FR
Montreal Restaurants: RestoMontreal.caEaster
RestaurantsGuides & ArticlesEvents

Logo RestoMontreal.ca

Restaurant Top Pick

Il Pagliaccio

Outremont
4.8$$ & $$$
CLOSEDOpens Tuesday at 5:30 pm
Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Saturday
Sunday
Easter: hours might differ
Il Pagliaccio Montreal Restaurant: Menu, Reviews & Reserve (2026)
Italian

Amenities, services & more

Suggested Articles

5★
88%
4★
5%
3★
2%
2★
5%
1★
0%

Mentioned in:

Il Pagliaccio was featured in the article(s) below.

Restaurants in OutremontMore

Brasserie Bernard Restaurant
Rumi Restaurant

Rumi

5198 Rue Hutchison
(1418)
Thammada Restaurant
HELM microbrasserie Restaurant
Tula Restaurant

Tula

5258 Boulevard St-Laurent
(1016)

Reviews for Il Pagliaccio

Food
Service
on Google4.6 (100+)
*as of 2026-04-01
5★
88%
4★
5%
3★
2%
2★
5%
1★
0%

Review Summary

Il Pagliaccio is described as unpretentious with lovely staff and clientele and a sparkling clean setting. Gnocchi are praised as among the best in North America, and the overall food quality with attentive service is a common thread throughout the reviews. When minor flaws appear, such as coffee that is sour or dishes that are a touch salty for some, accommodations are made and a less salty appetizer is offered. The dining experience is repeatedly called wonderful, the best Italian restaurant in Montreal by many, with consistently delicious food, excellent service, and a romantic, intimate atmosphere. The room is noted for calm lighting and a welcoming vibe, and the menu, though concise and changing, covers classics with well prepared pastas, seafood, veal, and wine, while portions can be shared and dishes split as needed. The staff are described as caring and hands-on, and guests appreciate the thoughtful service and value for quality. Repeated visits are common, with the place described as a little Italian gem worth returning to for reliably memorable meals.
Page 1 of 1 - 9 Reviews

The best Italian restaurant in Montreal! We have been there many times, & every time the food is very delicious, the service is always excellent! A great dining experience! Highly recommended

Nov 30, 2025
on Google

Visited this little Italian gem for the very first time.
The owner Manuel is a charming host & suggested a sampling of the various appetizers for the four of us to try. The menu is not large but It was all just great. Tomatoes & burrata, octopus, artichokes, pasta & the main meals branzino & veal piccata. Dessert a lemon tart & lava cake.
This ended up being a wonderfully surprising evening & a new gem to return to.

Aug 10, 2025
on Google

By far the best italian restaurant in Montreal. You can be assured of consistency & high quality.

Apr 29, 2025
on Google
5.0

Very nice Italian. Food is simple & sophisticated. Date & I split each course at the recommendation of our waiter. Great idea. Had two antipasti, pasta, piccata & dessert. Left very full.

Dec 6, 2024
on Google

Was not expecting it all, outstanding service, food & wine pairing, wow this place is worth a detour anytime, a must for any foodie that appreciates fine Italian cuisine!

May 11, 2024
on Google

Authentic italian food with great service. Definitely recommend. 10/10

Feb 10, 2024
on Google

Located on the north side of Laurier (west of Parc) along a stripe with a number of other restaurants, Il Pagliaccio is a more classical type of locale serving traditional Italian cuisine. The style & feel is in keeping with this, with white linen table clothes & many four seating tables & a relatively smallish sized space. In addition, there is an upper level with a private room that would hold from 8 to 20 people. In order to accommodate our party, the restaurant graciously set us up in this room given that it was full on the night of our dinner...so it was an even better meal that expected. For our meal, we enjoyed Endive Salad (a classic...very good), a Beet Salad (also very good), Spaghetti Vongole (very good) & Piccata Limone (with a thicker veal cut, but a smaller portion of vegetables...but still very good). For dessert it was a very nice, although a bit too moist, Tiramisu. Overall a very enjoyable meal with attentive & friendly service. Enjoy!

Oct 26, 2023
on Google

The best Italian restaurant in Montreal. Simple, elegant & consistent. The best quality of ingredients & peak hospitality. Merci Manuel!

Sep 25, 2023
on Google
5.0

Searching for some authentic North Italian fare, we were very pleasantly surprised by the quality of the food as well as the elegance of the service at Il Pagliaccio. Appetizers (ultra tender calamari), mains (melting gnocchi), dessert (brilliant panne cotta!) & their excellent wine choice - not to forget the delicious amuse-bouche brought between courses, made a meal that was both relaxed & yet gastronomically quite exciting.

Sep 15, 2015