Gibby's serves as a destination for prime cuts of beef and fresh seafood within a historic stone building defined by wood-burning fireplaces and dark wood accents. The menu focuses on dry-aged steaks that are trimmed on-site, alongside Atlantic salmon, rainbow trout, and oysters harvested from cold waters. Traditional sides such as baked potatoes, pickles, and sourdough bread accompany the primary meat and fish courses. Patrons encounter a multi-room layout that maintains an atmosphere of seclusion and warmth through its thick stone walls and low ceilings. The culinary preparation emphasizes classic grilling techniques over open flames to achieve specific textures and flavor profiles. Every selection of seafood undergoes rigorous sourcing standards to ensure consistency across the entire menu. This establishment functions as a dedicated center for meat and aquatic offerings in a centralized urban environment.
Does Gibby's have a private room for group events or parties?
Yes, Gibby's offers a private room available for group dining, private parties, corporate meetings, and special celebrations. Contact the restaurant directly to discuss availability and group menus.
Gibby's is widely celebrated as a quintessential Montreal steakhouse, cherished for its historic atmosphere, elegant decor, and traditional charm housed within a beautifully preserved centuries-old building. Many patrons praise the restaurant for its exceptional service, noting that staff often go above and beyond to create memorable experiences for birthdays and anniversaries. The menu is frequently lauded for its generous portions, high-quality steaks, signature Beef Wellington, and unique touches like fresh bread, pickles, and palate-cleansing sorbet. While some guests have noted inconsistencies in food preparation or service quality during busier times, the overall consensus among regular visitors and first-time guests alike highlights the establishment as a reliable and iconic destination for a classic fine dining experience in Old Montreal.
Our meal was delicious & prepared to perfection. The crispy fries were amazing.. Our server Catherine was attentive & exuberant. She was knowledgeable & clearly passionate about the restaurant. Our water glasses were refilled promptly albeit with quite a bit of spillage. ( ignore the half eaten pickle in the photo ) note - the bathrooms are downstairs or upstairs so this may be a problem for those with mobility issues & weak bladders.
Dining at Gibby's Steakhouse feels like stepping into history-in the best possible way. Housed in a beautiful 200-year-old building, the atmosphere alone sets it apart & gives the entire experience a timeless charm.
It's easy to see how this restaurant has maintained its reputation for over 55 years. The steaks are done to absolute perfection-expertly cooked, flavorful, & exactly what you hope for when you sit down for a classic steakhouse meal.
A special mention to our waiter, Kashra, who was incredibly charming & attentive. He added a personal touch to the evening that made the experience even more enjoyable.
Between the historic setting, exceptional food, & warm service, Gibby's delivers on every level. A true Montreal staple & well worth the visit.
Dining at Gibbys is one of those classic Montreal experiences that really lives up to the hype. From the moment you walk into the historic stone building in Old Montreal, the atmosphere feels warm, elegant, & timeless. The rustic charm mixed with white tablecloth service sets the tone for a proper steakhouse night.
The highlight, without a doubt, was the steak. Cooked perfectly to temperature, it was tender, juicy, & packed with flavor. You can tell they use high-quality cuts & treat them with care-no unnecessary fuss, just a well-executed steak done right. Every bite was consistent & satisfying, exactly what you hope for when ordering at a place known for steak.
The sides complemented the meal nicely, & the service was attentive without being overbearing. It felt like the staff genuinely cared about the dining experience, which added to the overall enjoyment.
Gibbys strikes a great balance between upscale dining & comfort. It's the kind of place you go for a special occasion or when you simply want a guaranteed great meal. If you're in Montreal & craving a proper steak, this spot should be high on your list.
Gibby's is one of those places you've heard about forever, almost myth-like in reputation… long before you ever actually go. For me, it had been sitting in that category for years.
With my brother visiting (a true steak connoisseur), it finally felt like the right time. I booked a table for five on OpenTable a few weeks in advance for a 7:45 seating… no issues at all.
From the moment we arrived, the experience felt dialed in. We were seated right on time, service was immediate, & the evening flowed exactly the way you hope a place like Gibby's will deliver.
What I Liked:
Service was a standout. Attentive, engaged, but never hovering or interrupting. Drinks came quickly, orders were taken efficiently, & everything arrived with great timing.
A really nice touch to start the meal was the bread & pickles brought to the table. The bread was light, fluffy, & fresh with a great texture, & the pickles were a hit around the table… simple, but done right.
Food-wise, we leaned into what Gibby's is known for… steak.
• The rib steak was exactly what you want it to be: cooked perfectly, rich, & deeply satisfying.
• Wedge salad & Monte Carlo potatoes rounded things out well.
• Across the table, rib eyes, filet, clam chowder, carpaccio-most dishes fully met expectations.
Now… did I need a 20 oz rib steak? Absolutely not.
Did I regret it? Only later that night, when my stomach started filing complaints.
In the moment? Not a chance. Plate cleaned. No survivors.
A fun highlight was the Spanish coffee service, rolled out tableside with a bit of fire & flair. A small touch, but one that adds to the overall experience.
& oddly… even the bill stood out. Thick, high-quality paper. It sounds ridiculous, but it actually matched the overall feel of the place… attention to detail, even at the very end.
That said, one miss worth noting, my wife's peppercorn steak was significantly undercooked & came out rare instead of the medium she ordered, & she found it a bit tough. She didn't say anything at the time (not in her nature), & I'm confident they would have corrected it quickly had we raised it. Still, at this price point, you expect it to land right the first time.
Atmosphere & Vibe:
We were seated in the basement dining room (one of three levels). I joked it might be the'ugly people section,' but in reality it was the opposite, just a great mix of people.
Families, date nights, multi-generational celebrations, groups like ours… it felt lively but not overwhelming. You could actually have a conversation without shouting, which isn't always a given in a busy steakhouse.
The building itself adds a lot. Historic Old Montréal charm, heavy wood, warm lighting-it feels like a place with stories in the walls.
Closing:
Gibby's delivers exactly what its reputation promises: a classic, high-quality steakhouse experience done right.
It's not cheap, but it's not trying to be. This is a place for occasions. Celebrations. When you want to lean in a little & enjoy it.
Would I go every week? No.
Would I go again? Absolutely, when the moment calls for it.
A couple small notes:
• No mashed potatoes (surprisingly missed by a few at the table, especially for softer options)
• Not exactly vegetarian-friendly… but that shouldn't come as a shock
At the end of the day, Gibby's is about steak, tradition, & experience & it delivers on all three, even if not every plate lands perfectly.
We went for my daughter's 40th birthday. Everything was better than 5 star. Our server James was over the top, very attentive with our needs , lovely personality & engaging. We had a fabulous time & all our food was Perfact!
We absolutely love Gibby's. It's been our go-to spot for every special occasion for years, & it never disappoints.
From the moment you walk in, you feel genuinely welcomed. The atmosphere is warm & classic, & the service is consistently attentive without ever feeling overdone.
The steak is always on point, perfectly cooked, high quality, & exactly what you expect every time. That consistency is what keeps us coming back.
This place has become part of our traditions, & we'll definitely continue going for years to come.
We had an amazing lunch at Gibbys today. The food was excellent, but our server, Vitali, really made the experience special. His service was outstanding-attentive, professional, & friendly. Highly recommend!
Went last week with my friends & absolutely loved the atmosphere , the decor was as if we went back in times with a touch of modernity. The drinks were great & our sirloin steak were cooked perfectly but the service of our server Benafsha was amazing ,very attentive service . Would definitely come back
Gibby's is by far one of the best restaurants we have ever been to. From the amazing architecture to the romantic atmosphere. Our Server, Justin, provided attentive & personal service, ensuring that our entire experience was the best it could possibly be. In addition to the best steak we have ever had, the Old Fashioned was tough to beat. While the cost was high, we truly got what we paid for & would do it again. This is a must for anyone in Montreal.
If you're looking for a classic, upscale steakhouse experience in Old Montreal, Gibbys absolutely delivers.
From the moment you step inside, the historic stone walls & warm lighting create an elegant, intimate atmosphere that feels timeless. It's the kind of place that's perfect for anniversaries, client dinners, or a refined night out.
The food is outstanding. The steaks are cooked perfectly to temperature - tender, flavorful, & expertly seasoned. The lobster is fresh & beautifully presented, & the sides are generous & satisfying. Everything feels thoughtfully prepared & high quality.
Service is another highlight. The staff are professional, attentive, & knowledgeable without being intrusive. They guide you through the menu & wine list with confidence, making the whole evening feel seamless.
Yes, it's on the premium side price-wise, but the quality, ambiance, & consistency make it worth it. Gibbys is a true Montreal classic - & for good reason.
Highly recommended for anyone who appreciates a traditional steakhouse done right.
