Overall, the reviews portray Jack Astor's as a warm, sport-minded casual spot with a lively atmosphere that families and groups enjoy, where food is generally tasty and well prepared and the staff are repeatedly praised for fast, friendly, attentive service; nights with sports on multiple screens can be busy and loud, and price levels are fair for the area, though a few visits note occasional slow service, menu items not meeting expectations, or cleanliness issues in the restrooms. The experience is often described as welcoming and fun, with reliable highlights including generous portions, a variety of dishes, and a convivial vibe that makes it a go-to choice for outings with friends or family, and for watching games.
Great restaurant! Visiting from out of town with the kids. Great drinks & food. First time time trying the loaded poutine & it did not disappoint. Chuck was our waiter & he was phenomenal! Excellent place to visit with the family!
I give this restaurant low star reviews because the quality of the food , the preparation of the food & the service is definitely not worth the price as a family of 4 & with a group of friends .
The chicken goat cheese wrap was packed with so much mayonnaise sauce that the tortilla was soggy underneath, the french fries had so much salt on them!!!
A friend of mine ordered the chicken parmigiana & when she asked the waitress for some cheese on top of her pasta the waitress said it already had some .
I think someone should tell the waitress that when pasta is served at any restaurant in Montreal they usually offer grated parmigiana cheese on top.
Our waitress also had absolutely no idea how the food or the drinks should be served or what type
Of ingredient's are inside any of the dishes .
We ordered a hot brownie with ice cream & the brownie was cold & we told our waitress she simply said , ice cream is always served cold .. lol..lol
4 people we paid $200.00 , for that price it's better to head to your local supermarket & shop a weeks worth of food for your family & cook it to your liking .
We don't mind paying to go out & eat but this was a big disappointment for the whole group . We will definitely not be going back to this location again .
Satisfied, lovely atmosphere, must be great for any type of sports shown on screen. Service wonderful, bar service great too. A little loud for talking but that's to be expected when so busy!
Mar 15, 2026
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Sarah was a very sweet server :) service was fast but nachos had less cheese than usual. Overall nice, specially cuz Sarah was very attentive & practiced her Spanish with us.
Great experience at Jack Astor's! Our server was a true one-man army - super attentive, friendly, & always checking on us to make sure everything was perfect. The service really made our visit special. The pina colada was very good & refreshing. We also loved the garlic bread & nachos; they were absolutely delicious & full of flavor. Everything came out fresh & well prepared. I'll definitely be coming back & highly recommend this place!
