Siamo Noi delivers an authentic exploration of Italian culinary traditions centered on the artistry of handmade pasta. The menu showcases regional techniques that elevate basic semolina and flour into refined plates of perfectly al dente noodles. Every dish emphasizes fresh ingredients and balanced profiles, ranging from robust tomato-based sauces to delicate herb-infused oils. Diners seeking dietary accommodations find a reliable selection of high-quality gluten-free pasta options that retain traditional textures. The atmosphere reflects a focused approach to food preparation, prioritizing clear flavors and structural integrity in every serving. This establishment maintains a commitment to the foundational elements of Italian kitchen culture by providing consistent, well-executed staples for every visitor. Each plate demonstrates a functional approach to flavor through precise seasoning and carefully sourced seasonal produce.
Siamo Noi offers a vibrant and stylish dining experience that frequently earns praise for its high-quality, authentic Italian cuisine and impeccable tableside tiramisu preparation. Many guests are particularly impressed by the professional and attentive service, which often elevates their overall visit. However, the restaurant frequently experiences a very high noise level, which some diners find challenging for conversation or intimate gatherings. While many appreciate the refined menu and beautiful décor, recurring feedback suggests that portion sizes are often perceived as small relative to the premium pricing. Experiences with the front-of-house staff are inconsistent, as some guests encounter welcoming hospitality while others report frustrations regarding reservations, seating delays, or dismissive attitudes. Overall, the establishment is widely considered a great destination for special occasions and group celebrations, though experiences regarding value and atmosphere can vary.
Comment dire, un restaurant italien un peu trop cher, mais avec des plats tres gouteux! J affectionne leur pizza a la mortadelle & pistache. Cependant notre service fut tres lents malgre le peu de d achalandage. Le restaurant est magnifique tres cossus, mais vieilli vite. Les menus sont deja tous grafignes & collants. Une place utile si vous etes un gros groupe. Le tiramisu monte a la table est une belle experience. Mais pour de la nourriture traditionnelle italienne, le prix est tres haut.
Despite its ambitions, this new establishment falls short of the benchmarks set by Sfoglina, Cipriani, or even (closer to home) Holder. The physical space is lovely, & the welcome is genuinely warm, the thoughtful addition of small stools for handbags is an excellent touch. Unfortunately, the front-of-house execution is undermined by fussy, uneven service & inconsistent cuisine.
The Food
The menu is a mixed experience. The starters ranged from average to poor. The seafood crudo was particularly disappointing: while the salmon was pleasant, the tuna lacked texture & flavour, & the scallops were entirely bland. The waiter's instruction that the chef suggested a squeeze of lemon felt less like culinary guidance & more like an admission that the dish required emergency seasoning. The pomodoro salad tasted of standard supermarket tomatoes, & the octopus was okay.
Mains, however, showed potential. The steak was excellent, & the accompanying asparagus was expertly prepared. The branzino, by contrast, was entirely unmemorable.
The Service & Ambience
The primary issue lies with the service. The waitstaff appear to be caught between a rigid, overly fussy training brief & a complete lack of basic product knowledge. Our waiter could not explain what distinguished the house Siamo Noi Negroni from a standard recipe (it tasted identical), & he offered no useful insight into the menu or the wine list.
The service is further marred by bizarre affectations. Presentation of a box of specialized knives for an ostensibly tender steak felt pretentious rather than premium-an unnecessary theatrical flourish that missed the mark.
Ultimately, the restaurant is struggling against its own pretension. It would benefit immensely from relaxing its posture, focusing on rigorous staff training, & ensuring the kitchen matches the standards of its best dishes.
Verdict: Skip this one for now until the management irons out the service flaws.
Jul 4, 2026
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
I really wanted to give this place 5 stars because the food was absolutely delicious & the atmosphere was lovely. Our server was also fantastic-attentive, friendly, & provided great service throughout our meal.
?However, the experience ended on a terrible note. At the very end of our night, the manager literally kicked us out. It was incredibly unprofessional & ruined what was otherwise a perfect evening. I would give the food & staff 5 stars, but management gets a 1-star for making us feel so unwelcome at the end. Proceed with caution.
Le service était correct, mais plusieurs frais nous ont été facturés sans être clairement expliqués. Nous avons demandé de l'eau ordinaire (eau du robinet), mais le serveur nous a apporté une bouteille d'eau minérale qui a ensuite été ajoutée à la facture pour 11 $, sans nous informer du coût au préalable.
De plus, une focaccia nous a été servie alors que nous ne l'avions pas demandée, & elle a également été facturée.
Concernant les pâtes, le menu indiquait la présence de truffe. Avant de commander, nous avons demandé confirmation au serveur, qui nous a assuré qu'il y en avait. Une fois le plat servi, il n'y avait pourtant aucune truffe. Lorsque nous avons posé la question, on nous a répondu qu'il s'agissait finalement d'un supplément payant.
Ce qui nous déçoit le plus, c'est que nous avons recommandé ce restaurant à de nombreuses personnes, y compris à des gens venant de l'extérieur de Montréal.
Indoor & outdoor parking
Outstanding service
Stunning ambiance
Incredible homemade Italian food ,the lemon pasta is a must
& for meat lovers the fillet mignon is out of this world
Not only is it a fun experience it's the in place to be!The chef Marco, & his attention to details makes a visual presentation stunning & no flavour was sacrificed.
A true culinary experience!!
In my top 5 dinners /evenings! Wonderful service, the food & presentation were exquisite & the atmosphere & vibe fun & vibrant without being too nosy for conversation. It was a first, but will definitely go back!
Magnifique découverte. Toutes les entrées que nous avons goûtées étaient excellentes. Ambiance tamisée & élégante, service impeccable. Une expérience culinaire incroyable du début à la fin. J'y reviendrai assurément.
