with many guests planning to return.View restaurant profile

GESO Ristorante - Italian Restaurants in Downtown

GESO Ristorante

Long-running restaurant with a flower-filled courtyard, featuring Italian specialties & wines

(60)

Downtown, Shaughnessy Village

Italian Pasta Grill Market Vegan Options Salads

Mentioned in: Best Venues for a Christmas Party in Montreal 2025 Best Hotel and Spa Restaurants in Montreal View More

Review Summary

GESO Ristorante offers a welcoming atmosphere near the hotel with consistently delicious food and attentive, discreet service. Diners praise a varied menu including eggplant parmesan, garlic crusted salmon, mushroom spaghetti, gnocchi, and even a notable Barolo that pairs beautifully with the meals. The wine list and tasting notes are highlighted along with thoughtful touches from staff and the owner, making for friendly and helpful interactions about the area. Some comments mention that value for the price can vary by dish, but the overall impression is of satisfying flavors, good vibes, and professional hospitality.View restaurant profile

Il Cortile - Italian Restaurants in Downtown

Il Cortile

Homemade Pasta • Pizza • & More

(275)

Downtown

Italian Pasta Seafood/Fish

Mentioned in: 15 Italian Restaurants To Impress Your Date Best Terraces in Montréal, Laval, the South Shore and the West Island View More

Review Summary

Il Cortile offers an enchanting Italian dining experience in a charming downtown courtyard, with authentic flavors, generous portions, and a warm, attentive staff that makes celebrations feel special; the atmosphere blends cozy European charm with a beautiful terrace that transports diners to Italy, and the menu features well executed pastas, gnocchi, seafood, and dessert options that consistently impress. Service can be slower during peak times or larger groups, but guests describe the staff as going above and beyond to accommodate requests and to create memorable evenings worth repeating.View restaurant profile

Reserve
Menu

El Pastaman

Open until 1 am

(542)

Downtown, The Village/Centre-Sud

Pasta Pizza Italian

Review Summary

El Pastaman is widely praised for fresh pasta with authentic flavors and generous portions. Reviewers note a wide range of options including halal, vegetarian, gluten free and other inclusive choices. Friendly and attentive staff create a welcoming atmosphere and go the extra mile for allergies and requests. Pasta favorites such as carbonara, Alfredo and rose sauce are frequently praised for flavor and freshness. Takeout and late hours make it easy to enjoy great pasta any time, with many diners calling it reliable value.View restaurant profile

Enoteca Monza Pizzeria Moderna

Italian Coffee and Specialties

(970)

Downtown, Golden Square Mile

Italian Pizza Pasta Salads

Review Summary

Enoteca Monza Pizzeria Moderna draws diners with a warm, modern setting, a broad menu focused on pizzas and pastas, and generous portions that many reviewers appreciate. Service is repeatedly praised for being attentive and friendly, with fast and efficient handling that enhances the dining experience, though a few visits note occasional delays or loud music. The food earns high marks for freshness and flavor, with particular affection for the crusty pizzas, creamy pastas, and a tiramisu that many describe as excellent, while a handful of dishes are mentioned as less impressive. The atmosphere suits both casual lunches and celebratory dinners, with terrace seating and a lively but cozy vibe that guests find appealing. Value is seen as solid for Montreal, with many saying the quality justifies the price, and the option to take advantage of specials or gluten free choices noted by some. Overall the reviews point to a dependable Italian spot that delivers consistently tasty dishes, friendly service, and a welcoming ambiance, making it a popular choice for repeat visits.View restaurant profile

Parma Café

Open until 9 pm

(274)

Downtown, Golden Square Mile

Italian Pizza Sandwiches Café Pasta

Mentioned in: Your Guide to Montreal's Must-Try Sandwiches

Review Summary

Parma Café is described as a casual Italian cafe with a broad menu of food and desserts, where fresh bread and generous paninis such as steak capicollo and porchetta, along with classics like tiramisu and cannoli, stand out for authentic flavors. Across reviews, the vibe is cozy and welcoming, the atmosphere lively, and the staff friendly and helpful, though a few notes point to occasional counter delays or a busy, noisy space. The sandwiches and deli items consistently come up as the top picks, with many praising the mortadella panini, the balance of fillings, and the crisp bread, while some diners mention value as a plus and others caution that take-out or lunchtime crowds can affect experience. Desserts and pasta are also highlighted for quality, with coffee praised by many and at least one miss on an iced latte. Overall, Parma Café is viewed as a reliable choice for flavorful, substantial meals and casual dining, offering good value and a memorable sandwich experience, while acknowledging that peak times can feel crowded and service can vary.View restaurant profile

Order

Restaurant Tbsp.

Located in the W Montreal Hotel

Open until 9:30 pm

(271)

Downtown, Old Montreal

Contemporary/Modern Italian Breakfast Gluten-free Options

Review Summary

Tbsp. is described across reviews as a chic, calm dining spot inside a hotel setting, with consistently attentive service and knowledgeable staff who help guests navigate a creative, high quality menu. The food is frequently praised for originality, flavor, and beautiful presentation, with standout items ranging from inventive starters and pastas to well balanced dishes like a fried Brussels sprouts salad and a sesame seed bagel eggs Benedict, and the cheese selection and cocktails are also highlighted. The atmosphere is noted as elegant and quiet, making it suitable for conversations, romantic dinners, or celebrations, and the dining room and decor receive compliments. While the majority of experiences are positive, a few notes point to dishes arriving cold on some visits, occasional pricing that feels steep for the portion or concept, and a brunch experience that fell short due to disorganized service. Overall, Tbsp. appears to offer a memorable dining experience with strong creativity, solid service, and a focus on zero waste dishes on newer menus.View restaurant profile

Restaurant Abruzzo

May be temporarily closed

(111)

Downtown, The Village/Centre-Sud

Italian Café Gluten-free Options

Review Summary

Guests describe Restaurant Abruzzo as a cozy, chic Italian spot with carefully chosen background music that creates a warm, relaxing vibe. Impeccable service and a spotless setting are highlighted, with staff attentive to details and plates plated with care. The menu showcases from scratch cooking and generous portions at fair prices, with gluten free options available. Dishes mentioned include prosciutto with parmesan, mushroom arancini, chicken parmigiana, lobster ravioli, lardo and mushroom pizza, and pappardelle with venison ragout in red wine, as well as raviolis with porc and provolone. Leftovers are often taken home because portions are generous and the pricing feels fair. The experience is described as consistently authentic and soulful, with a sense of being a gem that makes guests want to return for special occasions. A Palermo inspired atmosphere and a few new twists like triangular spaghetti Bolognaise add to the variety.View restaurant profile

Ristorante Beatrice

Urban oasis in the heart of Montreal

May be temporarily closed

(173)

Downtown

Italian Market Grill Pasta Seafood/Fish Creative

Mentioned in: The Best Private Rooms in Montreal

Review Summary

Reviews for Ristorante Beatrice highlight outstanding food and usually solid service, with praised dishes such as filet mignon, cavatelli, fettucine and truffle specials, as well as carpaccio and cannoli, and a wine program noted for interesting pairings. The service is repeatedly described as attentive, knowledgeable and courteous, though a few accounts mention moments of haste or inconsistency and occasional upselling. Ambiance elicits mixed feelings: many find it elegant and immaculate, while others describe the setting as bland, cold, or overly polished in a way that clashes with the food. Some diners call the experience superb and worth a visit, including special wine dinner events, while others feel the value is questionable given price and atmosphere. Overall the place comes across as a destination for strong food and friendly service, with impressions of atmosphere and value varying by guest.View restaurant profile

Restaurant Siciliana

(312)

Downtown

Italian Pasta Pizza

Review Summary

Reviewers describe Restaurant Siciliana as warm and cozy with a retro vibe and a wood-fired oven that elevates pizza and garlic bread. The Italian flavors feel authentic and ingredients seem fresh, with frequent praise for pasta, lasagna, seafood dishes, and the pizza, though the crust can be dry or burnt in places. Service is often noted as friendly and attentive, creating a welcoming atmosphere, while some visits report slower pacing or uneven timing between courses. The ambience and decor contribute to a casual, charming feel, and many appreciate the value and portions. Some reviews mention downsides such as cleanliness issues, lingering oven fumes, or a need for greater consistency, but overall the dining experience is viewed positively and many would return.View restaurant profile

Order

Trattoria Trestevere

Italian Coffee and Specialties

(224)

Downtown, Golden Square Mile

Italian

Mentioned in: On the Hunt for Montreal's Best Cannoli

Review Summary

Overall, reviews describe Trattoria Trestevere as a warm, family‑run Italian spot with a cozy, unpretentious vibe and a staff that makes guests feel welcome from start to finish. The food is consistently praised for authentic flavors and classic dishes such as gnocchi, lasagna, veal parmigiana, seafood pasta and carpaccio, with several highlights including gnocchi rosé and a rich dessert selection. While the interior is described as charmingly old‑school rather than upscale and prices can be on the higher side for some, the generous portions, thoughtful service and lively, homey atmosphere make the experience worth it for many diners. Multiple reviews emphasize the standout hospitality and explanations of the menu, and many say they would return or recommend it for a romantic evening, family dinner or casual night out. In essence, Trattoria Trestevere is frequently portrayed as a dependable, welcoming place for traditional Italian cooking, where good service and comforting flavors leave a lasting impression.View restaurant profile

Order

Parma Café

Opens Tomorrow at 8:30 am

(252)

Downtown

Italian Pizza Sandwiches Café Pasta

Mentioned in: Your Guide to Montreal's Must-Try Sandwiches

Review Summary

Overall, Parma Café receives strong praise for delicious Italian style dishes, excellent coffee, and friendly, efficient service in a bright, welcoming setting that works for both quick meals and work sessions. The sandwiches and paninis are frequently highlighted as flavorful and substantial, with monthly specials and crowd favorites keeping regulars coming back, while espresso and other drinks are often described as top quality. The atmosphere is often noted as pleasant and conducive to lingering or getting work done, though a few reviews mention that the space can feel small or busy and that some prices run high for the portion or item. Occasional critiques point to dryness in a porchetta panini and a few service hiccups, but the overall impression is of reliable food, good value in portions, and friendly staff. In short, Parma Café stands out for solid coffee, tasty bites, and a welcoming vibe that draws guests back.View restaurant profile

Order

Located at Place des Festivals, IL TEATRO puts everything in place to give you an incomparable experience.

Ristorante Il Teatro

Come experience an unforgettable gastronomic adventure.

(40)

Quartier des Spectacles, Downtown

Italian Pizza Pasta Grill Salads

Mentioned in: Best New Restaurants in Montreal (April 2026)

Review Summary

Ristorante Il Teatro offers a very pleasant evening with friends, with meals described as delicious and a burrata that is particularly praised. The atmosphere is elegant and unique, with a warm, intimate dining room that enhances the overall experience. Service is repeatedly described as impeccable and attentive, with staff who are professional, friendly, and knowledgeable about the menu. Guests note thoughtful care from the team and a manager who engages with guests and shares enthusiasm for the restaurant. The decor is described as superb and the overall impression as a refined discovery that makes it a place to return to. Many express the desire to come back to try new dishes and to visit before or after performances. Overall, Il Teatro comes across as a strong new favorite with high standards for food, service, and ambiance.View restaurant profile

Reserve

Tiamo

(662)

Downtown, Quartier des Spectacles

Italian Pizza

Mentioned in: Where to Eat in Montreal's Quartier des Spectacles

Review Summary

Overall, Tiamo comes across as a stylish and cozy Italian spot with a lively atmosphere and a strong emphasis on wood-fired pizzas and generous portions, though several reviews mention high prices relative to portion size and mixed dish quality. Pizzas are frequently highlighted as excellent, along with tasty pastas and appealing desserts, while a few mains can be bland or overcooked and some tables experience slow service or inconsistent pacing, especially during busy times. The cocktails and wine lists are often praised, and many guests note attentive, friendly service, even as others report variable experiences and occasional gaps in attention or speed. The ambiance is repeatedly described as chic, vibrant, and suitable for dates or groups, but noise levels can be loud and seating tight, with some guests noting discomfort at higher levels or near kitchens. Reservation advice is common, as is the sentiment that the dining experience can be very good or excellent, but value for money depends on expectations and the specific dish and moment.View restaurant profile

Order

Bellucci Italia

(569)

Downtown, Quartier des Spectacles

Italian Pasta Seafood/Fish

Review Summary

Bellucci Italia receives praise for authentic Italian cooking, with standout wood fired pizzas, fresh pastas, and desserts that many describe as exceptional. The atmosphere is described as cozy and elegant, with large windows and a lively vibe that makes it a good spot for dates or groups. Service is frequently highlighted as friendly and attentive, though a few visits report slow, uneven service and crowded, tightly spaced tables during peak times. While prices are often noted as high, the overall quality, ingredients and execution are seen as worth the splurge by many guests. The wine list and cocktails are a plus, complemented by flexible accommodations for families and large parties. Some diners note occasional dish issues such as over-salted sauces or inconsistent pasta, but these concerns are the exception rather than the rule. Overall, Bellucci Italia is regarded as one of Montreal's notable Italian options, delivering strong flavors, welcoming hospitality and a memorable dining experience that invites return visits, especially when reservations are secured for busy periods.View restaurant profile

Order

Pizzeria Moretti

(159)

Downtown

Italian Pasta Pizza

Review Summary

Pizzeria Moretti earns praise for consistently delicious food and a lively, stylish Italian atmosphere. Reviews highlight a wide menu of pizzas, seafood, pasta, and desserts, with the wine list often noted as strong. The vibe ranges from energetic and vibrant to very noisy, which can make conversation difficult. Service quality is mixed, from attentive and friendly to slow or inconsistent, with occasional lapses such as slow refills, tables moved during meals, or high prices and unexpected charges for water. Some visits include thoughtful gestures and welcome hospitality, while others describe rushed handling or a detached greeting. Overall, the food and ambiance draw guests back for special occasions and groups, though opportunities remain to improve consistency and value.View restaurant profile

Order

Cappello

44th floor

(138)

Downtown

Italian Pasta Salads Seafood/Fish

Mentioned in: At the RestoMontreal Team Table: Our February 2026 Media Invitations and Favourites 17 Restaurants with Amazing Views in Greater Montreal View More

Review Summary

Cappello receives high marks for its breathtaking city views, sophisticated yet inviting atmosphere, and a menu that frequently pleases with well executed Italian dishes and a standout tiramisu, while the wine list and cocktails get consistent praise. The experience is often described as memorable and well suited for special occasions, with service commonly noted as attentive and professional, though some visits mention slower pacing during busy periods and occasional missteps in timing or presentation. A common thread notes that prices can be high for the portions or certain dishes, and a few criticisms point to underseasoned or overly fatty items, yet many dishes are described as delicious and thoughtfully prepared. Overall, Cappello's dramatic views and engaging ambiance are the defining draw, making it a spot many would return to for a special night, provided expectations align with the moment.View restaurant profile

Reserve

Celeste

Sandwiches Italian Comfort Food

(40)

Downtown

Italian Mediterranean

Mentioned in: The Best Spots for Dirty Martinis in Montreal At the RestoMontreal Team Table: Our January 2026 Media Invitations and Favourites View More

Review Summary

Reviews collectively describe Celeste as a stunning, inviting dining room with beautiful décor, a warm, attentive staff, and a vibe that blends refined elegance with comfort. The food is consistently praised for freshness and flavor, with highlights such as cannelloni, mushroom pasta, branzino tartar, calamari, and raw tuna, along with a standout stracciatella salad, cowgirl cut steak, and crispy duck fat potatoes; desserts like a chocolate cake are repeatedly cited as exceptional. Drinks, including red wine from Puglia and espresso martinis, are noted as well balanced, and the bread is described as amazingly fresh. While the restaurant is seen as on the pricier side, many feel the quality, presentation, and service make the experience worthwhile, making it a popular choice for special occasions, date nights, or lively evenings with friends. The atmosphere and staff are consistently described as top notch, with guests leaving eager to return to Celeste for another memorable night out.View restaurant profile

Pizza Maria

Downtown, Golden Square Mile

Pizza Italian

Via Vivoli

Open until 9 pm

(1)

Downtown

Italian

Bella Sandwicheria

Opens Monday at 11 am

(8)

Downtown, Golden Square Mile

Mentioned in: Your Guide to Montreal's Must-Try Sandwiches

Review Summary

Reviews describe Bella Sandwicherie as a bright, modern spot in a downtown food court with sandwiches that are full of flavor on freshly baked focaccia. The menu features hearty options such as meatballs with arugula pesto, porchetta with a spicy bomba spread, and prosciutto with fig jam and stracciatella, all presented on their own freshly baked focaccia. The sandwiches are delicious and worth a detour for a flavorful quick bite, and the space is noted as lively yet ideal for a weekday lunch. Price comes up as a drawback for some, described as pricey for a lunch inside a food court, though others find the value reasonable compared to similar spots. Hours were said to be weekdays only with weekends closed in November, so calling ahead to confirm is advised.View restaurant profile

Order

Le Restaurant Crossbar

(29)

Downtown

Italian American Breakfast

Review Summary

Le Restaurant Crossbar shows mixed feedback from diners, with breakfast described as meh or expensive and the new breakfast menu seen as costly for a regular meal, while the overall atmosphere is often described as pleasant and the location near the Bell Centre with games on a plus. The margarita pizza earns strong recommendation, and some servers are praised for teamwork and friendliness, though service is also described as inconsistent and at times non existent after ordering or slow, with seating rules sometimes unclear. Food quality varies from acceptable to disappointing, with an omelet that may taste reheated, small pancakes with scant syrup and cold toast mentioned, though a hot chocolate and some staff interactions are positively noted. There are comments about good follow up asking if the meal was okay and about attentive service by some staff, yet the pricing is repeatedly called high and value questionable, reinforcing a sense of inconsistency overall. Overall Le Restaurant Crossbar comes across as a lively spot with a good ambiance and some helpful staff, but quality and value are uneven across visits.View restaurant profile

Order

Sea-Me

May be temporarily closed

(83)

Downtown

Italian Pasta Seafood/Fish

Mentioned in: Montreal's Seafood Hotspots: Where to Catch the Best Flavors

Review Summary

Sea-Me earns praise for its flavors and presentation, with sea bass and branzino highlighted as standouts, the mushroom risotto beloved, and oysters with house vinaigrette noted, while MTL à table events are described as a good way to discover the menu. Service is repeatedly described as attentive and friendly, and the setting is bright and attractive, though a few reviews mention hiccups such as a plate that was too salty, a dry fish, a dessert substitution when tiramisu was unavailable, and questions about water options and the bill. Ambience is described as lively but not overly noisy, with some weeknight visits feeling a bit dull yet still enjoyable for the culinary experience. Overall, Sea-Me is seen by many as offering excellent food and service with generous portions and good value, while a minority note price or consistency concerns.View restaurant profile

La Marinara

Open until 9:30 pm

(1058)

Downtown

Italian Bistro

Review Summary

La Marinara earns widespread praise for authentic Italian cooking, homemade pasta that many describe as among the best, and a warm, intimate, unpretentious dining room. Reviews highlight friendly, attentive service from a family-run team and a cozy atmosphere that feels welcoming rather than formal. Dishes like gnocchi, fettuccine and veal marsala are repeatedly praised, with tiramisu and Caesar salad noted as standout desserts, while some nights offer generous portions and others feature smaller servings for certain items. Occasional drawbacks include a very salty soup, a carbonara with too much cream cheese, and high wine prices, but these are not universal. Overall, La Marinara is seen as a dependable downtown option that delivers comforting, well-executed Italian flavors and a consistently positive experience that keeps locals and visitors returning.View restaurant profile

Heirloom Vin & Pizza

Gourmet Sandwiches & Italian Deli

(114)

Quartier des Spectacles, Downtown

Pizza Italian Pizzeria

Mentioned in: Where to Eat in Montreal's Quartier des Spectacles The Best Wood-Fired Neapolitan Style Pizzas in Montreal View More

Review Summary

Heirloom Vin & Pizza draws mixed to positive feedback, with praise for a strong dough and high quality ingredients and many calling it one of the best pizzerias in town, especially downtown. The dough is repeatedly praised and service is described as fast and friendly even on busy nights, with takeout working smoothly, though ambiance is often noted as lacking and the venue can feel like an upgraded food court. The menu offers variety with good wine options and poutine and is a solid choice for a midday meal. On the pizza side, the calabrese is flavorful and the four cheese pie can be excellent when the cheese balance is right, but some find the four cheese version too blue cheese heavy and the vegetable pie bland. The caesar salad is small and could use more sauce.View restaurant profile

BOSSA Prêt à manger

(352)

Downtown

Sandwiches Pasta Italian Café

Mentioned in: Where to Find Cheap Eats in Montreal Your Guide to Montreal's Must-Try Sandwiches View More

Review Summary

Reviewers repeatedly praise Bossa for large, flavorful sandwiches made with high quality ingredients, from porchetta and chicken parmigiana to mortadella and cannoli, with many noting generous portions and a satisfying mix of textures. The menu's variety satisfies many tastes, including hot and cold options, and the desserts are frequently highlighted as standout treats. Service is described as fast and friendly, with attentive staff and cashiers who help with orders and recommendations, though a few notes mention long lines during peak hours and occasional slower experiences at certain locations. Overall, the experience is described as delicious, consistent, and great value for the price, with several mentions calling it among the best sandwich spots in Montreal. Some reviewers felt the hype was excessive or noted occasional grease or price concerns, and one review mentioned a past issue with dessert presentation, but most recall a warm, welcoming vibe and reliable quality across visits. In short, Bossa offers substantial, flavorful sandwiches and a positive, bustling atmosphere that attracts repeat visits.View restaurant profile

Sotto by Soubois

(29)

Downtown

Charcuterie Pasta Italian Seafood/Fish

Mentioned in: Burrata: The Fanciest Cheese and Where to Taste it in Montreal Best Supper Clubs in Montreal You Need to Experience View More

Review Summary

Overall, reviews describe Sotto by Soubois as delivering top notch food and a warm, attentive atmosphere when service runs smoothly. The menu earns high marks for seafood such as octopus and oysters Rockefeller, Cajun oysters with heat, and other dishes that are fresh, flavorful and well presented. Drinks and cocktails are often highlighted, with the dirty gin martini receiving particular praise, and portions described as satisfying and balanced. The vibe is repeatedly noted as lively and welcoming, whether during a party, a birthday, or a casual dinner, and the central downtown location is a plus. Several visits recount service missteps and timing issues, including a Valentine dinner with long waits, bread substitutions, a rude exchange with staff, a mistaken bill item, and at least one overcooked fish and undercooked pasta. Even with occasional flaws, the kitchen's passion and the balance of tradition and creativity come through, leading many to say Sotto by Soubois is worth returning to.View restaurant profile

Restaurant Tuscolo

Open until 3 am

(192)

Downtown

Italian Pizza Pasta Grill Market Mussels

Review Summary

Restaurant Tuscolo elicits mixed feedback, with pizza often praised as amazing and tiramisu noted as memorable, while overall dining experiences range from very good to not ideal due to service quality and value. Food is generally described as good to excellent, but waits for pasta can be lengthy and portions can vary even when served at the same time, raising questions about price. Service can be slow or disengaged on some visits, though other experiences highlight attentive staff and a pleasant atmosphere with indoor or balcony seating and a downtown price range that is respectable; a solid wine selection from France and Italy is also mentioned. Overall the reviews emphasize standout flavors and a memorable pizza, but inconsistent service and value balance influence whether the visit feels worth it, leaving some patrons eager to return and others unsure.View restaurant profile

Order

Stella Brasserie italienne

(1400)

Quartier des Spectacles, Downtown

Italian Pizza

Review Summary

Stella Brasserie Italienne is described as a downtown Montreal gem with a prime location for catching a show and a lively atmosphere that suits pre or post theatre dining. Food generally draws strong praise, especially pizzas with dough described as perfect and toppings top notch, and a diverse menu that includes pasta, seafood, and meat dishes with several items singled out as standouts. Signature cocktails and a wine list are frequently highlighted as part of the experience. Service is consistently praised for friendliness and efficiency in many visits, though some reviewers note uneven attention, slow water refills, or missteps during busy periods. Ambiance is often described as chic and energetic, with a warm vibe and terrace option, and some comments mention the occasional noise level or busyness at peak times. Prices are sometimes labeled as high, but many reviews feel the value is fair given location, quality, and drinks, making the overall experience worth returning for. Overall, the consensus is that Stella Brasserie Italienne is a go-to spot for a delicious meal before or after a show, offering generous portions, strong pizza and cocktail offerings, and a hospitable atmosphere, with service consistency as the main area for improvement.View restaurant profile

Reserve

Piazza Sociale Restaurant

(2)

Downtown, Golden Square Mile

Pizza Italian Pasta

Vago Italien

(164)

Westmount, Downtown

Italian Grill Pasta Seafood/Fish

Review Summary

Reviews describe Vago Italien as a neighborhood spot with friendly, attentive service and a welcoming vibe, where the food generally shines with strong plate presentation and standout dishes like gnocchi, though a few items such as meatballs and fried calamari have been noted as pricey for what is offered. Desserts, the wine list, and a sangria are frequently praised, and many say they would return, noting it as a good option for dinners, celebrations, or corporate gatherings. The ambiance is described as elegant and modern, sometimes lively or loud, with a private room and easy parking after hours highlighted as bonuses. Overall the impression is very favorable, with guests mentioning memorable meals, professional and personal service, and a sense of reliability that makes it a top choice for multiple visits.View restaurant profile

Order

Bis Ristorante

Italian Seafood/Fish Grill Gluten-free Options

(1524)

Downtown

Mentioned in: Burrata: The Fanciest Cheese and Where to Taste it in Montreal

Review Summary

Reviews of Bis Ristorante describe a warm, cozy Italian dining spot with authentic, flavorful food and professional yet friendly service. The ambiance is frequently described as romantic and conducive to conversation, though some tables feel close and can be a bit loud at times. Dishes such as fresh pasta, risotto and seafood or meat specials are hailed as delicious and generously portioned, with many meals described as memorable and well prepared; a few critiques note overdressed salads or occasional overcooked pasta. The staff and management are consistently praised for attentiveness, hospitality and a welcoming atmosphere, contributing to a homey dining experience. The wine list and desserts are well received, supporting Bis Ristorante as a top Italian option in the city for date nights, celebrations or casual dinners alike. Some reviews mention higher prices, though most feel the quality and experience justify the cost; parking options can also be convenient. Overall, Bis Ristorante comes across as a standout for authentic Italian cuisine, warm service, and a memorable, repeatable dining experience that guests are eager to return to.View restaurant profile

Reserve

Da Vinci

Long-established classic Italian restaurant with creative presentations, elegant ambiance and lounge bar.

Italian Seafood/Fish Mediterranean Contemporary/Modern Grill

(167)

Downtown, Golden Square Mile

Review Summary

Da Vinci is described as an elegant, welcoming Italian spot where the atmosphere and attentive service can elevate celebrations, with private rooms and thoughtful touches noted as a plus, but several reviews flag value and consistency as concerns. Valentine’s Day menus were fixed per person and portions were small, featuring a shared burrata salad and bite sized desserts while lobster ravioli appeared as a regular portion. Service ranges from subpar in some visits, with no drink menu and rushed service, to exemplary when staff are on point and attentive throughout the evening. The kitchen turns out flavorful dishes such as pasta Bolognese, mushroom risotto, lamb, tomahawk steak, black cod, and salmon tartare, and desserts and drinks are occasionally praised. However, the price level is criticized by some as too high for what is delivered, while others feel the overall experience justifies it. Overall, Da Vinci emerges as a refined option with strong service and solid Italian cooking, best enjoyed when expectations match the pricing.View restaurant profile

Order

Pizzéria NO.900

Pizza Pizzeria Italian Gluten-free Options

(475)

Downtown

Mentioned in: Exploring Quebec City's Pizzerias: Our Recommendations 19 Must-Try Food Trucks in Montreal for a True Street Food Experience View More

Review Summary

Across reviews, Pizzéria NO.900 is consistently praised for delicious Neapolitan style pizza with a light, flavorful dough and a crisp wood fired crust, fresh toppings, and plenty of variety, with many noting that the pizza tastes authentically Italian and even compares to meals in Naples. The ambiance is described as warm, cozy and convivial, with efficient service and attentive, friendly staff; reservations are often recommended to secure a table, and some mention a charming bar area and open kitchen. Value is generally described as good, with large portions and a strong price to quality ratio, though a few diners point out tight seating or occasional small tables. Some reviews mention minor flaws such as a crust that can be overcooked or soggy centers on certain pies, and a few instances of upselling or crowded conditions during peak times. Desserts like tiramisu and cannoli receive praise, and several patrons declare it among the best pizza spots in Montreal or even the world, encouraging return visits.View restaurant profile

Osteria MKT

(132)

Downtown

Italian Mediterranean

Review Summary

Osteria MKT elicits mixed reviews that cover great food and occasional service issues. Many praise the food as delicious and well presented, with standout dishes like Caprese salad, buffalo mozzarella, lamb pasta, pappardelle with lamb, and tiramisu, and describe the setting as impressive and well suited for private events or a quiet lunch on the terrace. The service is described as friendly and attentive in some visits, while others note slower, less proactive service and long lunch times, with rare missteps such as a lack of apology for a problem. The location and parking are convenient but access can be confusing, and the bathroom situation receives mixed comments. Overall, experiences vary: some meals feel worth the price and memorable, while others feel average or overpriced for the quality. Osteria MKT is also highlighted for hosting private events with strong organization and flexible space to accommodate guests.View restaurant profile

Da Giovanni

Opens Tomorrow at 11 am

(242)

Quartier des Spectacles, Downtown

Italian

Review Summary

Da Giovanni is described across reviews as a classic, affordable Italian spot in Montreal with a warm, nostalgic vibe and a long tradition, known for comforting dishes like spaghetti with meat sauce or meatballs and a well loved pizza crust. Pizza and house wine are frequently praised, portions are generous, and value is highlighted by many diners. The atmosphere is repeatedly called cozy and old-fashioned, though several comments note that the newer location or updated decor with TVs and music changes the feel and diminishes some of the original charm. Service tends to be friendly and attentive, with praise for quick service and accommodating staff, while a few reviews mention crowds, hours, or occasional inconsistencies. Some criticisms focus on discrepancies between online pictures and the actual menu, or on tables that feel crowded. Overall the reviews present Da Giovanni as a reliable, nostalgic choice for classic pasta and pizza at a fair price, beloved by generations and a go to staple in Montreal.View restaurant profile

Order

Fiorellino

(590)

Downtown

Pizza Italian Pizzeria

Mentioned in: The Best Pizza in Montreal The Best Wood-Fired Neapolitan Style Pizzas in Montreal View More

Review Summary

Fiorellino comes across in reviews as a buzzy downtown Italian spot where the pizza is the star and the vibe is warm, lively, and often loud. Guests rave about the wood-fired crust, light dough, and flavorful pastas and gnocchi, with numerous dishes praised for freshness and presentation; the antipasti, salads, and desserts also get favorable mentions. The drinks program is highlighted for well-crafted cocktails and a thoughtful wine list, though some note a limited selection by the glass and a bustle around bar service. Service is generally described as attentive and friendly, with several servers and bartenders going above and beyond, while other visits report long waits for food or a crowded, noisy dining room that makes conversation difficult. Reservations are advised, especially on weekends, and the atmosphere is considered ideal for a lively date night or group outing rather than a quiet meal. Overall, Fiorellino is seen as a delicious, high-energy Italian option in the city, offering excellent pizza and strong hospitality with some variability in pace and acoustics.View restaurant profile

Order

Bar Edicola

Opens Tomorrow at 7:30 am

(103)

Downtown

Italian Bar Pasta Café

Review Summary

Bar Edicola comes across in these reviews as a stylish, warm Italian-inspired spot in downtown Montreal that feels both relaxed and refined. The vibe is lively with uplifting music, a cozy and convivial atmosphere, and attentive service that balances efficiency with space to chat. The drinks program earns praise, from well mixed cocktails to solid coffee service in the morning, and pastries like pistachio croissants. Small plates and dishes such as artichokes, olives, tuna with pistachio, pesto pasta and other simple, fresh offerings are consistently described as tasty and well prepared. The overall experience is described as authentic and welcoming, with guests noting a touch of Italy in the service and ambiance. The space can feel compact and busy at peak times, making it ideal for a casual bite, a coffee, or an aperitivo with friends, rather than large gatherings. While some reviews mention occasional price concerns or room layout, most agree Bar Edicola delivers a memorable, high quality Italian moment in the city, making it a go-to for coffee, cocktails, and bites.View restaurant profile

Bar Caffettiera

(542)

Downtown

Café Italian Pastries

Mentioned in: The Most Aesthetic Cafes in Montreal

Review Summary

Bar Caffettiera is widely praised as an authentic Italian coffee spot in downtown Montreal, with espresso and cappuccino repeatedly described as outstanding and pastries like the pistachio croissant and nocciola coffee singled out as standouts. The atmosphere is lively and welcoming, blending Italian vibes with a casual, no frills service that many reviewers say handles rushes well. The space is small and can get very crowded, and the outdoor terrace in summer is nice but seating indoors can feel cramped; music can be loud. Menu highlights include panini and mortadella pistacchio sandwiches, bombolone, granita latte, and a variety of Italian snacks, with many raving about the granita and the croissants. Several reviews note that the experience is best for coffee and socializing rather than working, and a few mention occasional inconsistencies in pastries or service. Overall Bar Caffettiera stands out as one of the top coffee spots in the city for authentic Italian flavor, vibrant vibe, and friendly staff, albeit with crowding and noise to consider.View restaurant profile

Osteria Schiavio

(219)

Downtown, Old Montreal

Italian Pizza Pasta

Review Summary

Patrons describe Osteria Schiavio as a warm, authentic Italian spot in downtown Montreal with homemade pasta and fresh ingredients across a menu that pairs lasagna, gnocchi, and tuffoli with pizzas and desserts like tiramisu and pistachio cannoli. The atmosphere is commonly praised as cozy and inviting, with nice Italian charm, good music, and an indoor terrace that adds to the experience. Service is repeatedly highlighted as attentive and friendly, with staff known for helpful recommendations and thoughtful touches. Prices are generally considered reasonable for the location, and many say they would return to try more dishes or for a date or family outing. A few caveats include occasional slower service on busy game nights and occasional menu misses such as a margarita pizza that lacks basil or portions that feel small for the price, but the overall impression is of high quality Italian cooking and a welcoming, reliable spot.View restaurant profile

Reserve

Wienstein & Gavino's

Open until 2 am

(1007)

Downtown, Golden Square Mile

Italian Pizza Grill Pasta

Mentioned in: Where to Eat Before a Hockey Game or Concert at Montreal's Bell Centre

Review Summary

Reviews highlight Wienstein & Gavino's as a lively Italian spot on Crescent Street with fresh pasta, generous portions, and a welcoming atmosphere that makes it a reliable downtown option for pizza, pasta, and seafood. The pasta is frequently described as fresh and flavorful with items such as pesto al basilico, fettuccine Alfredo, ravioli, and other house specialties, and the pizzas and arancini are often cited as standouts along with burrata bruschetta. The service is praised for friendliness and attentiveness, though there are occasional notes of slower pace or less consistent front of house during busy times, and a few visits mention noise level and large crowds. The ambience is described as chic yet comfortable, with a vibrant energy, warm bread with olive oil, and a solid wine and cocktail program that pairs well with meals, sometimes with lively terrace options. Some reviews point to minor drawbacks such as occasional heavy sauces, limited menu clarity on certain dishes, or accessibility concerns, but the consensus is that the restaurant delivers flavorful Italian fare in generous portions at good value, prompting repeat visits and recommendations to friends.View restaurant profile

Order

Il Miglio

Located on the main floor of the Hampton Inn.

(49)

Downtown, Golden Square Mile

Italian Pasta

Mentioned in: The Best Places to Eat Pasta in Montreal

Review Summary

Il Miglio receives mixed notes: the bolognese is fairly decent and pasta generally tastes good, with carbonara well prepared and salmon pasta described as excellent, while the tiramisu and truffle arancini also get praise. Some diners mention fast service and a busy market setting nearby, along with an appealing appetizer plate featuring beets marination and seeds with cheese. However, portions are sometimes small or perceived as overpriced, and the side focaccia can be dry and charged separately. A few critics call the way pasta is served in pieces a scam, and the prosciutto pizza is criticized for having hardly any prosciutto for the price. Overall, the restaurant is seen as delivering solid food and nice presentation in a Montreal market context, with a few consistency and value concerns across different visits.View restaurant profile

Tiramisu