Monday

Closed

Tuesday

5:30 pm - 10 pm

Wednesday

5:30 pm - 10 pm

Thursday

12 pm - 2:30 pm, 5:30 pm - 10 pm

Friday

12 pm - 2:30 pm, 5:30 pm - 10 pm

Saturday

5:30 pm - 10 pm

Sunday

Closed

Il Pagliaccio is described as unpretentious with lovely staff and clientele and a sparkling clean setting. Gnocchi are praised as among the best in North America, and the overall food quality with attentive service is a common thread throughout the reviews. When minor flaws appear, such as coffee that is sour or dishes that are a touch salty for some, accommodations are made and a less salty appetizer is offered. The dining experience is repeatedly called wonderful, the best Italian restaurant in Montreal by many, with consistently delicious food, excellent service, and a romantic, intimate atmosphere. The room is noted for calm lighting and a welcoming vibe, and the menu, though concise and changing, covers classics with well prepared pastas, seafood, veal, and wine, while portions can be shared and dishes split as needed. The staff are described as caring and hands-on, and guests appreciate the thoughtful service and value for quality. Repeated visits are common, with the place described as a little Italian gem worth returning to for reliably memorable meals.

Reviews for Il Pagliaccio

Food

Service

on Google4.6 (100+)

*as of 2026-04-01

4.8 56 ratings

5★

88%

4★

3★

2★

1★

Write your review

Reviews often mention

Display All vin(10) prix(9) italian(9) italien(6) dessert(6) qualite(5) recommend(5) appetizer(4) quality(4) highly recommend(3) ingredients(3) gnocchi(3)

Review Summary

Page 1 of 1 - 7 Reviews

Ted

5.0

The opposite of pretentious, lovely staff & clientèle. Super clean. The gnocchi were the first excellent gnocchi I've had in North America. My wife loved this place. Service was excellent. On the imperfect side, the coffee served was way sour, the food salty for the salt-sensitive. That said, they accomodated & gave us a less salty appetizer ; we will definitely return & recommend it.

Feb 6, 2026

on Google

Yannis

The best Italian restaurant in Montreal! We have been there many times, & every time the food is very delicious, the service is always excellent! A great dining experience! Highly recommended

Nov 30, 2025

Martine

Vraiment un resto où l on se sent complètement ailleurs. Mon mari étant sicilien a adoré ce resto sympa & accueillant. C'est un des meilleurs restos qu' il a visité depuis longtemps à Montréal. L ambiance, le service, la bouffe & le vin tout était parfait. Petites lumières tamisées & ambiance romantique. Je vous le recommande fortement. Merveilleux endroit pour un petit souper à deux.

Sep 25, 2025

Amanda

What a great restaurant! Went twice & will surely go back soon ! The owner Manuele is so caring & kind. The food is outstanding & so is the service. Highly recommend place!

Jul 10, 2025

Donato

Great restaurant Highly recommended!

Feb 25, 2024

Andrew

Authentic italian food with great service. Definitely recommend. 10/10

Feb 10, 2024

Foodie

1 Review

Nourriture délicieuse. La cuisson du loup de mer a été parfaite à chacune de nos visites. Que dire du porcelet qui est succulent! L'accueil du proprio est très chaleureux. Ses recommandations pour le choix des vins ont toujours été justes, nous avons fait de belles découvertes. Le fondant au chocolat est à se damner!

Dec 27, 2014

SuggestionsMore

Viva Restaurant + Bar

Birbante

InformationError?

Restaurants NearbyMore

La Petite Marche

Le Bleu Raisin

Monsieur B (B pour Bistro)

Artigiani Pizzeria Cucina

La Buvette du Dep

Le Roseline

Mirazu

Pamika Thai

Barranco MTL

Clébard

Suggested Articles

Mentioned in:

Restaurants in OutremontMore

Events NearbyMore

Related Links

Review Summary