Stellina is widely praised for delicious Italian cooking and attentive service, with many tasting menus and pasta described as outstanding, fresh handmade noodles and well balanced flavors, and the open kitchen adds a showy and engaging touch; the atmosphere is warm and lively, and the staff are friendly and professional, making visits memorable, especially for date nights or small gatherings, with tiramisu and burrata frequently highlighted as standout items; however several reviews flag small portions, high prices, a limited menu, and occasional inconsistencies such as undercooked pasta or over salted dishes, and some noise and a few service hiccups during busy times; overall Stellina is seen as a strong, must try Italian option in the city, delivering quality pasta and memorable dining experiences even as some visits feel rushed or pricey.
Juste des bon mots pour de l'excellente nourriture! Frais fait devant nous, nous étions au comptoir je recommande, excellent service également, employé & management efficace, courtois & polis.
Nicolas & the entire staff provided impeccable service & exquisite attention to detail! The wine selection is extensive, & every dish we tried was flavorful, well-textured, & thoughtfully prepared. Our experience truly surpassed all expectations. We'll definitely be back & won't hesitate to recommend it to family & friends.
I am writing this review quite late, as my visit was about a year & a half ago, so things may have changed since then. Based on my experience, however, this was one of the worst restaurants I have been to in Montreal.
The pasta was not properly cooked, & our orders were mixed up. I asked for no bacon, yet my husband received the bacon free dish instead. We were also charged for bread, which is almost unheard of in an Italian restaurant.
Prices were extremely high for what was offered. With two pasta dishes & one or two appetizers, the bill was easily around 200 dollars. The only reason I am giving two stars is the location. The Old Port is beautiful, but I would recommend trying other restaurants instead.
The food is incredible, I highly recommend the bone marrow. We had 4 different pasta dishes at our table & this was the best one. The service however, was noticeably off & you can just tell they have communication issues between staff.
The food runners were amazing, but they did not know much about our food, & what was what, lol. They just brought the dishes out & you can tell the servers don't talk to them much, so hard to order through them. They were great though.
We weren't checked one once during our main course, which was really unfortunate because we wanted to order wine with our pasta, finally our server came once we were all pretty much done. After that we weren't checked in on again, & we wanted to order dessert. We flagged our server down (again) to ask for a dessert menu, which she just handed to us, & didnt say anything. Finally when she returned, we ordered one of the desserts (there's only 4, which is fine) & she said they were all out! It's like damn, why not say that as you deliver it. It would have been nice to have been talked to more & considered during our meal. Maybe it wasn't her day, we all have off days, but we left as a result & ended up going to Monarch a few doors down & the difference in service was night & day!
Had a great experience at Stellina for my friends birthday they were very accommodating in moving our reservation to adjust for timing. The service was great, the staff was super friendly. Our food was outstanding. The espresso martini are a must try!! Would recommend
Dec 14, 2025
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
The food is delicious, the best pasta in Montreal.
I recommend the tiramisu & the crudo.
The service is attentive at all times & very friendly. It's a shame that the noise is so loud that it's difficult to talk. But none of that matters because the flavour is exceptional.
The food was okay for what it was. The octopus had 3 pieces on the plate. Portions way too small for the price. It's a beautiful location with food that's alright but I wouldn't recommend coming here, as within a 5-10 minute walk you can find a much better restaurant, spend the same money & actually leave full.
Nourriture excellente! C'est vraiment l'endroit pour manger de bonnes pâtes fraîches. Carte très simple, ambiance bistro, un peu écho, mais très chouette. Prix abordable pour la qualité de nourriture. Essayez le menu découverte, ça vaut la peine d'essayer un peu tout! Je recommande 😊
Oct 19, 2025
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
I loved Stellina. I am extremely picky with Italian food considering I lived there for an extended period & therefore struggle to find good Italian food outside Italy. I loved that many people in the kitchen were actually speaking Italian, which made me feel like they knew what they were doing, as the cooks & chef themselves were from there. The food was absolutely amazing also. I recommend the tarta di cipolla, pappardelle, tagliatelle al ragù & the crudo entree. I must say that that texture of the panna cotta was not good. It was like a pudding rather than the true flan-esque texture of an authentic italian panna cotta. The taste however was nice. Amazing experience. I will return. Grazie
I had an amazing experience with my girlfriend. We are people trying a bunch of restaurants & I gotta say that we had a very good experience here. Everything from the start to the end was perfect. Fresh products, great wine & a very good service from Stephen & Gabriel. I definitely recommend this place !
I keep coming to this place because its simply amazing. The Changing menu always slaps. If you get the tasting menu you really get to taste their best that they have. GET the focaccia with the prosciutto butter, it is simply devine! Ill keep going again & again. Definitely recommend for date & more
Nous avons eu la chance d'essayer le menu découverte & ce fut une expérience absolument parfaite. Chaque plat était préparé avec soin, les saveurs étaient à la fois surprenantes & parfaitement équilibrées. Une cuisine italienne en finesse & gourmande. & que dire du service de Tess 12/10! Je recommande fortement!
Aug 4, 2025
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
OMG!! What a Great Experience!
From the moment we walked in, we knew we were in for something special. We were lucky enough to sit right in front of the open kitchen-it felt like the Italian version of Teppanyaki, & it was absolutely captivating!
Watching the chefs in action was a show in itself. Each one was incredibly talented, kind, & passionate about their craft. They not only delivered outstanding Italian dishes, but they also brought so much energy & heart to the experience. Every plate was a masterpiece-flavorful, fresh, & perfectly presented.
Highly recommend grabbing a seat near the kitchen if you can-it adds a whole new layer of enjoyment. We'll definitely be coming back! Bravo to the whole team! 👏🍝🔥
Dinner at Stellina was truly enjoyable. The service was exceptional-professional, warm, & clearly experienced. The staff made us feel welcome & taken care of throughout the evening.
The pasta was outstanding, full of flavor & perfectly cooked. We also loved the fresh bread & well-crafted drinks that complemented the meal nicely. But the real standout was the tiramisu. It was recommended to us, & I'm so glad we took that advice-it was absolutely divine & the perfect way to end the meal.
Stellina is a great spot for anyone who appreciates quality Italian food, thoughtful service, & a cozy, elevated dining atmosphere. Highly recommended!
Always have a great time at Stellina.
The food is delicious, the ambiance is warm & inviting, & the staff is lovely. I often come here to relax after work, but it's also a perfect spot for a cozy date night. I especially loved their burrata & pasta so fresh & flavorful. The dishes also came out quickly, which I really appreciated.
I'm giving 4 stars only because the beef/meat dishes aren't quite to my taste, but that's just personal preference. Overall, I really enjoy this restaurant & highly recommend it :)
I only have good things to say about this place. It can often be a hit or miss with new Italian restaurants opening in the city since the MTL market is super saturated with them. We had a prior reservation at Dinette Marcella, which failed due to a reservation error on their end. We were able to secure a table at the Chef's bar at Stellina rapidly & without fuss. We were well greeted, & the service was super professional. The ambiance was lively, & our food was well-prepared & delicious. I would highly recommend it for anyone looking for high-quality pasta in a more upscale environment. Perfect for dates, groups or even solo dining. Keep up the great work, guys.
