Lucille's Oyster Dive

Avy-Loren

4.0

Food. Overall good, sadly the seafood pasta was quite poor as well as the calamari appetizer. It's sad that a seafood & fish place would have these two dishes poor. Calamari's was miniature little pieces that were greasy, overly breaded & barely any calamari's. The portion was horrible as well. Tons of other places for the price are not better, but 110% superior. The seafood pasta was also a massive let down & had very limited seafood in the pasta & the portion was also smallish for the price.
Now, the ribs were fantastic but the French fries were a let down. First, very little of them, secondly, they place them under the ribs so you're forced to have rib sauce all over them which we all did not prefer, plus the crispness was no longer as they were saturated with bbq sauce. Should be on the side or separate dish & a larger portion as fries are super low cost.
The other rock star was the lobster rolls. Probably one of the better places to have these in the city & highly recommended. Pricing & portion was on par with the market.
The dessert was yummy & terribly impressive.

Would I go back again. Yes. But I would never eat the above mentioned dishes we didn't enjoy

Diana

5.0

I don't normally post a review after one dinner. Well, my husband & I have eaten at Lucille's on Monkland in NDG (Montreal) 4 times over the span of a few weeks, &'all 4' of our experiences were 5-star worthy when it comes to food, service & atmosphere.
Yesterday, my husband had a decadent Watermelon Marguerita, fresh crisp salad, Steak-frites (medium-rare as requested & so tender), & chocolate mousse. He raved.
I had a Tanqueray Martini, a dozen Premium Oysters, & Asian-Style Salmon Tartare with Plantain Chips. Delicious.
Everything we've ever eaten there has been equally superb. They have an extensive menu & signature cocktail list (but you can order other cocktails & wine). They cater to seafood & meat lovers alike--appetizing presentation & attention to detail, fresh elevated dishes. It's a great spot for date-night & for groups, whether dining inside or on their beautiful terrasse.
Staff is always welcoming & super friendly. Special thanks to Nihed for taking such good care of us yesterday (& on our previous visit), & Alysha for looking in on us. Josef from a previous visit was also great. Kudos to the magicians in the kitchen & the mixologist. &, the atmosphere, as usual, was lively & fun.
Highly recommended. My husband I can't wait to go back.

Anitha

4.0

Loved the food, the ambience & the service we received. Really liked the premium oysters (they were a little expensive though) lobster rolls were too good (be aware that you get 2 of them in a plate & it is cold) 2 was too much for me. seafood pasta was also tasty.

Willowspritew

5.0

Love their lobster rolls & ribs from their food truck. The New York Steak & prawns was well made & delicious, oysters were wonderful. Their seafood bloody Cesar was amazing.

Michel

5.0

I had a lobster roll from their tent during the Imagine Monkland festival & it was very good. The prices are a little high, notably for the size, but it is lobster so that tends to be more expensive. I would love to try their other dishes, they seem to be a good place for oysters & other seafood. Hopefully I can pass by soon.

Lakshana

4.0

I had an amazing dinner experience here! We really enjoyed the oysters & the burrata. The sangria & atmosphere were decent, but the real star of the show was the Octopus salad-absolutely delicious! I can't wait to come back & try more of the seafood.

Chris

5.0

I loved our visit to Lucille's. We were a party of 6 & everyone seemed to love their food. Service can be a bit slow, but the waitress we had was friendly & was able to answer any questions we had about the food.

We had the seafood tower, which is really good, but somewhat expensive for you you get. Don't know if I would get it again

I had the fish tacos, which were very tasty, & my wife had the calamari, which also tasted great, but I wish the portion size was a bit bigger.

My friend & I couldn't decide between the lobster rolls & steak, so we ended up ordering both the lobster rolls & the porterhouse for 2. The porterhouse was the best steak I have eaten at any restaurant & the lobster roll was also great.

All in all, it's a very good restaurant, & we'll 100% be going back.

Kenny

5.0

From the warm welcome by the hostess at the door to the attentive service from staff like Judy, Lucille's delivers excellence. The steak for two is perfectly cooked, the lucky lime oysters are fresh, & the lobster rolls are rich & buttery. Even the Caesar salad impresses with its bold flavors.

The cozy yet stylish ambiance makes it perfect for any occasion. Manager Jesse ensures everything runs smoothly, adding a personal touch. With gluten-free options & a well-curated menu, Lucille's is a top choice for seafood & steak lovers.

Joanne

2.0

Seafood Tower for $200 was Not worth it! Crab stuck to shell tells me it was cooked & stored for a couple days! Oysters were tiny & dry! Waitress dropped food & was gone. Should have had a Steak!

Nena

4.0

This place is such a good vibe & heavenly gift for the seafood lovers, keeping in mind Montreal is not by the ocean so always accounting for that freshness bit which is why I give it 4 stars. Loved getting affordable oysters (albeit small) they hit the spot & satisfy the craving!!! The Caesar was an absolute DREAM come true. The lobster rolls delivered. I can't wait to go back. We visited with a friend who had a newborn. & the staff were kind & lovely. Highly recommend. Lovely neighborhood