Best Pizza Restaurants in Old Montreal (2026) - Reviews & Menus

Restaurant Jacques-Cartier - Pizza Restaurants in Old Montreal

Restaurant Jacques-Cartier

May be temporarily closed

Old Montreal

Review Summary

Visitors describe Jacques-Cartier as a place where meals arrive hot and on time, ingredients feel fresh, and the atmosphere stays relaxed and welcoming, with attentive, friendly service that keeps pace even when busy. The menu at Jacques-Cartier covers seafood highlights like seafood spaghetti, mussels and fries, and lobster, along with crowd pleasing pizzas and simple, well balanced pastas and steaks, all prepared with clear flavors and solid textures. The overall impression is consistent quality, good value, and a warm, lively vibe that makes Jacques-Cartier a dependable favorite for casual meals with family or friends.View restaurant profile

Terrasse Jacques-Cartier - Pizza Restaurants in Old Montreal

Terrasse Jacques-Cartier

May be temporarily closed

(208)

Old Montreal

Comfort Food Burgers Poutine Pizza Grill Salads

Review Summary

Across reviews of Terrasse Jacques-Cartier, guests celebrate a lively terrace, a central location, and reliable, flavorful dishes ranging from smoked meat poutine and sandwiches to burgers and seafood, all with fresh ingredients and generous portions; service is consistently friendly and efficient, with attentive staff and smooth timing even on busy days, while the vibrant yet welcoming ambiance and street view make it easy to linger for a casual lunch or evening drinks with friends.View restaurant profile

Bevo Pizzeria

The best wood-fired pizza in Montreal!

Opens Today at 11:30 am

(953)

Old Montreal

Pizza Italian Pasta Pizzeria

Mentioned in: Burrata: The Fanciest Cheese and Where to Taste it in Montreal Best Venues for a Christmas Party in Montreal 2025 View More

Review Summary

Bevo Pizzeria stands out in Old Montreal for a warm, inviting atmosphere and wood fired, thin crust pizzas with fresh toppings, complemented by arancini, pastas and a creative drinks menu. Reviewers consistently praise fast, attentive service and genuine hospitality, with staff offering thoughtful recommendations and making guests feel welcome. The vibe is versatile, from cozy corners to lively spaces and a terrace, all crafted to enhance a relaxed Italian dining experience. Quality and value are frequently highlighted, with many noting flavorful dishes, generous portions, and well balanced sauces and toppings. While a few notes mention occasional timing during busy periods, the overall impression is a memorable, satisfying visit that keeps guests returning.View restaurant profile

Pizzeria Moretti

Opens Today at 5 pm

(102)

Old Montreal

Italian Pizza Pasta Afghan

Review Summary

At Pizzeria Moretti, reviews describe a lively, welcoming atmosphere with attentive service and a focus on creating a memorable dining experience, especially for romantic occasions. Pizzas and Italian staples are repeatedly praised for flavor, and drinks like espresso martinis are highlighted as well. While many note smooth service, a few experiences mention kitchen delays and uneven table service. The vibe and terrace are a strong draw, with music described as fun but sometimes too loud for a quiet dinner, leading some to plan return visits for future occasions. In short, Pizzeria Moretti delivers solid Italian fare and hospitality, with room to improve music balance and consistency.View restaurant profile

Order

Benedetta

Café | Jardin + Bar | Restaurant

Opens Today at 11 am

(105)

Old Montreal

Bar Café Pizza

Review Summary

Across the reviews, Benedetta comes across as a warm, stylish spot in the Old Port with a charming courtyard and a vibe that blends trendy and inviting. The food is repeatedly described as delicious, with standout pastas, pizzas, paninis, and Italian inspired dishes, all made with fresh ingredients and thoughtful flavor balance. Cocktails and espresso drinks receive high marks, and the speakeasy downstairs adds extra charm to the evenings. Service is cited as professional, friendly, and attentive, with several mentions of staff going above and beyond, though a few notes point to occasional slow or crowded service during peak times. The experience is praised for its atmosphere, music, and overall value, and many say it’s a reliable spot for brunch, lunch, or a night out with friends or a date. Benedetta is seen as a gem in Montreal’s Old Port, consistently delivering great food, great drinks, and a memorable setting, with guests already planning return visits.View restaurant profile

Comptoir 400

Open until 11:30 pm

(314)

Old Montreal

Pizza Salads Pastries Café Ice Cream

Review Summary

Comptoir 400 comes across as a lively Old Port spot with a pleasant terrace and a mix of solid dishes and variable service, where reviewers praise the location, atmosphere and flavors in items like mussels, poutine, pizza, burgers and fish, while noting that portions and prices can be inconsistent and some dishes arrive cold or underseasoned. The menu spans seafood, mains and shareables, with several mentions of bruschetta, salads and the arugula pizza as standouts, though a few experiences describe slower service, slow drink refills and uneven attention from staff. The ambiance is repeatedly described as warm and welcoming, making it a good casual option for families, groups or a relaxed dinner, especially outdoors, but timing can suffer during peak hours and some visits feel rushed. Overall, Comptoir 400 is seen as a worthwhile stop for a tasty, location-driven meal with friendly service, yet guests should temper expectations about consistency across visits.View restaurant profile

Order

Paradiso

Opens Today at 11:30 am

(25)

Old Montreal

Pizza Burgers Pasta Salads

Review Summary

Paradiso elicits a mixed bag of reviews, with some diners calling the pizza mediocre and the calamari frozen and hardly memorable, while others praise a vegetarian pizza, pasta fettuccine bolognaise, and a crisp Chardonnay served in a lively vibe with disco soundtrack. The location is described as convenient, and several notes mention a pleasant atmosphere, yet some visits are marked by slow service and food that feels like frozen fare, leading to concerns about value for money in a tourist area. Fast and friendly service and a standout tiramisu appear in positive reports, whereas a few parties felt the bill was excessive and hard to justify, especially when ordering meals with drinks. A winter Saturday visit is described as quiet, contrasting with busier nights. Overall, Paradiso is seen as inconsistent, delivering moments of tasty dishes and good service but also experiences of high prices and uneven quality.View restaurant profile

Balboa

Opens Today at 5 pm

(107)

Old Montreal

Pizza Pasta Italian

Review Summary

Balboa in Old Montreal offers Italian fare anchored by wood-fired pizzas with a standout organic sourdough crust, complemented by pasta, antipasti, and desserts that many reviews call delicious. The ambiance is repeatedly described as beautiful and inviting, providing a lively yet intimate backdrop for casual nights out or dates. Service is praised for being attentive and friendly, and the cocktails and wine list receive positive mentions, though several visits note slow or inconsistent service and long waits for drinks or dishes at busy times. The pizza is often the star, with reviewers praising the crust and toppings as among the best in town, while a few say the price is high for the value and some pizzas do not rise above the ordinary. Dishes such as fungi pasta and arancini are highlighted as excellent, whereas some patrons found the bolognese or certain plates underwhelming. Overall the place is seen as a stylish and reliable destination in the area that delivers strong pizza and atmosphere, with many diners planning to return to try more of the menu.View restaurant profile

Order

Slice + Soda

Opens Today at 11 am

(497)

Old Montreal

Pizza Italian

Mentioned in: Where to Find Cheap Eats in Montreal The Best Spots in Montreal for Takeout and Delivery Meals Under $20 View More

Review Summary

Slice + Soda is widely praised for giant, affordable slices with a thin, crispy crust and fresh toppings that give a New York style feel in a compact, welcoming space. Reviewers note that the slices are big, fast to serve, and often satisfying as a quick bite, with classic and creative toppings like pepperoni, Margherita, veggie, carnivore, prosciutto, and a Caesar salad pairing complementing the pizza. The crust is described as airy yet crisp with a balanced sauce, and some add olive oil or chili flakes for extra kick. The open kitchen and casual, cozy ambiance, sometimes with a communal table, contribute to a neighborhood vibe that many enjoy, while seating can be limited and lines can get long on busy nights. Service is usually friendly and efficient, though a few visits mention variability in product quality or dish availability, such as reduced toppings on a later visit. Diners frequently note the value, with large slices for a reasonable price, and some call it the best pizza in Montreal or a must try, particularly for a quick meal in Old Montreal. Overall, Slice + Soda comes across as a reliable go to for a tasty, satisfyingly sized slice that pairs well with sodas and a casual, lively atmosphere.View restaurant profile

Order

Pizzeria Bros

Opens Today at 11 am

(395)

Old Montreal, Downtown

Pizza Salads

Review Summary

Reviews describe Pizzeria Bros as a fast, friendly spot with very good value and a wide, customizable pizza menu that includes gluten free crust and vegan cheese options, halal pizzas, and crowd favorites like Aloha, Sorrento, Veggie Delight and Garden; many diners note pizzas are prepared fresh and often in front of guests, with a thin crust and a wood fired feel highlighted, and service described as quick and cheerful; the atmosphere is described as cozy and welcoming, though a few visits mention cramped seating, occasional smoke in the dining area, or minor issues like a slippery floor step; several remarks praise attentive staff, helpful recommendations and overall pleasant vibes, making it a reliable quick bite and a place people are eager to return to; while a couple of reviews point to drawbacks such as overcooked crust, a slightly oily finish or occasional air quality concerns, the overall tone is positive with many saying they would come back and would recommend it to friends.View restaurant profile

Order

Pizzéria NO.900

Opens Today at 11:30 am

(689)

Old Montreal

Pizza Pizzeria Italian Gluten-free Options

Mentioned in: Exploring Quebec City's Pizzerias: Our Recommendations 19 Must-Try Food Trucks in Montreal for a True Street Food Experience View More

Review Summary

Reviews of Pizzéria NO.900 mix high praise for the pizza itself with comments on a light, chewy Neapolitan crust, fresh sauce, and flavorful toppings that some call the best in the city, along with strong notes on gluten free options and a few standout entrées like burrata and arancini. The atmosphere is described as warm and intimate, though space is tight and can feel crowded or noisy, and a few visits mention heat or cold in the dining area. Service quality varies widely, from fast, friendly, and attentive to slow or understaffed on busy nights, with some pizzas arriving late or cold and occasionally a mistake such as a missing topping. Value and portioning yield mixed reviews, with many finding prices reasonable and portions fair while others feel toppings could be more generous or a burrata pie overpriced. Overall the pizza and vibe draw repeat visits, but potential diners should be prepared for inconsistent service and space constraints, and reservations or off peak timing is advised.View restaurant profile

Ugo Pizzeria

Opens Today at 10 am

(112)

Old Montreal

Pizza Salads

Review Summary

Ugo Pizzeria is praised for delicious pizzas made with quality ingredients and a crust that is light and fluffy yet crisp on the outside. Generous slices and a menu that includes sandwiches and focaccia style squares, along with house salads and cookies, are frequent highlights. The staff are consistently described as friendly, fast and attentive, creating a cozy and welcoming vibe. The pizza is often noted as flavorful and well cooked, with a crust that can be thick yet tender inside. Prices are seen as a bit high by some, but many feel the taste and overall experience justify it. Occasional comments mention hours not always matching posted times, leading to disappointment when doors close early. Catering options are available and well received, and many reviewers say they would return or would happily recommend Ugo Pizzeria to others.View restaurant profile

Order

Restaurant Solana

Opens Today at 4 pm

(54)

Old Montreal

Mediterranean Pizza Tartare Salads Burgers Fusion

Review Summary

Solana receives high marks for warm, attentive service and a welcoming atmosphere that suits both terrace dining and a cozy indoor setting, with staff noted for being professional and accommodating. The menu offers a wide range of options, including vegetarian dishes, pizzas, seafood, and skewers, with lamb and chicken cooked to perfection and many dishes described as tasty and well prepared. Dishes such as salmon, seafood linguine, mussels, large shrimp, and a satisfying quinoa salad are highlighted, along with crowd pleasers like a chicken burger, all described as good value for the area. The atmosphere is modern and friendly, with outdoor seating, occasional street performances, and a pet friendly policy that makes it easy to dine with dogs. Overall Solana emerges as a reliable favorite in the Old Port, frequently recommended and noted for returning to try more dishes.View restaurant profile

Order

Trattoria Gio

Opens Today at 12 pm

(327)

Old Montreal

Italian Pasta Pizza Grill Salads

Mentioned in: On the Hunt for Montreal's Best Cannoli

Review Summary

Overall, reviews of Trattoria Gio describe a welcoming spot with solid Italian fare and a lively Old Port ambiance, where many diners praise flavorful pizzas, pastas, and desserts and note friendly, attentive service when it runs well. The kitchen is credited with well prepared dishes like pasta and braised meats, and the atmosphere and value are frequently highlighted. At times, however, service is described as slow, disorganized, or inconsistent, with delays in seating, taking orders, or delivering courses and occasional order mix ups, and a few dishes arriving too salty or not as hot as hoped. When issues arise, staff or management are described as making efforts to rectify things, and many guests say they would return for the food and overall experience. In sum, Trattoria Gio is regarded as a solid, enjoyable option with strong flavors and a pleasant vibe, though service experiences can vary.View restaurant profile

Order

New

Pizza Welly's

May be temporarily closed

Old Montreal

Pizza

La Cave à Manger

Open until 8 pm

(518)

Old Montreal

Bakery Desserts & Sweets Sandwiches Pizza Pastries

Mentioned in: The Best Croissants in Montreal: Our Top Picks The Best Festive Drinks in Montreal: Hot Chocolates, Lattes, and Holiday Sips to Try This Season View More

Review Summary

La Cave à Manger is a tiny yet highly praised bakery tucked into Old Montreal with a cozy, intimate vibe and a small seating area, where pastries are repeatedly described as flaky, buttery and addictive. Standouts include the pistachio roll, croissant eclairs, croissants and the tiramisu croissant roll, along with beloved bagels and ham and cheese croissant, and the space often earns praise for its breads and creative offerings; the pistachio croissant and red velvet croissant are frequently cited as among the best in town. The service is consistently friendly and attentive, with staff going the extra mile, though some notes mention prices being on the high side for the portions and occasional inconsistencies in flavor. The space is small and sometimes crowded, with outdoor seating in good weather, and the basement location adds rustic charm. Overall, La Cave à Manger stands out as a must visit for pastry lovers in the Old Port, delivering high quality baked goods and a welcoming atmosphere, with many reviewers already planning a return.View restaurant profile

Order

La Baraque du Vieux St-Vincent

Opens Today at 11 am

(88)

Old Montreal

Pub Food Burgers Pizza Grill Sandwiches Poutine

Review Summary

Reviewers describe La Baraque du Vieux St-Vincent as a cozy, welcoming spot in Old Montréal where friendly service and a warm atmosphere stand out. The menu centers on comforting classics like smoked meat and poutine, with the smoked meat club sandwich and a well made hamburger noted by several diners. Fries are praised as fresh and crispy, and the accompanying gravy and sauces earn glowing remarks. Some find the food good value even if a few think prices run a bit high for what is served. The setting is versatile, great for a quick lunch, casual drinks, watching a game, or a family outing, with an attentive staff that makes guests feel at home. Guests also appreciate the staff willingness to accommodate requests and the overall sense of hospitality. The ambiance is cozy and relaxed, though at times the spot can feel touristy depending on the season, and the experience centers on classic comfort food in a friendly neighborhood vibe. Pets are welcome in the summer and the patio is an inviting option when weather allows. Overall, the smoked meat and warm service create a dependable, satisfying visit for many patrons.View restaurant profile

Osteria Schiavio

Opens Today at 11:30 am

(218)

Downtown, Old Montreal

Italian Pizza Pasta

Review Summary

Patrons describe Osteria Schiavio as a warm, authentic Italian spot in downtown Montreal with homemade pasta and fresh ingredients across a menu that pairs lasagna, gnocchi, and tuffoli with pizzas and desserts like tiramisu and pistachio cannoli. The atmosphere is commonly praised as cozy and inviting, with nice Italian charm, good music, and an indoor terrace that adds to the experience. Service is repeatedly highlighted as attentive and friendly, with staff known for helpful recommendations and thoughtful touches. Prices are generally considered reasonable for the location, and many say they would return to try more dishes or for a date or family outing. A few caveats include occasional slower service on busy game nights and occasional menu misses such as a margarita pizza that lacks basil or portions that feel small for the price, but the overall impression is of high quality Italian cooking and a welcoming, reliable spot.View restaurant profile

Reserve

Al Pizzetta

Opens Today at 11:30 am

(142)

Old Montreal

Italian Pizza

Review Summary

Overall, reviews convey a mix of highs and lows at Al Pizzetta. Pizzas are repeatedly praised, especially the Margherita and certain mushroom varieties, with some diners calling the crust tasty and the toppings fresh, while others find some pizza bland or overpriced for the area. Pasta dishes such as carbonara and fettuccine Alfredo receive strong praise when executed well, though a few meals veer toward bland or not tasting traditional, and one reviewer notes a pasta that did not taste like Bolognese. Appetizers like calamari and bruschetta are highlighted for flavor, and the dining setup, including a terrace, is appreciated by those who dine al fresco. Service is described as attentive in some visits and brisk in others, but generally friendly. The overall impression is that Al Pizzetta can deliver authentic, satisfying Italian flavors for a casual meal, but consistency and value seem to vary by visit and personal expectations.View restaurant profile