Gibby's

SUE-ELLEN

2.0

Montreal is known for its culinary excellence, our experience was far from it. On recommendation, we reserved. The location & ambience were lovely, we looked forward to the experience. I'm not sure what the problem was with our seating, there seemed to be ample space, however 2 waiters continuously bumped our chairs when going by, not just a few times but over & over. My husband ordered beef carpaccio to start, which they did not have. When it came to dessert, he ordered crème brûlée, which they didn't have either. My beef wellington boasted approximately 2 tbsp of duxelle, I took the pastry off because I found it hard to believe they would send it out of the kitchen like that & sure enough the duxelle was almost non-existent. We overheard the table next to ours order a second bottle of wine & were told there was no more of that brand, so they would have to order something else. It can also be noted that our server seemed to go out of his way to be rude. Each time I thanked him he would just walk away as I was speaking to him, he seemed unhappy that we were there. Not having ample product, repeatedly banging into customers & overall rude service, I have had a hard time choosing which steak house has been my favourite during our travels, Gibbys has made it very easy to determine which was the worst

Aldo

4.0

Food is amazing, & the quality of everything is supreme, however completely honest the service wasn't at the same level, it wasn't bad but it was a little bit unfriendly, really like this place & definitely will be back.

Maxime

5.0

Le steak a 79$ de 22oz était juste parfait prix goût toute est la!! belle endroit historique qui a une histoire

Otus

5.0

Great Steakhouse in a really nice old building

JP

4.0

Always great

Dark-Gray

5.0

Very beautiful restaurant with a higher class approach to a steak house

Junk

5.0

Very good steak house, great meat in fact the best place for steaks in the area. But the atmosphere is old antique. It needs a serious makeover apart from the steaks & lobsters there aren't many other option.

Tony

5.0

Definitely going back 🥩🍷❤️👍

Brandon

5.0

Excellent meal & amazing service, thanks!!!

Lewis

4.0

Clam chowder was great, salad was great, bread was great, asparagus was great, Monte Carlo potatoe was dry & lifeless, shrimp cocktail shrimps were poorly prepared (over cooked) - rubbery & tough.