Pizza Toni specializes in the authentic craft of hand-stretched dough and high-quality toppings prepared within a traditional stone oven. The menu focuses on the fundamental elements of artisanal pizza, utilizing fresh ingredients to create balanced flavor profiles across a variety of classic and contemporary styles. Each pie features a signature thin, blistered crust that provides a distinctively crispy texture while remaining light enough to highlight the house-made tomato sauce and premium mozzarella. The establishment maintains a streamlined kitchen workflow to ensure consistency and speed for every order produced on site. Patrons find a casual and efficient environment designed specifically for the appreciation of high-quality, straightforward pizza preparations. This focus on core culinary techniques ensures that the final product remains focused on texture, heat, and seasonal ingredient integrity.
Pizza Toni is widely celebrated as one of the best spots in Montreal for New York style pizza, praised for its thin, crispy crust, high-quality ingredients, and perfect balance of sauce and cheese. Many diners highlight the pepperoni, spicy honey, and vodka-based slices as standouts, often pairing them with the highly recommended house dipping sauces. While the restaurant is frequently described as busy with a vibrant, welcoming atmosphere and efficient, friendly staff, the compact size of the space and occasional long wait times are noted by some. Despite a few mixed experiences regarding pricing, delivery consistency, or specific taste preferences, the vast majority of visitors consider the food a must-try staple and frequently return for the consistent quality and flavor.
Hands down one of the best pizza places I've been to, & definitely the best place that I've tried while being in Canada.
Love that they sell pizza by the slice, have all their flavors ready to go & that they heat it back up in the pizza oven vs just handing you a warm slice, so you get a nice hot & crispy slice of pizza.
Atmosphere was wonderful, employees are cheerful, & pizza was quick. It was busy but they manage to keep everyone flowing without looking wait times. Even better you can watch them make the pizza & see that they have several pizza ovens so that they can keep up with demand & keep wait times down.
Such a shame I don't live in Montreal, as I would eat here every week at least once if I could. I would make this place my weekly pizza night. If you're looking for some amazing New York style pizza, this place definitely delivered.
Pizza is amazing!! Best NY style slice ive had outside of NYC, the vodka pep & sweet cherry pie were amazing! Definitely coming back to try the square focaccia slices!
So it's pizza. Is it the best pizza in town? No. Is it the worst, no. Is it mid? No. There is better NY style pizza out there, but you can do worse. Their square pizza is actually better tbh.
Moves quite fast despite being unbelievably busy.
Mar 15, 2026
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
J'aimerais vraiment aller manger sur place, mais les deux fois, on a commandé en livraison. & honnêtement : la qualité est top, même rendue à la maison.
Pâte bien croustillante, sauce incroyable & des toppings de feu 🔥 Cette fois-ci, on a pris la pepperoni au miel épicé. Avec le dipping ranch… c'était franchement cochon & délicieux.
Craving a taste of Brooklyn right in the heart of Mile End? 🍕✨
Pizza Toni on Saint-Viateur is serving up what many call the best New York-style slice outside of NYC. Whether you're grabbing a quick'car slice' or sitting down to a full pie, that signature crunch & slightly sweet sauce are absolute game-changers.
Did you know? 💡 Pizza Toni was founded by the same team behind the legendary Falafel Yoni. To make sure they nailed the authentic NYC vibe, the owners actually trained with seasoned pizzaiolos in Los Angeles & Villeray before opening!
Our personal favorite? The'Grandma' Square Slice. It's thick, rustic, & has those perfectly crisp, burnt edges that every pizza lover dreams of. Pair it with one of their custom house pilsners & you've got the ultimate Montreal lunch. 🍺🗽
Drop a 🍕 in the comments if you're a thin-crust purist or a square-slice devotee!
#MTLfoodie #MontrealPizza #MileEndEats #MTLmoments #PizzaToni
📷 @StayserEats
Pizza Tony serves a decent New York-style pizza. Some people may find it a bit too oily, but if you enjoy a generously topped pizza that's filling & really sticks with you, it's worth trying.
I've ordered from them several times, & overall I'd say it's average-plus. It's definitely not the best pizza I've ever had, but it gets the job done & is a reliable option when you're craving this style of pizza.
Cet endroit est la meilleure pizzeria de Montréal, étant un amateurs de la pizza style New-York, celle ci me remplie de joie. Le drizzle du miel épicé & des produits de qualités sont une pépite a essayer a tout prix.
Great NY style pizza, heard good things about this place & we came to try. Service was awesome, cashier recommended the Sweet Cherry Tomato-we also got a Margherita slice, both were delicious.
You've had pizza Toni but have you had pizza toni takeout, straight out the oven New York style?
That's the only way I'm gonna enjoy pizza Toni now.
The warm crispy slice with perfect load of sauce & cheese was perfect last night. Honestly FANTASTIC.
I love y that you guys have little knickknacks too like the rolling papers, magnets & stickers. Cheers
