Pizza Toni

Deanne

5.0

I happened upon Pizza Toni, & even though I just got jerk chicken down the street I came in for a slice... really well done ny style marg slice: thin, crispy bottom & a good level of acid on the sauce. After that I got a square to go, not usually my style but 10/10 would do again. Vibes are dope, hand washing sink...really thoughtful.

Jul 15, 2024

on Google

Meeps

4.0

Solid slice, ill give it an 8.2. It's a little light on the sauce but the crust has a beautiful char on it. If you're looking for a NY style pizza in town, this is a great choice

Jun 2, 2024

on Google

M

5.0

Best new york style in mtl

May 21, 2024

on Google

TB

5.0

I don't typically care for NY style pizza bit Toni is awesome. Great sauce, great crust, I'm not super crazy about their pepperoni though. I enjoyed their jalapeno with a bit of pepperoni as opposed to their full pepperoni, too oily for the small amount of pepperoni they put.

May 14, 2024

on Google

Fady

5.0

Great New York styled pizza !! Amazing, about time we get this kind of pizza in Montreal ! 👌🏼

Apr 6, 2024

on Google

Andrew

5.0

Great NY style Pizza, always get a pie when I'm in Montreal.

Mar 19, 2024

on Google

Sharon

4.0

I tried Pizza Toni for the first time & I wanted to leave a review to help others out who might not know what to expect. I'm originally from NJ & I wanted to try this place because it was supposed to have more "NY style" pizza instead of Montreal style pizza. I will say that the crust was definitely reminiscent of NY style pizza & overall I did like it. I ordered the eggplant parmesan pizza for myself & the vegan pizza (with 1/2 pepperoni) for my son. I was a bit disappointed with mine because it tasted like the peppers were marinated in something with vinegar. I really hate vinegar which is why I didn't choose the mushroom pizza (since it said it was their marinated mushroom mix) & I didn't want to take the chance of something vinegary. The pizza I ordered mentioned cheese, tomato sauce, heirloom peppers & eggplant. I can't 100% for sure say it was vinegar, but it was definitely not just plain peppers as they were very tangy & that taste overwhelmed the entire pizza for me. So I can't say if I would have fully liked it or not. I think if I had gotten plain cheese, or if you could choose your toppings, I would have liked it more. My son got the vegan cheese pizza & he really loved the vegan cheese & the pizza itself. I took a bite & I thought the vegan cheese tasted really good. I got 1/2 pepperoni because he really likes pepperoni, but some places are too spicy for him. He has GI issues & so if he eats spicy foods it aggravates his system. Unfortunately although he loved the taste of the pepperoni, he found they were very spicy for him (he's only 10). So I just want to give that caveat to anyone concerned with that. If you like spicy or it doesn't bother you, you will probably like it. The other downside is that the pizzas are VERY expensive. I knew this ahead of time on their website, but I'm just letting people know in case. For me, it was a fun splurge but not something I would order that regularly. It was $87 for 2 pizzas & a hot honey dip, although I did also add pepperoni to a pizza that doesn't normally have it so it might have been extra. I did find the pizzeria to have a nice atmosphere & there were lots of young people hanging out & eating pizza. The restaurant did not seat large numbers, but it still felt spacious & looked very clean. Everyone working there was nice & they looked happy. I really do think that for someone who is not sensitive to vinegar, they would probably really like it. I just don't have an adventurous palate for that kind of stuff. Also, I ordered some hot honey on the side to drizzle on my pizza & it was really delicious.

Mar 12, 2024

on Google

Alexia

5.0

Hands down my favorite place in Montreal to get a slice of NYC style pizza, or even two. The crust, the tomato sauce, the toppings, yummyyyyy

Mar 7, 2024

on Google

Alex

5.0

1 of the.best pizzas in town, new york style

Jan 26, 2024

on Google

Michael

5.0

Best New York style pizza in Montreal with no debate. Service is always great & they keep pounding til 9 at night. Must try their triple P with hot honey & ranch!

Oct 22, 2023

on Google

Rick

5.0

This place serves a solid slice of thin NY style pizza. Nice undercarriage & no flop.

Sep 25, 2023

on Google

Rebelksc

5.0

The best NY style pizza🤤

Sep 25, 2023

on Google