Gibby's

Cindy

5.0

While this feels like a traditional steakhouse, they pay attention to every detail. Our service was wonderful & from the Gibby's salad to the seasonal cheesecake the food & cocktails were wonderful. You could also feel the history of the building. Highly recommend.

James

3.0

For the price you pay for the meal you'd expect much better service. Not that our waitress was slow it just that she had too many tables to take care of
They need to hire more staff. I was disappointed in the overall experience, coming from Texas, I was told it was a finest steakhouse in Old Montreal but I didn't think so.

Matt

5.0

Been to Montreal twice over my years & have now visited Gibbys twice. Worth the visit, very enjoyable experience. Beautiful building, great history, fantastic service & exceptional steak - my wife & I had a fantastic time, thank you!

Marv

5.0

Really good. If you don't like a heavily seasoned steak then dont get the seasoning & garlic on top the steak!

Jmac1066

5.0

Truly a magnificent experience. This is one of the oldest & well respected steakhouses in Montreal. No real dress code but wear the best outfit you have. Filet mignon was succulent but really it's impossible to make a bad choice here. It's not cheap but given the caliber of the restaurant it's appropriate. Besides they treat you like a member of the aristocracy!

C

5.0

Excellent old school steakhouse. They were very busy & possibly a little understaffed but the service was still excellent. Steak was delicious & expertly prepared. Wedge salad among the best I've ever had. Only criticism would be the veggies included with the meal were very sparse. Great wine list with a few reasonably priced gems available. If you want the classic steakhouse experience this is it.

Mike

4.0

We are here on holiday & wanted a special occasion restaurant for the trip & our anniversary. We arrived a little early but no issue & we were given a table for two at the back next to one of the serving desks. Started with a great house martini & enormous pickles, bread etc. We both ordered shrimps & fillet mignon. Shrimps were lovely - sweet & juicy, although interesting that they were sourced from India rather than the Canadian variety. Mains were so so. We ordered our meat medium & they came with a nice bark on them but were definitely on the done side of medium. Wine was good although got the feeling that even though I was getting a good bottle, I was being pushed for something more expensive.

Being near the serving end of things we definitely got to see & hear a lot more than we would have liked, especially relating to the'management' of the more junior staff. Not professional. Other downer for me was that as we were finishing out dessert, our waiter summarily slapped the bill down on our table (we had not requested it & the restaurant was not full & we had not been slow). I expressed surprise & said I was hoping to have an Irish coffee, so the bill was withdrawn & service resumed.

Overall, a lovely setting, regular luxury steak house but I have had better for less.

Sylvie

2.0

Gibbys n'est plus ce que c'était que nous croyons … nous avions des amis de l'extérieur il y a deux semaines & nous avions décidé de réserver au Gibbys pour une valeur assurée… hey bien non la viande était de piètre qualité dont nous n'avons jamais vu dans le passé… j'ai aussi dû retourner mon steak car la cuisson n'était pas ce que j'avais demandé… nous étions très déçus pour nos invités… on ne pense pas retourner … & pourtant nous sommes des habitués du Gibbys !!!

Steven

5.0

The steak was so good here & I'd rather go here than the Keg. I think prices are reasonable for a steakhouse to be honest. & I loved the bread & apps they served for free. You will not leave hungry.

Lisa

5.0

Service was top notch. Pacing of the meal was perfect. We didn't feel rushed. Food was all you would expect from a long standing traditional steakhouse. The Beef Wellington was perfectly seasoned. We dined indoors which was cozy. The outdoor terrace looked quite inviting as well.