Best Italian Restaurants in Outremont (2026) - Reviews & Menus

Explore 4 local dining options, sorted by relevance. You can also view the highest rated or explore the full list.

Il Pagliaccio

Opens Today at 5:30 pm

(56)

Outremont, Mile-End

Italian

Mentioned in: Our Outremont Food Guide: Where to Eat, Drink, and Grab a Sweet Treat

Review Summary

Il Pagliaccio is described as unpretentious with lovely staff and clientele and a sparkling clean setting. Gnocchi are praised as among the best in North America, and the overall food quality with attentive service is a common thread throughout the reviews. When minor flaws appear, such as coffee that is sour or dishes that are a touch salty for some, accommodations are made and a less salty appetizer is offered. The dining experience is repeatedly called wonderful, the best Italian restaurant in Montreal by many, with consistently delicious food, excellent service, and a romantic, intimate atmosphere. The room is noted for calm lighting and a welcoming vibe, and the menu, though concise and changing, covers classics with well prepared pastas, seafood, veal, and wine, while portions can be shared and dishes split as needed. The staff are described as caring and hands-on, and guests appreciate the thoughtful service and value for quality. Repeated visits are common, with the place described as a little Italian gem worth returning to for reliably memorable meals.View restaurant profile

Le Petit Italien

Opens Today at 5 pm

(25)

Outremont

Italian

Review Summary

Le Petit Italien earns high marks for a warm, intimate atmosphere with superb musicians and drinks at reasonable prices, delivering a very enjoyable night. The menu is praised for dishes such as Caesar salad, fried eggplant, fettuccine carbonara, and spaghetti bolognese, with ravioli called a delight and the bolognese described as rich and meaty and a standout for many, though one review notes the pasta was not particularly special. Desserts like tiramisu are noted as really good. Service is described as fast and attentive, and the overall experience is described as a beautiful evening with excellent value, making a return visit likely.View restaurant profile

Pizzéria NO.900

May be temporarily closed

(144)

Outremont

Pizza Pizzeria Italian Gluten-free Options

Mentioned in: Exploring Quebec City's Pizzerias: Our Recommendations 19 Must-Try Food Trucks in Montreal for a True Street Food Experience View More

Review Summary

Overall, reviews describe Pizzéria NO.900 as a place with impeccable service and a warm, welcoming vibe, with an outdoor terrace on a pedestrian street that feels special on sunny days; the menu features fresh Italian style pizzas with a dough that is widely praised for its quality, though the bottom of the crust can be a little burnt, and vegetarian friendly and lactose free options are available. The atmosphere is convivial and the service is noted as fast and attentive even when busy, with consistent quality and good value that make it a repeat choice for many, a pleasant contrast to fast food and a reminder of a real pizzeria experience.View restaurant profile

Pizzeria Magpie

Opens Today at 5 pm

(692)

Mile-End, Outremont

Pizza Italian Pizzeria

Mentioned in: The Best Pizza in Montreal The Best Family-Friendly Restaurants in Montreal: Where to Eat with Kids Year-Round View More

Review Summary

Overall, reviews describe Pizzeria Magpie as a beloved wood fired Neapolitan spot with a warm, cozy vibe, where the pizzas and fresh ingredients shine and the service is frequently praised as attentive and friendly; many note standout pies like Mortadella, Diavola, and other creative options, along with good cocktails and a well received limoncello surprise, while some diners mention a few rough patches such as long waits at peak times, a hot room or variable AC, and occasional menu items that don’t hit as hard or feel limited; the dough quality and oven mastery are repeatedly cited as key strengths, and several readers call it among the best pizza places in Montreal and worth the trip, with high marks for atmosphere, desserts, and overall value.View restaurant profile