Sel Noir Steakhouse : Savourez les meilleures coupes au cœur du Mille carré doré de Montréal. Offrez-vous nos steaks méticuleusement préparés, complétés par une carte des vins soignée, le tout dans une ambiance élégante qui définit l'art de la table.
Globalement, les avis sur Sel Noir Steakhouse soulignent une ambiance chaleureuse et élégante, un service excellent et des steaks qui sont souvent cuits à la perfection et savoureux. Les convives louent fréquemment les portions généreuses, les options de menu bien pensées et un programme de vins et de cocktails bien fourni, ce qui en fait une option idéale pour un rendez-vous, une célébration ou une soirée entre amis. Si l'expérience est globalement positive et que beaucoup décrivent l'atmosphère comme accueillante et le personnel comme sympathique et attentif, quelques visites signalent un service plus lent ou des incohérences dans l'assaisonnement ou la cuisson, et certains plats n'ont pas répondu aux attentes. Les réservations sont souvent recommandées et des plats comme le tomahawk ou le surf and turf retiennent l'attention, tout comme les desserts tels que le cheesecake qui reviennent fréquemment. Dans l'ensemble, Sel Noir se distingue comme une adresse de choix pour le steak à Montréal, pour ceux qui recherchent des pièces de qualité, une ambiance raffinée et une hospitalité fiable.
I've been coming to Sel Noir regularly & it never disappoints. The steaks are consistently on point, perfectly cooked, full of flavour, but honestly the mac & cheese deserves its own mention. Rich, indulgent, & the perfect companion to whatever cut you order. The drink menu is where they really surprise you though, unique cocktails you won't find just anywhere, & they're as well-crafted as the food. Add in attentive service that makes you feel like a regular & a vibe that's moody, lively, & just plain cool, & you've got a spot that's hard not to come back to. If you haven't been, go. If you have, you already know.
I had such a great experience here! The oysters were absolutely delicious, & my favourite dish of the night was the tuna tartare so fresh & full of flavour. The drinks were perfectly made &
We also loved our server, Gabriel he was attentive, friendly. I would definitely come back again!
16 févr. 2026
sur Google
🍽️
Sachez où manger à Montréal avant tout le monde.
Découvrez en primeur les ouvertures les plus branchées, des menus secrets et les coups de cœur de RestoMontreal.ca. Rejoignez plus de 50 000 foodies.
Had the surf & turf for 2. First off, service is great & attentive. 40oz tomahawk is flavorful, tender & juicy with a nice grilled taste. Shrimps are A1...overall great romantic experience & the quality to match it.
⭐?⭐? Very disappointing experience - extremely overpriced for what you get
We chose this place after reading mixed reviews & seeing the nice décor & downtown location. Unfortunately, our group visit (3 people) turned out to be one of the worst dining experiences we've had, especially considering the price 💸.
Let me start with the positives, because yes, there are some:
The location is great, easy access downtown 📍. The ambiance is calm & stylish, lighting is nice, & the bar looks beautiful 🍷. On paper, this place has potential.
But that's where the positives end.
🍽? Food & Portions
For a restaurant charging around $100 per person, the portion sizes are shockingly small. As you can clearly see in the photo, the meat portion is tiny-honestly, peanut-sized for that price. This is absolutely unacceptable.
They also cannot seriously claim this is Wagyu beef. We are not clueless customers. Anyone who knows meat can tell this is NOT Wagyu. Charging premium prices while misrepresenting quality is a huge red flag 🚩.
No sides included, everything is extra. No ketchup. No napkins. For a place positioning itself as upscale, this feels careless & lazy.
🧑?🍳 Service (Major Issue)
Service was very poor, similar to what other reviewers mentioned.
• Plates were taken away before we were finished
• Long waits just to get basic attention
• Staff chatting among themselves while customers waited
• No follow-up, no check-ins, no professionalism
At this price point, service should be polished & attentive. Instead, it felt rushed, disorganized, & indifferent 😒.
💰 Value for Money
This is the biggest issue.
The quality does NOT justify the price. Not even close.
Paying $100+ per person for:
• Tiny portions
• Average (at best) food
• Poor service
• Missing basics like napkins
…is simply unreasonable.
Other reviewers mentioned anniversaries, special occasions, & high tabs with minimal acknowledgment. We weren't even expecting anything special-but basic respect & service should be standard, not optional.
❌ Final Thoughts
This place tries to sell a luxury experience, but delivers mid-level food at luxury prices. Ambiance alone does not make a restaurant worth returning to.
Food: we ordered the Filet Mignon & Pan Roasted King Salmon. The Filet Mignon had no flavor, was brutally charred & not cooked properly. The Pan Roasted King Salmon had a strange texture & a bright orange sauce that didn't compliment the dish very well. For my drink, I ordered a Tanqueray & tonic; it was watered down & had barely any substance to it. The side of fries were decent.
Service: we had a female waitress who wasn't very attentive nor friendly. I noticed that she was very attentive & outgoing to the three other parties in the establishment, except for us; we were virtually ignored. We had to ask for water, straws, a steak knife; probably because we were tourists - so that tells you what you need to know.
Atmosphere: was very nice, I did like the interior, but the vibe of the waitstaff was… not good. The restaurant was empty & the waitstaff were just chillin around the bar, giving strange looks. The gentleman who greeted us & took our coats upon entering was very nice & welcoming, but it was unpleasant & downhill from that point forward.
As a restaurant owner myself, I highly recommend! Fantastic birthday dinner! Food was excellent, staff was attentive & friendly, perfect music. 10/10. Lovely for date night or girls night out.
Incredible food & ambience! The staff works so well together, & Desmond, the owner, is very attentive. Sel Noir made for an incredible anniversary evening for my wife & me. Strongly recommend!
3 mai 2025
sur Google
🍽️
Sachez où manger à Montréal avant tout le monde.
Découvrez en primeur les ouvertures les plus branchées, des menus secrets et les coups de cœur de RestoMontreal.ca. Rejoignez plus de 50 000 foodies.
The decor & lighting were good. I was surprised that the NY strip I ordered was sliced, & it was quite oily. The seasoning was uneven, but the cuisson was correctly done to medium as I had requested. The service started off well but lacked attentiveness toward the end.
I recently had the pleasure of dining at Sel Noir, & I must say, they truly redeemed themselves after a previous experience that didn't quite live up to expectations. This time, everything was flawless! We started with a octopus appetizer that was cooked to perfection-tender, flavorful, & beautifully presented. For the main course, I opted for the steak, which was cooked exactly as requested-juicy, tender, & packed with flavor. My wife had the filet mignon, & it was everything she had hoped for-mouthwatering & incredibly tender. To top off the meal, we indulged in a creamy crème brûlée with caramelized top & silky smooth custard. We also shared a delightful cookie with ice cream for dessert, which was the perfect sweet ending to an already amazing meal. The service was exceptional, attentive without being overbearing, & really made the experience feel special. It's clear that the staff at Sel Noir is committed to offering a top-tier dining experience, & I'm so glad we gave them another chance. Can't wait to return!
This hidden gem of a steakhouse offers an unforgettable dining experience. Tucked away in an intimate setting, the warm glow of candlelight & the inviting aroma of sizzling perfection set the tone. The steaks, especially the show-stopping tomahawk, are perfectly charred to seal in bold, rich flavors while remaining impossibly tender. The seafood offerings are equally exquisite, providing a luxurious complement to the star of the menu. The ambiance is cozy & romantic, perfect for special occasions or quiet evenings. With attentive, professional staff who elevate every detail, this isn't just a meal-it's an experience you'll savor long after it ends.
Amazing restaurant that checks all the boxes! The atmosphere is warm & inviting, with a perfect blend of modern decor & cozy ambiance. The staff are attentive, knowledgeable, receptive, friendly & so fun, & did a great job of guiding us through the menu, cocktails & wine list with genuine enthusiasm. The food is delicious. The wine list is fantastic. They also often have new desserts, which are all 10/10. Great spot for any occasion!!
13 oct. 2024
sur Google
🍽️
Sachez où manger à Montréal avant tout le monde.
Découvrez en primeur les ouvertures les plus branchées, des menus secrets et les coups de cœur de RestoMontreal.ca. Rejoignez plus de 50 000 foodies.
J'ai récemment passé une soirée au Sel Noir & c'était une expérience incroyable. L'ambiance est à la fois intime & accueillante, parfaite pour un souper mémorable. Les plats sont exquis, préparés avec soin & créativité, chaque bouchée est un vrai délice. Le service est impeccable, avec une équipe attentive & passionnée. Si vous cherchez un endroit pour savourer une cuisine raffinée dans une atmosphère agréable, je vous recommande vivement le Sel Noir!
One of the best meal experiences I have ever had! Jasmine was the best with the attentiveness & made the whole evening exceptional! The burrata was delicious...must order like many of the reviews suggest. I shared the surf & turf for 3 people & everything was perfectly cooked & seasoned to perfection! Tender lobster tail, steak cooked to the right temperature & the carrots were yummy! I will we back...one of my top 3 dining experiences for sure!
This restaurant definitely deserves 5 stars! The food was absolutely divine, the service was incredible & the atmosphere was perfect. The music was just at the right level for us to enjoy (i.e: we could have a conversation without having to yell to hear each other). I was there with a group of women & the staff was so kind, patient & attentive to us. The burrata was excellent & even though this is technically a steakhouse, I went for the gnocchi & was not disappointed at all - it was GOOD! The dessert of the moment was just the right touch to end the meal without being too heavy. Finally, given the disaster that is downtown Montréal for parking, I was very grateful that they offer valet service & happily took advantage of it! If you were on the fence about trying Sel Noir out, let this be your sign that you need to get yourself there asap! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
My experience at Sel Noir was beyond expectations! Food was excellent & flavourful! The staff is attentive & what can I say about the drinks? Absolutely divine!! I can't recommend it enough! An amazing steakhouse in Montreal! Cosy & nice atmosphere!! 5 ⭐️
8 juin 2024
sur Google
🍽️
Sachez où manger à Montréal avant tout le monde.
Découvrez en primeur les ouvertures les plus branchées, des menus secrets et les coups de cœur de RestoMontreal.ca. Rejoignez plus de 50 000 foodies.
Food was ok but not special. Filet mignon & carrots were good. Service was bad, slow & non attentive dessert never came... super long delays...... server was more busy doing shots at diffrent tables ... staff should be more focused... needs a bit of refining & training overall.
The Purple Haze is a delicious cocktail. My rib eye was wonderfully cooked, & it was excellently paired with the grilled mushrooms. My fiancee's filet mignon had an excellent crust, & was delightfully buttery. The staff were friendly attentive, & accommodating. Definitely a restaurant we will revisit. The restaurant could be slightly brighter, & the table was a little wobbly - or the top was warped. This is such a minor detail, & did not take away from the overall experience, but it is a detail that should not be overlooked.
If you're crossing from corner of Sherbrooke & Simpson don't miss this fantastic stake house. The atmosphere is unique , great service & amazing food. We had the NY steak & ribeye & both were fantastic. Cream brûlée was also great . Staff are very friendly & attentive. Overall, it's a must try!
