Best American Restaurants in West Island (2026) - Reviews & Menus

40 Westt Steakhouse

Opens Tuesday at 11:30 am

(575)

Pointe-Claire

American Canadian Mediterranean Seafood/Fish Steakhouse Salads

Mentioned in: The Best Spots for Dirty Martinis in Montreal 18 Steakhouses in Montreal to Enjoy a Perfectly Grilled Cut View More

Review Summary

Westt Steakhouse is widely praised for impeccable service, a refined ambiance, and steaks that are consistently cooked to perfection. The menu earns compliments for rich flavors and thoughtful presentation, from tomahawk and New York strip to lobster and filet mignon, with desserts like crème brûlée and chocolate soufflé that seal the experience. The open kitchen, elegant decor, and attentive staff contribute to a sophisticated, welcoming vibe that makes occasions feel special, while the wine list complements each course nicely. Some reviews note that the live band can be loud at times, but the overall atmosphere remains lively and upscale. This spot is repeatedly recommended for celebrations and special dinners, delivering memorable meals, dependable quality, and a sense of hospitality that keeps guests returning.View restaurant profile

Reserve
Menu

Atelier de Cuisine Table Rouge

Opens Today at 6:30 am

(11)

Pierrefonds-Roxboro, Montreal-West

Italian Sushi Pasta Desserts & Sweets Pizza Greek

Mentioned in: Original and Unique Restaurants in Montreal

Review Summary

Atelier de Cuisine Table Rouge is described as a warm, energetic space where the team keeps the atmosphere engaging and relaxed, with clear instruction and generous portions. Dishes such as the Portuguese option and the Italian street food receive enthusiastic praise for flavor and variety, and dietary restrictions are smoothly accommodated. The location is noted as spacious, bright, clean, and modern, making it well suited for team events and group activities. Family friendly programs and summer cooking classes for kids are highlighted for teaching practical kitchen skills and giving a strong sense of accomplishment, appealing to a broad range of guests.View restaurant profile

Wayback Burgers

Opens Today at 11 am

(86)

Pierrefonds-Roxboro, Kirkland

Burgers American Comfort Food

Review Summary

Reviews consistently praise Wayback Burgers for fresh beef that is not frozen, flavorful burgers cooked to order, and a variety of options including veggie patties, with many noting juicy burgers and good toppings. Fries and sides are described as crispy and well seasoned, and shakes are a popular accompaniment. Service is repeatedly called friendly, patient with kids, and efficient, and the atmosphere is welcoming with a clean retro vibe. Value is highlighted by several reviewers as strong for the quality, while a few mention higher prices or occasionally less memorable burgers. Overall the place is seen as a reliable, quality burger spot with good service and a pleasant dining experience.View restaurant profile

Order

Moe's Bar & Grill

Pointe-Claire, Dollard-des-Ormeaux

American Deli Smoked Meat Pasta Greek Grill

Pizza Salvatoré

Opens Today at 11 am

(382)

Dollard-des-Ormeaux

Pizza Poutine Chicken Wings Comfort Food American

Review Summary

Reviews describe Pizza Salvatoré as a reliable and popular choice with fast, friendly service and generous toppings, offering everything from classic pies to loaded or stuffed crust options. The pizza is often praised for flavor and a sauce that stands out, with crust described as soft or doughy and toppings that are plentiful rather than skimpy. Delivery is speedy and staff are courteous, with many customers returning again and again. Value is frequently noted as good, aided by affordable prices, coupons, and app perks, though a few mentions point out that portions can be small or pricing uneven compared to some chains. Dishes like BBQ chicken and NY pepper and bacon are highlighted favorites, and dipping sauces add an extra perk. The overall impression is that Pizza Salvatoré delivers quality, consistency, and a nostalgic, satisfying pizza experience, earning praise as one of the best options in the region.View restaurant profile

Order

Smoke Meat Pete

Opens Today at 9 am

(946)

L'Île-Perrot

Smoked Meat American Burgers Breakfast

Mentioned in: The Best Smoked Meat in Montreal

Review Summary

Smoke Meat Pete is widely praised as a standout for smoked meat in Montreal and a landmark in the city’s tradition. The atmosphere is repeatedly described as lively and old school, with live blues, a friendly staff, and a vibe that makes the wait part of the experience. The meat is tender and richly flavored, with standout fries and coleslaw and ribs and poutine also receiving praise. Several reviews discuss value, noting portions or prices have shifted over time and that some days feel pricey for the size. Crowds and noise are common, especially when live music is on, but the energy is part of the appeal. Service is often described as fast and friendly, with the ordering system at the counter and options for takeout or bundles. Overall the reviews converge on a memorable Montreal experience where the food, music, and atmosphere combine to justify a trip.View restaurant profile

The Keg Steakhouse + Bar

Opens Today at 12 pm

(700)

Pointe-Claire

Steakhouse Seafood/Fish American Grill Contemporary/Modern Canadian

Review Summary

Overall, reviews paint The Keg as a place with consistently excellent steaks and reliable cocktails, especially for ribeye, filet mignon, and New York strip, with sides and baked potatoes praised and the menu offering solid value for many diners. The ambiance shifts from intimate, low lighting dining to a lively bar area, and the atmosphere is often described as warm and comfortable, suitable for special occasions. Service is generally friendly and professional, with many experiences featuring attentive staff and smooth pacing, though crowded rooms can feel noisy and rushed, and timing can suffer on busy nights. A number of visits report good experiences spoiled by long waits for meals, occasional miscommunications at the bar or with reservations, and some inconsistency in cooking, with some dishes overcooked, underseasoned, or drier than expected. Overall, The Keg is viewed as a dependable go to for steak lovers, offering strong dishes and a pleasant atmosphere, while price and occasional service or kitchen hiccups remind guests that experiences can vary by location and night.View restaurant profile

Order

La Cage

Opens Today at 11:30 am

(272)

Vaudreuil-Dorion

Grill Burgers Pub Food Sandwiches BBQ Salads

Mentioned in: The Best Sports Bars in Montreal: Where to Watch Your Favorite Games

Review Summary

Overall, La Cage feels like a lively, family friendly sports bar where guests repeatedly note a warm welcome, attentive service, and a reliable, upbeat atmosphere. The menu offers a wide range of crowd pleasers and daily specials, with many praising generous portions and dishes such as salmon tartare, buffalo wings, poutine, burgers, tacos and a tuna tataki bowl, while drinks and snacks like popcorn on arrival add to the casual vibe. On busy game nights the service is fast and efficient and the vibe stays energetic, making it a convenient spot for families, friends, or watching a game. While most experiences are positive, there are occasional criticisms about crowded conditions, long waits, or miscommunications about promos, and a few specific dishes receiving mixed reviews such as a burnt kids pizza or uneven kitchen timing. Overall the quality of food and the friendliness of the staff stand out, with many calling it a go to place for sports, celebrations, and casual evenings, and frequent return visits reflecting consistent satisfaction.View restaurant profile

Bistro Grace

Modern upscale bistro, with sleek decor and market driven fresh cuisine.

Opens Tuesday at 5 pm

(91)

Pierrefonds-Roxboro

Bistro American Contemporary/Modern French

Review Summary

Overall, Bistro Grace earns high marks for outstanding food and a cozy yet upscale atmosphere, with warm and attentive service that makes for a welcoming experience. Reviews describe flavorful, beautifully presented dishes and a memorable dessert lineup, including a cherry pie that far exceeds its photos. The staff are consistently praised for knowledge and attentiveness, reinforcing the sense of a refined, hospitable dining environment and making it ideal for a special night out. Instances of inconsistency and slower service surface in some visits, particularly when crowds or staffing are tight, and a few patrons feel that certain items are overpriced relative to value. Some guests highlight the West Island location as a hidden gem and express a strong desire to return, while others note mixed experiences with drinks and overall value. This blend of standout cuisine and variable service keeps Bistro Grace regarded as a wow worthy option with caveats to consider.View restaurant profile

Reserve

Rubs BBQ Américain

Opens Today at 11:30 am

(56)

Pierrefonds-Roxboro, Dollard-des-Ormeaux

American BBQ Comfort Food Burgers Smoked Meat

Mentioned in: American BBQ and Smokehouse in Montreal: Must-Tries

Review Summary

Overall, Rubs BBQ Américain earns praise for authentic smoked meats with a standout smoke flavor across brisket, pulled pork, ribs and surprisingly good fried chicken, while portions are described as generous and prices reasonable for the quality. The service is repeatedly noted as friendly and attentive in a cozy setting, and many reviews say the platter options easily feed two or three people with enough variety to please a group. The experience centers on the meats, especially the brisket and ribs, but some reviews mention price or portion balance on certain platters and a few outings felt underwhelming or affected by temporary changes such as renovations or menu shifts. Overall, many would return and recommend Rubs BBQ Américain for a solid, satisfying American style BBQ experience.View restaurant profile

Order

Bâton Rouge Grillhouse & Bar

Opens Today at 11:30 am

(709)

Vaudreuil-Dorion

American Grill BBQ Steakhouse Salads Burgers

Review Summary

Overall, reviewers describe Bâton Rouge Grillhouse & Bar as a solid choice with tasty dishes, generous portions, and a warm, welcoming atmosphere, and many praise the attentive, professional service across locations. The ribs and steaks are frequently highlighted as well prepared with good wine pairings, and the dining experience is often noted as enjoyable whether in bar side or dining room settings. However, there are recurring concerns about meals arriving cold or over/under cooked, occasional inconsistent service, and perceptions of high prices or a somewhat limited menu. The atmosphere can feel lively and sometimes noisy, with occasional slower moments or staffing friction cited by some guests. Still, the gist across reviews is that the restaurant delivers strong food and service often enough to warrant returning, even as a minority experience disappointment on a given visit.View restaurant profile

Bistro Nolah

Opens Today at 10 am

(366)

Dollard-des-Ormeaux

Cajun Creole Comfort Food Bistro Contemporary/Modern American

Mentioned in: Gumbo and Jambalaya in Montreal: A Taste of New Orleans Guide to the Best Restaurants in Montreal's West Island View More

Review Summary

Bistro Nolah is described as a warm, intimate spot with a small but lively dining room and a vibe that nods to New Orleans. The food receives high praise across the board, with standout dishes including gumbo, jambalaya, shrimp and grits, fried chicken, brisket, catfish, hush puppies, bread pudding, and beignets, noted for rich flavors, generous portions, and thoughtful presentation. Brunch is a major draw, offering inventive southern favorites and a few guests calling it among the best, though the restaurant can be busy and reservations are often advised due to limited space. The service is repeatedly described as attentive, knowledgeable, friendly, and accommodating, contributing to an overall welcoming atmosphere that makes it feel like a special occasion without being overly formal. Several reviews mention a charming interior and, in good weather, a terrace experience that enhances the mood. Occasional notes of spice balance and timing show that the kitchen can be very busy on weekends, with a few patrons noting long waits or specific dishes that could have more heat or variety. Overall, Bistro Nolah is seen as a top choice for southern comfort cuisine in Montreal, delivering consistent quality, strong hospitality, and a dining experience that fans are eager to repeat.View restaurant profile

Order

Bâton Rouge Grillhouse & Bar

Opens Today at 11 am

(1246)

Dollard-des-Ormeaux

American Grill BBQ Steakhouse Salads Burgers

Review Summary

Overall, reviews describe Bâton Rouge as a dependable spot for hearty meals with generous portions and solid steaks and ribs, offered in a warm, welcoming, and often lively atmosphere that feels like a familiar home base and is generally priced reasonably. The service is frequently praised for friendliness and attentiveness, with many servers noted for recommendations, speed, and smooth operations; however, some visits report busier crowds leading to noise and occasional lapses with reservations or miscommunications. Quality and consistency are described as strong overall, though a few meals are cited as over salted, underseasoned, or arriving cold, and some portions or value concerns surface when compared to prior visits. Delivery experiences vary, with some orders arriving well and others not meeting expectations. Despite mixed moments, the consensus remains that Bâton Rouge is a reliable choice for a satisfying meal and a pleasant atmosphere that keeps guests returning.View restaurant profile

Reserve

Milestones

Opens Today at 12 pm

(492)

Pointe-Claire

American Grill International Tartare Burgers

Review Summary

Milestones comes through in reviews as a vibrant, family friendly spot with a lively bar scene, generous portions, and good value, where the atmosphere and friendly, attentive service are frequently praised and the menu is seen as reliable for casual dinners, celebrations and group outings. Food is described as tasty and well prepared with a range of crowd favorites and well priced drinks, though some visits note hit or miss experiences, including slower service during busy times, occasional order mix ups, and a few dishes that arrive lukewarm or underseasoned. Several reviewers mention strong vegetarian and allergy friendly awareness, while others feel some vegetarian choices could be more flavorful. The noise level and size of the dining room can be loud, and accessibility such as parking can be challenging at times. Overall, Milestones is viewed as a dependable, welcoming option with great staff and a vibrant vibe, with most guests planning to return despite the occasional inconsistency.View restaurant profile

Order

Kirkland Resto-Bar

Opens Today at 4 pm

(98)

Pierrefonds-Roxboro, Kirkland

American Bistro Contemporary/Modern Burgers Fish & Chips

Review Summary

Overall, reviews describe Kirkland Resto-Bar as a cozy, inviting spot with a mix of refined dining and casual pub vibes, a pleasant terrace, and occasional live music. The cuisine is described as well executed and flavorful, with highlights such as fried cheese curds and other pub favorites, and the service is frequently praised for friendliness, attentiveness, and professionalism, though a few experiences note slower service or some inconsistencies. The atmosphere is repeatedly described as warm and appealing, with good value and reasonable prices, and the venue is seen as a local gem with a welcoming staff and a lively yet relaxed vibe. Some reviews mention downsides like a small menu, occasional delays, or dishes that fall short, but the overall impression is positive and many look forward to returning.View restaurant profile

Order

Jack Astor's

Opens Today at 12 pm

(724)

Dorval, Dollard-des-Ormeaux

American Steakhouse Burgers Chicken Wings

Mentioned in: The Best Quiz and Trivia Nights in Montreal

Review Summary

Overall, at Jack Astor's the reviews portray a lively, family-friendly spot with reliable burgers, chicken, bowls and plenty of portions, and friendly service, though a few visits suffer from mismatched orders, slow checks, or higher prices for dishes that don't stand out. Diners frequently praise the food as tasty and plentiful, with bar vibes and quick drink service during games, while the atmosphere is described as fun and sometimes loud, with holiday decorations that delight families and crayons on the table for kids. The staff are often highlighted as attentive and accommodating, able to navigate dietary needs and explain menu options, yet some reports reference outdated decor and POS issues, language barriers for non French speakers, and occasional order errors. For many, Jack Astor's remains a go-to for casual nights out, birthday celebrations, or catching a game, with plans to return, though a few guests note that portions can feel smaller for the price.View restaurant profile

Nickels Deli & Bar

Opens Today at 7 am

(226)

Pointe-Claire

American Deli Grill Breakfast Smoked Meat

Review Summary

Nickels Deli & Bar comes across in reviews as a reliable spot for classic deli fare and smoked meat, offering generous portions and a broad menu that suits breakfast, lunch, or a casual dinner. The atmosphere is described as clean, casual, and welcoming, with friendly service that many patrons appreciate; however, a few visits mention slower pacing or inconsistency. The food tends to be praised for taste, especially the smoked meat, poutines, and other comfort dishes, while some items are noted to vary and a couple of visits report mixed experiences. Prices are generally considered fair, though a handful of comments point to higher costs or limited platter options in some contexts. Its location near the airport and in the Dorval area makes it a convenient stop for travelers and locals alike, contributing to frequent returns from regulars who value dependable flavors and a family-friendly vibe.View restaurant profile

Order

Annies Sur-Le-Lac

Opens Tuesday at 11:30 am

(251)

Sainte-Anne-de-Bellevue

American Burgers Fish & Chips Sandwiches

Review Summary

Annies Sur-Le-Lac gets praise for its stunning lakeside setting and relaxing terrace, with diners enjoying generous portions and a variety of crowd favorites such as nachos, wings, fajitas, fish and chips, salmon, and burgers, all complemented by a lively atmosphere and, on sunny days, a view of boats gliding by. The location and ambience are repeatedly cited as the highlight, making it a popular stop for a casual lunch, drinks, or a summer outing. Food quality is described as solid to very good, with many noting flavorful dishes and friendly staff in some visits, though there are notable inconsistencies. Service is frequently described as uneven or slow, water refills and attentiveness sometimes lacking, and timing can be off with arrivals or checks; price points are sometimes judged high for the value. Occasional comments mention construction near the river and a busy or quiet vibe depending on the day. Taken together, Annies Sur-Le-Lac remains a go to waterfront option, especially for the view, but some visits emphasize the need for more consistent management and service.View restaurant profile

Order

Pizza Salvatoré

Open until 3 am

(498)

Salaberry-de-Valleyfield

Pizza Poutine Chicken Wings Comfort Food American

Review Summary

Reviewers consistently praise Pizza Salvatoré for excellent pizza and good value, with favorites including a pepperoni New York style and a Mediterranean pie, plus a variety of poutines and sides; the food is described as fresh, flavorful and generously topped, and desserts like Nutella donuts are noted by some. Service is generally fast and friendly, but a few reviews point to inconsistency between locations, occasional delivery delays, and staffing issues, and at least one discount was not honored. The restaurant is seen as clean and the staff professional, with many customers choosing takeout or taking advantage of deals through the app. Overall, it is regarded as a reliable, satisfying option for pizza and related dishes at a reasonable price, though some improvements in consistency and customer service are mentioned.View restaurant profile