Gibby's

Mel

1.0

I debated even writing this review, as I don't usually leave restaurant reviews-positive or negative.
I received a gift card to Gibby's for Christmas & was genuinely excited to return. The gift card was purchased over the phone & was ready for pickup at the time of our reservation, which went smoothly.
We were seated at a very tight table for two, with our chairs wedged between the backs of neighboring tables. While uncomfortable, we managed to settle in without disrupting other diners.
Shortly after, another couple was seated at the table beside us, requiring us to stand-with drinks in hand-to allow them access to their seats. Unfortunately, this became a recurring issue throughout the evening. Our server, Sebastian, repeatedly squeezed past us to pour water, take orders, & deliver food, frequently bumping into me without offering an apology.
The neighboring table eventually raised concerns about the lack of space & was reassigned, which once again required us to get up so they could exit. When salads, pickles, & bread arrived (all of which were very good), yet another table was seated nearby, & once again we had to interrupt our meal to let new diners through. Menus were passed over my head, & the repeated bumping continued. I was bumped well over a dozen times during the course of the meal without any acknowledgment.
For our mains, we ordered two Gibby's cuts cooked medium. They arrived medium rare. While not prepared as requested, the food was still enjoyable, & we chose not to send it back.
Overall, the food was solid. Unfortunately, the service left much to be desired.
When it came time to pay, I mentioned the gift card. Having served before, I had already calculated a 20% tip based on the full bill, not just the remaining balance after the gift card was applied. The gift card was processed, the remaining balance paid by debit, & the tip entered accordingly.
As I handed the payment machine back & said thank you, Sebastian tore off the receipt, tossed it onto the table, & walked away abruptly.
If a 20% tip is considered unsatisfactory, I would suggest checking in with guests shortly after their mains arrive, minimizing physical disruptions throughout the meal, & offering a simple'excuse me' or'sorry' when repeatedly bumping into diners.
Regardless of the tip amount, acknowledging & thanking guests is just good manners & what I would think is expected when you are representing a business.
While the food was good, Montreal has many excellent restaurants. At Gibby's price point, the overall experience matters just as much as the food-& unfortunately, this experience didn't feel worth it. I'm glad this was a gift card, & I'll be choosing a different restaurant to recommend or gift in the future.

10 janv. 2026

sur Google

Joshua

5.0

We had a wonderful time & truly enjoyed our experience at Gibbys. The food was excellent from start to finish, & Genevieve, our waitress, was fantastic very friendly, attentive, & made the evening even better! We highly recommend the Oyster Rockefeller, & you can't go wrong with the filet mignon or the beef Wellington.

9 janv. 2026

sur Google

Jeannie

5.0

We visited over the Christmas break as a group of six & had the most amazing time! The ambiance was incredible, so cozy & festive right before Christmas. Our waitress, Genevieve, was absolutely wonderful & took such great care of us. The food was outstanding, especially the escargots entrée, which was truly out of this world would recommend trying it. Genevieve also recommended fantastic wines that paired beautifully with our meal. Thank you so much for the warm hospitality & we will definitely be back!

6 janv. 2026

sur Google

Gam

5.0

Gibbys Restaurant is a Family Tradition every December 30th! We always enjoy the beautiful ambiance & great service! We recommend the Rib Eye Steak, Grilled Salmon, Platter of large Shrimp, Beef Wellington, Cornish Hen! The salads were delicious. A must try are Gibbys Monte Carlo potatoes! For dessert we all ordered the Chocolate Mousse, it was the perfect ending to our beautiful dinner!

31 déc. 2025

sur Google

Oscar

3.0

It came highly recommended by the Hotel Concierge, but the food was a bit disappointing, the lamb chops were severely overcooked; although they did replaced them.
I must say that the setting is absolutely beautiful & our Kasakh waiter was very nice & pleasant.

23 déc. 2025

sur Google

Kaz

2.0

Great location & atmosphere, but the service did not match the price. I made a simple birthday request for my wife in advance & confirmed it with the hostess, but it was never done. Meanwhile, another table received birthday service. Very disappointing experience-I would not return or recommend.

1 déc. 2025

sur Google

Michael

5.0

I had an exceptional dining experience at this steakhouse & can't recommend it enough! From start to finish, everything was top?notch.

Staff Highlights:
Mourad - Attentive, friendly, & always available when we needed anything. His professionalism made us feel truly welcome.
Yvon - Equally accommodating & courteous, Yvon ensured our dessert (Brazilian Coffee) ran smoothly & added a personal touch that set the tone for a wonderful evening.

Food: The dishes were absolutely delicious-each steak cooked to perfection, beautifully presented, & bursting with flavor. Every side & appetizer complemented the main courses wonderfully.

Overall, the combination of outstanding service from Mourad & Yvon, along with the superb cuisine, guarantees I'll be back soon. I wholeheartedly recommend this restaurant to friends, family, & coworkers alike.

29 nov. 2025

sur Google

Keith

5.0

Gibby's is one of the best places I've ever eaten at. Been there several times over many years. Never had a bad meal or bad service. Highly recommend.

28 nov. 2025

sur Google

TRoberts

5.0

A Truly Exceptional Dining Experience at Gibbys, Montréal

If you're visiting Montréal & looking for a dining experience that blends elegance, flavor, & outstanding service, Gibbys at 298 Pl. d'Youville is an absolute must-visit. From start to finish, everything about our evening was crafted to perfection.

The moment we sat down, we were welcomed with their signature pickles simple yet vibrant, the perfect way to activate our palates for what was to come. The appetizers set the tone for the night: the French onion soup was rich & deeply flavorful, the wedge salad is very fresh, & the beef carpaccio was delicate, & seasoned beautifully. Just when we thought it couldn't get better, they surprised us with a lemon sorbet palate cleanser that was refreshing & light.

The main courses were the highlight. Our steaks were cooked with absolute precision tender, juicy, & full of flavor. The potatoes paired perfectly, making each bite feel balanced & satisfying. & the finale, the Gibbons Delight dessert, was exceptional. It reminded us of a smooth, velvety chocolate mousse & was the perfect way to end the meal.

The cocktail menu here is just as impressive as the cuisine. Each drink was crafted with intention & flavor. Favorites from the night included the Steakhouse Martini Gibbys, Obsidienne Silhouette, Fraise Limoncello Spritz, & Le Nectar, all delicious, refreshing, & beautifully presented.

A special thank you to Benna, our server, who truly elevated our experience. Friendly, attentive, & knowledgeable, she made the night even more memorable.

Overall, Gibbys delivered an unforgettable experience. The cuisine, the cocktails, the atmosphere, & the service all came together seamlessly. I definitely recommend visiting this spot when in Montréal, you won't be disappointed.

26 nov. 2025

sur Google

Kevin

5.0

I went to Gibbys over the weekend & cannot recommend this restaurant enough. Klaude was my server for the evening & was attentive, kind, & took the time to happily answer all of my questions. The night started with delicious, warm bread & pickles. The clam chowder is some of the best I've ever had with a healthy amount of clams in every bite. I had a Gibbys salad & loved the house dressing. My entree consisted of the large Filet Mignon, a broiled lobster tail, & Monte Carlo potato with asparagus. The steak was cooked to perfection & I have never had a twice baked potato so incredibly delicious. The broiled lobster tail was in a class of its own. The dining room has exposed wood beams & has a very intimate & historic feel to it. I cannot recommend this place enough & will make it a point to go back. A perfect place to treat yourself to an incredibly delicious meal that you will never forget. Thank you again, Klaude & crew!

18 nov. 2025

sur Google

Mark

5.0

Wonderful meal at Gibby's this evening. It has been years since I was last there & I was happy to learn that the food, service & atmosphere were still at the same impeccable level as I remembered it. The Beef Wellington was superb as were the Cornish Game Hens. Our server Adib was nothing short of splendid. Cannot recommend Gibby's enough!

16 nov. 2025

sur Google

Kevin

5.0

A quintessential old school steakhouse. Our server Amin was amazing & the food was excellent. The Beef Wellington was cooked perfectly. Would definitely recommend & would return 10/10

4 nov. 2025

sur Google

Rachida

5.0

Jai vraiment apprécié l'expérience, c'était vraiment délicieux un beau mélange de saveurs & de textures qui ont réjoui mon palais, les serveurs sont chaleureux & très professionnel, c'est un endroit romantique & assez calme je recommande la salade pêches & burrata un vrai délice 🙂

4 nov. 2025

sur Google

Callum

5.0

A (now former) friend of mine tried to tell me that''The Keg' is just as good as Gibby's, if not better, so I asked him exactly what kind of drugs he's been smoking! VERY embarassing & SAD, Owen! I've had the crab cakes at Gibby's & I've had the crab cakes at'The Keg,' & let me tell you, it's not even remotely close! & that's without even mentioning the STEAKS!
Pre-appatizers: Before they even take your order they bring you pickles, bread, butter, bacon bits, etc -- now THAT is service! Everything in this category is excellent, be careful not to fill up on it.
Steaks: These are the best steaks in town, believe me! I recommend the wellington, 8oz tenderloin, & ribeye. Tremendous! Friend of mine had the rack of lamb & said it was wonderful.
Appateizers: Really recommend the burrata appatizer (served with fresh peaches, nice!), beef carpaccio, clam chowder, & the crab cakes. They bring you a green salad or wedge salad to start as well -- IMO these can be ommitted; good but not special. Once upon a time gaspacho was offered as well which was the BOMB! Unfortunately it's no longer part of the starter options which is regrettable indeed.
Fish/Chicken/Other Mistakes: If I wanted fish I'd go to a fish-house, not a steak-house. I mean, really? . . . anyways, the wife had the salmon or halibut or some non-steak item & really enjoyed it . . . she'll come around!
Sides: Monte Carlo Potato, sauteed mushrooms, whatever you like. Quality.
Dessert: Cheesecake with blueberry reduction . . . simply incredible! Ice cream . . . very nice! Chocolate Cake . . . elite!
Drinks: Many excellent wine choices. Whiskey Sour was no joke.
Prices: Very pricey IMO, special occasion type of spot. But, you know this going in & you certainly get what you pay for!
Overall: NO GIBBY'S SLANDER WILL BE TOLERATED! Gibby's is an institution in Montreal, & is somehow not universally hailed as the best place in town! Would love to see the gaspachpo make a return, but hey . . . whatcanyoudo?

3 nov. 2025

sur Google

Sabrina

5.0

We had such an amazing time at Gibbys! Our waiter Adib M gave us the best experience. He explained everything on the menu & was very knowledgeable on the items. He told us the history of the building & was everything a good waiter should be ! 10/10 would recommend!!!

2 nov. 2025

sur Google

Benjamin

5.0

Celebrated my birthday at Gibbys while in Montreal. Started with table bread, steak tartare & escargot. All delicious. Beef Wellington was one of the best I've had. Great service & ambiance as well. Highly recommended in you are in Old Montreal!

27 oct. 2025

sur Google

Paige

5.0

Best steak house in montreal. From the ambience to the service to the food, everything was spectacular. Our server, Luc, was amazing - so attentive & accommodating. 100/10 recommend !!!

26 oct. 2025

sur Google

Karine

3.0

Notre première visite était sous forme de date night & on nous a assis à côté de plusieurs groupes qui étaient bruyants. Nous comprenons cela mais peut être il aurait été judicieux de ne pas placer des tables de deux à côté des tables de 10. Cela dit, nous avions une réservation pour 20h30, & nous sentions que le service était essoufflé & laissait à désirer. Longue attente avant de prendre notre commande, verres d'eau qui restent vides. Jai commandé un Martini avec olives farcies au fromage bleu mais on m'a apporté le drink avec des olives avec noyaux sans explications ou excuses. Lorsque j'ai posé des questions à ce sujet, on m'a fait sentir comme si je devais accepter le drink bidon à 22$ sans dire un mot. Au prix payé pour le repas en général, je m'entendais à un service de plus attentionné & chaleureux. C'est comme si les tables avec les factures les plus élevées recevaient un meilleur service.Cela dit, le steak était très bon ainsi que la chaudrée de palourdes. Pour un repas similaire à meilleur prix & avec un meilleur service, je recommande The Keg.

26 oct. 2025

sur Google

Nerissa

5.0

A few people recommended trying Gibby's on our trip to Montreal. So glad we did the food was amazing & atmosphere was everything. Our server Adib was amazing. So warm & friendly & service was on point & efficient. Thanks for your attentiveness & great recommendations on things to try. Adib made our experience so much better more memorable. Definitely will be back!

12 oct. 2025

sur Google

Paul

5.0

While in Montreal on business. One of my coworkers from Calgary, who is originally from Montreal highly recommended we all go to Gibby's for dinner. It was a wonderful & absolutely wonderful experience. The restaurant was quite busy, which is apparently pretty common for this really popular restaurant. Initially they sat us in a lounge area upstairs, where we enjoyed a couple of appetizers & some drinks & were served by the most wonderful server imaginable. We all Loved her.
When we were finally brought downstairs to eat, we enjoyed an unbelievable dinner & some great wine selections. I would highly recommend this restaurant if you are ever in Montreal. Not to be taken lightly. This is a high-end restaurant with high-end quality, food, & wines.
But the staff was over-the-top professional, & we loved every moment of it.
Paul
Calgary

27 sept. 2025

sur Google