Reviews of Jack Astor's consistently highlight a lively, welcoming atmosphere with big portions and a diverse menu that keeps many guests coming back. Service is frequently praised as friendly, attentive, and efficient, with staff going the extra mile on busy nights and helping guests navigate the menu. The food is generally well received, including favorites like burgers, chicken dishes, and shared plates, and the drinks and decor are noted positively. A few reviews raise concerns about slower service, occasional tepid or greasy dishes, high prices for the quality, and noise levels that make conversation challenging. Overall, the sentiment is that Jack Astor's is a reliable go to for casual gatherings, sports events, and celebrations, with many visits described as memorable due to the atmosphere and service. The consistency varies by night and location, but the common thread is that good service and a lively vibe are central to the experience.
Great experience at Jack Astor's! Our server was a true one-man army - super attentive, friendly, & always checking on us to make sure everything was perfect. The service really made our visit special. The pina colada was very good & refreshing. We also loved the garlic bread & nachos; they were absolutely delicious & full of flavor. Everything came out fresh & well prepared. I'll definitely be coming back & highly recommend this place!
Our waitress Zarah was very sweet. She made sure that she got our order right & checked in on us throughout the meal. You couldn't tell it was only her third shift.
Good service from Zarah food good value , steak , pasta chicken 2 drinks 2 coffees 1 dessert all in 155. One issue cutlery not properly cleaned handles were sticky . Time to upgrade the dishwashers .also there were nat like fruit flies all around table
Feb 15, 2026
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
We always enjoy eating at Jack Astors but this was a new location for us. Our server Zarah was amazing. She was kind & caring & her service was excellent
