FR
Montreal Restaurants
RestaurantsReviewsArticlesWhat's On

Logo RestoMontreal.ca

Filter & Sort
District
( Selected)
AND
Places
( Selected)
AND
Option
( Selected)
Dietary restrictions
AND
Cuisine
( Selected)
OR
Dish
( Selected)
OR
Type
( Selected)
AND
Amenities
( Selected)
AND
Services
( Selected)
AND
Special Menu
( Selected)
AND
Atmosphere
( Selected)
Time
( Selected)
Budget
( Selected)
Sort By

Pizza Toni
Restaurant Top Pick

Pizza Toni

Mile-End
4.5$
OPEN11:30 am - 9 pm
Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Saturday
Sunday
Pizza Toni Montreal Restaurant: Menu, Reviews & Reserve (2026)
Pizza
At pizza toni we serve ny style pizzas and “grandma” style square pies. We believe in sourcing the best ingredients we can in order to make the best possible pizzas. Over our first year of operation we kept the menu tight and simple with only 6 pizzas available. We’ve decided that now is the time to open things up and give the people what they want - more options! So, we’ve added a slew of new toppings for you to enjoy. From organic mushrooms to vegan cheese. Build out your dream pie! Pro tip: we recommend you stick to just a few toppings in order to keep the structure of your pie sound.

Amenities, services & more

Suggested Articles

5★
73%
4★
12%
3★
6%
2★
8%
1★
1%

Mentioned in:

Pizza Toni was featured in the article(s) below.

The 10 Best Mile-End RestaurantsMore

Rumi

5198 Rue Hutchison
(1406)

Events NearbyMore

Reviews for Pizza Toni

Food
Service
on Google4.4 (1300+)
*as of 2026-02-01
5★
73%
4★
12%
3★
6%
2★
8%
1★
1%

Review Summary

Pizza Toni is widely praised for thin crispy New York style crusts, fresh toppings, and a well balanced sauce that often earns it a top spot for pizza in Montreal, with many recommending it for takeout or a quick dine-in visit. The menu shines with crowd pleasers like vodka pepperoni, classic Margherita, Sicilian or square pizzas, and dessert options such as a sweet cherry pie pizza, plus a vegan cheese option and a standout garlic dipping sauce and hot honey; the crust and dough are repeatedly lauded for texture and chew. The atmosphere is described as cozy and the staff friendly and efficient, though some reviews mention sporadic service hiccups or value concerns and a few pizzas that miss the mark on flavor or toppings. Overall, Pizza Toni is considered a must try by many Montreal pizza lovers, delivering bold flavors, crisp crusts, and consistent quality that keeps customers returning despite occasional criticisms about price or consistency.
Page 1 of 18 - 347 Reviews

Was in town & we stopped in because my boyfriends buddy brought us,, best slices we've had in awhile & we both work at pizza places in the states! Service was amazing def stop in if you can!

Feb 9, 2026
on Google
5.0

Pizza shop worker from New Orleans here - slices, in-house Pilsner, & the environment are all 10/10 , affordable pizza with great dough structure & super cool workers. Will be back.

Feb 9, 2026
on Google

Meilleure pizza de style new-yorkais à Montréal!

J'aimerais vraiment aller manger sur place, mais les deux fois, on a commandé en livraison. & honnêtement : la qualité est top, même rendue à la maison.

Pâte bien croustillante, sauce incroyable & des toppings de feu 🔥 Cette fois-ci, on a pris la pepperoni au miel épicé. Avec le dipping ranch… c'était franchement cochon & délicieux.

Je recommande fortement!

Feb 8, 2026
on Google
5.0

Service is brick,t hey treat you like family the second you walk in. But word to mother, this crust is buggin It's thinner than a MetroCard. I'm out here eating cheese & sauce off my lap because the base gave up on life 10/10 for the hospitality, though.

Feb 6, 2026
on Google

vodka pep was a 10/10!

Feb 6, 2026
on Google

best pizza in St-Henri

Feb 2, 2026
on Google

Pizza was phenomenal as always - the vodka cheese was especially fire. Vanessa was incredibly friendly & welcoming; even with the place super packed, service was 10/10. Definitely my go-to pizza spot in MTL!

Jan 31, 2026
on Google

Craving a taste of Brooklyn right in the heart of Mile End? 🍕✨
Pizza Toni on Saint-Viateur is serving up what many call the best New York-style slice outside of NYC. Whether you're grabbing a quick'car slice' or sitting down to a full pie, that signature crunch & slightly sweet sauce are absolute game-changers.
Did you know? 💡 Pizza Toni was founded by the same team behind the legendary Falafel Yoni. To make sure they nailed the authentic NYC vibe, the owners actually trained with seasoned pizzaiolos in Los Angeles & Villeray before opening!
Our personal favorite? The'Grandma' Square Slice. It's thick, rustic, & has those perfectly crisp, burnt edges that every pizza lover dreams of. Pair it with one of their custom house pilsners & you've got the ultimate Montreal lunch. 🍺🗽
Drop a 🍕 in the comments if you're a thin-crust purist or a square-slice devotee!
#MTLfoodie #MontrealPizza #MileEndEats #MTLmoments #PizzaToni
📷 @StayserEats

Jan 30, 2026
on Google

For me the pest pizza

Jan 30, 2026
on Google

Probably the best pizza in MTL + the staff is super chill & friendly

Jan 29, 2026
on Google

Great pepperoni pizza!

Jan 27, 2026
on Google
3.0

Pizza Tony serves a decent New York-style pizza. Some people may find it a bit too oily, but if you enjoy a generously topped pizza that's filling & really sticks with you, it's worth trying.

I've ordered from them several times, & overall I'd say it's average-plus. It's definitely not the best pizza I've ever had, but it gets the job done & is a reliable option when you're craving this style of pizza.

Jan 26, 2026
on Google

C'est trot bon & le service est incroyable

Jan 21, 2026
on Google
5.0

Super bonne pizza ! La pâte est croustillante, moelleuse, & le tout est savoureux 🤤
L'endroit n'est pas grand mais on y est très à l'aise & l'équipe est vraiment aimable :)
Merci pour le bel accueil ! On repassera tester le reste de la carte

Jan 19, 2026
on Google

Yummy! Fav spot to stop at for a good slice of sweet cherry pie :)

Jan 19, 2026
on Google

The pizza was súper cold , delivery about 1 hours , bad experience

Jan 16, 2026
on Google

Best pizza in Montreal🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 keep up the good work 👌

Jan 15, 2026
on Google
5.0

Pizza is really good. Everything is fresh. On the expense side but overall i would recommend.

Jan 15, 2026
on Google

Cet endroit est la meilleure pizzeria de Montréal, étant un amateurs de la pizza style New-York, celle ci me remplie de joie. Le drizzle du miel épicé & des produits de qualités sont une pépite a essayer a tout prix.

Jan 13, 2026
on Google

Probably top 3 pizza I'll ever have in my life

Jan 13, 2026
on Google