Place Carmin est largement salue comme une destination culinaire francaise remarquable dans le Vieux Montreal, proposant des plats soigneusement elabores tels que la moelle osseuse, le canard a l orange, le tartare de veau, les coquilles Saint-Jacques dans une puree de pommes de terre, la tarte tatin au boudin et le Paris Brest, avec des cocktails et une carte des vins solide qui complètent l experience. L espace et le service sont souvent describes comme elegants, attentifs et professionnels, ce qui en fait un lieu adapte pour des diners intimes, des evenements privés et des brunchs, tandis que les avis mentionnent une ambiance allant du calme et raffinee a plus anime pour les groupes. Bien que beaucoup de commentaires celebrent la qualite, certains convives trouvent que certains plats ou portions peuvent etre inconsistants et quelques choix du menu ne repondent pas toujours aux attentes, avec des remarques occasionnelles sur le rapport qualite-prix ou le service en periode d affluence, mais l impression generale est que Place Carmin propose une experience incontournable et digne d une etoile, qui pousse les visiteurs a revenir.
Some of the worst coffee I've had in a restaurant. It was somehow both sour & very bitter at the same time (coffee nerd). I wasn't able to drink it.
The scrambled eggs I think could have been good. The truffle seemed hidden & the cold soft cheese really threw off the temperature as it wasn't cooled with the eggs. I'm also a fan of soft cooked scrambled eggs but something seemed off to me.
I had high hopes for this meal but was disappointed.
The restaurant is very beautiful & I did have excellent service so no complaints there.
This was our favourite meal of our trip. We went to Modavie the day before & I was just so disappointed with the food there.
Definitely recommend trying Place Carmin out. Our favourite was the blood pudding tatine & duck orange. So so good! Will definitely come back when we visit Montreal again.
23 oct. 2025
sur Google
🍽️
Sachez où manger à Montréal avant tout le monde.
Découvrez en primeur les ouvertures les plus branchées, des menus secrets et les coups de cœur de RestoMontreal.ca. Rejoignez plus de 50 000 foodies.
Nous sommes allés samedi dernier le 6 septembre dernier. Le repas était délicieux mais le service de la serveuse n'était pas bien. Nous avons ressentit de l'impatience & honnêtement ça beaucoup diminué notre expérience
Incredible experience! Found this place on the Michelin list & truly cannot believe they don't have star - very worthy of one. Trevor our server was phenomenal through & through, the cocktails were impeccable, & I might consider this place as my last meal - that's how good the food was.
Came here for a date night, the atmosphere was good, the restaurant feels very grand & luxurious making it the perfect place for a date. Enjoyed our meal, it's hard to find chimichurri on a menu in Canada!
19 août 2025
sur Google
🍽️
Sachez où manger à Montréal avant tout le monde.
Découvrez en primeur les ouvertures les plus branchées, des menus secrets et les coups de cœur de RestoMontreal.ca. Rejoignez plus de 50 000 foodies.
Trevor was a great server & the gin martini was on point. Food was delicious. Scallop ceviche, deviled eggs, leek puff pastry, & the cod are all great. Peach crepe for dessert. The facade of the restaurant is equally as beautiful as the interior.
Seeiously, Place Carmin is something special. From the minute you walk in the door you are taken care of & the ambiance is set by the beautifully minimalist but elegant atmosphere. Despite there being several tables in the room, we felt like we were the only people there because of how amazing the service was!
Beyond service, the food was an absolute culinary delight. We kept raving about each dish & left with full bellies & full hearts. Honestly, not a bad sip or bite the entire night.
Thank you for everything & we absolutely look forward to coming back in the future!
