Gibby's

Scott

5.0

Great place. Perfect beef Wellington.

Chantelle

2.0

Food was overrated, my peppercorn steak was dry & the Beef Wellington was overcooked & hard on the outside-none of it melted in your mouth. The wedge was just a massive piece of iceberg lettuce that we sent back because it tasted terrible. The potatoes were disappointing too. Worst fine dining meal I've ever tasted. The only good things was that the cocktails were tasty, & our server was so kind. But the kitchen needs some serious training on how to cook meat, because what they served was embarrassing & shouldn't have even left the kitchen.

Petros

5.0

Wow, simply wow!
This place is withstanding time.
From the valet to the dessert, I give this place 10 on 10.
Beef Wellington was cooked to perfection.
Gibby's is a must try if you're in Montreal looking for a steakhouse.
Definitely going back

Jessica

5.0

Went to Gibby's as a group of four. The food & service were impeccable. Our waitress Genevieve was charismatic, & made great recommendations. She ensured to accommodate dietary restrictions, which was very important to us. She also explained the Gibby's classics to us, which was a nice touch.

The food was excellent. To my knowledge Gibby's is one of only two restaurants in Montreal where you can get beef wellington. I've been to the other restaurant too, & I must say that Gibby's is well worth the expense. Although both are excellent, Gibby's has a ton of sides included, & it makes the price worth it for sure. The portions are also generous where you are actually leaving feeling full without having to break the bank.

For Atmosphere I gave four stars as we were sat at a round table for 5 instead of four, which made it hard to share plates & it felt like we were screaming across each other. The table was also right in the waitstaff's path, & at one point a full table was lifted overhead. Otherwise it was a fine atmosphere!

Lorne

1.0

The food is not the same as when the Rosenbergs where operating.
the beef is LOW grade!

ANTHONY

2.0

We do fine dining & we appreciate good food. Except for the valet parking for free gratuity not included the experience at Gibbys is below expectation . being from the USA from Florida where the best of the best in steak houses like New York prime Ruth Christ capital gril the Oakes etc etc etc gibbys as a steak house is disappointing .the pickles were so average coming from a canned jar the bread was below average the beef Wellington had a thick crust not fluffy & well prepared like st hell kitchen at a Gordon Ramsey restaurant & the steak au poivre was way below average.the steak was below average & the sauce was terrible .the potato Monaco was nothing to be proud of . The pricing was too expensive for the quality .the atmosphere is ok but dark & unattractive . So if you are looking for a steak culinary experience in Montreal again Moshe's is the only place that falls at the lower end of average compared to the great state of Florida .& the taxes on the food is unreal .sorry Montreal but getting worse & worse 🥲🥲🥲❤?

Brad

5.0

Went for Lunch, was extremely satisfied, price was great for what they offer. They offered bread & a pickle to start. We ordered Tartare & Rockefeller both were great, the Pepper Steak was amazing, Steak was seasoned well but still beefy & the sauce was delicious. The asparagus was also seasoned well & cooked well. The Lamb was lamb, it didnt wow me compared to the steak. They offered a small refreshing sorbet after your appetizers. For dessert we had a chocolate cake that was a bit decadent for my taste but it had great crispy texture on the bottom, still solid.

Scoot

5.0

Exceptional food! Outstanding service! Diane, our server again this year, 100% attentive to our needs & extremely personable. Gibby's & their Beef Wellington are worth the trip from Toronto every Birthday. In my opinion, the best restaurant in Old Montreal.

Griff

5.0

The most delicious Beef Wellington, & the kindest staff! You will certainly have the meal of your life here.

Jeremy

5.0

The beef wellington was excellent!