Atwater Cocktail Club is described as a stylish hidden speakeasy with a dramatic, glamorous setting and a long list of inventive, well-balanced cocktails that impress with flavor, presentation, and originality. The entrance tucked away in an alley adds to the secret society vibe. Staff are repeatedly praised for warmth and knowledge, though some reviews note that service can be slow and lines may form during peak times. Vibe, music, and ambiance are highlighted as top reasons to visit, with many calling it a Montreal gem and an ideal spot for dates or nights with friends. Prices are sometimes described as a bit high, but the overall experience and craftsmanship are considered worth it. Overall, Atwater Cocktail Club delivers on atmosphere and creativity, standing out as a must visit for cocktail lovers.
Belle expérience, surtout pour les cocktails/mocktails.
Ambiance speakeasy bien assumée en semaine, low key, intime, avec une vibe underground. Ça sent même la fumée de leurs cocktails'smoke show', ça ajoute au trip. La musique est solide.
Le week-end, ça switch plus en mode club, plus bruyant, plus énergique.
Le staff est cool, rien à dire. Côté bouffe, c'est correct mais un peu fancy pour ce que c'est, clairement pas la raison principale d'y aller.
Ici, tu viens pour une chose : vivre une vraie expérience cocktails/mocktails. & là-dessus, c'est impeccable.
May 4, 2026
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
There are great bars… & then there are unforgettable experiences - & Jess at Atwater Cocktail Club is the reason this place sits in a league of its own.
From the moment we sat down, Jess brought an energy that completely set the tone for the night. It wasn't just service - it felt personal. She took the time to understand exactly what we were in the mood for, & somehow turned that into drinks that were not only perfect, but genuinely memorable. Every cocktail felt intentional, like it was crafted specifically for us.
What makes Jess different is her presence. She's warm, locked in, & effortlessly creates a vibe that makes you want to stay longer, order one more round, & just enjoy the moment. You can tell she loves what she does - & it shows in every interaction, every recommendation, every detail.
I've been to a lot of bars… but I can confidently say Jess is the best bartender I've ever had. This wasn't just a night out - this is the kind of experience that makes you come back again & again.
I'll 100% be returning & it's entirely because of her.
Suave, esoteric, & classy. Me & my review partner both had 2 cocktails each & oysters. We were impressed by the cocktails & my partner very much enjoyed the Mad Whale. Kind & cool staff, awesome place overall, just not necessarily our vibe. (22/27) always love a hidden entrance.
P.S. the 27 rating scale represents the 27 aspects of a great meal.
Really enjoyed the vibe here. Our mixologist Jess was awesome. So friendly & talented. Bob at the front door was super nice. Great selection of cocktails. Will return!
Mar 22, 2026
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
If Gatsby had a Canadian cousin who knew how to mix a proper drink, this would be his basement.
Tucked away like a secret you're not supposed to tell your in-laws, this prohibition style speakeasy absolutely nails the vibe.
Dim lights ? Check. Cool crowd ? Check.
Music that makes you nod like you understand jazz on a spiritual level ? Double check.
We worked our way through the Purple Rain, the Federal Reserve, & the Honey & Peach, basically a tour of flavor from rock concert to Wall Street to summer picnic. Each cocktail was beautifully balanced, dangerously smooth, & strong enough to make us briefly consider investing in something.
Now… about the ice.
Let's just say the cubes were less
'elegant chill' & more'Arctic expedition.'
By the time we found our way around the glacier in the glass, half the drink had relocated to the North Pole. We came for cocktails, not to reenact Titanic.
That said, the atmosphere & music were so good we almost forgave the icebergs. Almost.
Final verdict: fantastic night, stellar drinks, great vibes, just bring a tiny pickaxe… 😜
I went to Atwater Cocktail Club last night & honestly… never again. The moment I walked in, there was a strong, unpleasant smell at the bar - almost like aged cheese. Not exactly the vibe.
I always order a martini to test a bartender's skills, & this was hands down the worst martini I've ever had. Weak, no balance, no flavor, just… big. The other drinks weren't any better - nothing unique, nothing craft about them.
To make things worse, the host/bouncer kept passing gas right near the entrance. I wish I was joking. It was genuinely nauseating & made the whole experience even more uncomfortable.
For a place that's supposed to be a speakeasy with great cocktails, this was a huge disappointment. Definitely not worth the hype.
Elevated cocktail bar with a smooth speakeasy vibe. Everything we had was well balanced & exceptional. Sebastian & team were wonderful hosts. They definitely earned their Top 50 marks!
Montreals speakeasy game is top Notch & Atwater's Cocktail club ranks high on this scale! The vibes are vibing & the cocktails were so carefully crafted, tasted incredible & were presented beautifully! My friend & I had an incredible time!
Such a great spot! The staff were friendly & welcoming-offering us a welcome drink while we waited to be seated, which really elevated the experience. The vibe was amazing, with great music at just the right volume so you could still have a conversation. The drinks were top-tier, especially La Récolte, recommended by our waiter-honestly one of the best cocktails I've ever had. Can't wait to come back!
