Gibby's

Christopher

5.0

Finding a steakhouse that serves world-class steaks is one thing; finding one that can seamlessly handle a bachelor party of 14 guys without missing a beat is a rare miracle. From the moment we walked in, the staff treated us like royalty. Usually, a group of our size gets shoved into a cramped corner or stuck with agonizingly slow service, but the hospitality here was incredibly sharp, fast, & accommodating.

The pictures of the food don't do it justice. We got a seafood tower (forgot to take that picture), delicious salad, & naturally a steak cooked to perfection. To accompany the food, the cocktails were superb. The old fashions & espresso martinis kept coming. Just make sure you leave room for their cheesecake.

Mike

5.0

You haven't experienced Montreal unless you had dinner at Gibbys. Everything was perfection!!! Boston Mike

Laureen

1.0

We really wanted to enjoy a meal here. My daughter & I came to Montreal for a girls night out & made a reservation at Gibbys. There was a nice gentleman who served us water told us'JP' will be by to serve us shortly - only he never showed up. We sat for twenty minutes without taking even our drink order- the table next to us was seated after our arrival & served their drinks. We gave up after twenty minutes & went to the Keg which was great. The gentleman who served us our water felt bad for us & assured us JP was told we were here but we just had a bad taste in our mouths at that point.

Jessica

5.0

Went to Gibby's as a group of four. The food & service were impeccable. Our waitress Genevieve was charismatic, & made great recommendations. She ensured to accommodate dietary restrictions, which was very important to us. She also explained the Gibby's classics to us, which was a nice touch.

The food was excellent. To my knowledge Gibby's is one of only two restaurants in Montreal where you can get beef wellington. I've been to the other restaurant too, & I must say that Gibby's is well worth the expense. Although both are excellent, Gibby's has a ton of sides included, & it makes the price worth it for sure. The portions are also generous where you are actually leaving feeling full without having to break the bank.

For Atmosphere I gave four stars as we were sat at a round table for 5 instead of four, which made it hard to share plates & it felt like we were screaming across each other. The table was also right in the waitstaff's path, & at one point a full table was lifted overhead. Otherwise it was a fine atmosphere!

Kayla

5.0

The waitress Sarah is one of the kindest , reliable & professional woman. I always recommend Sarah as a waitress because I know my experience will be exceptional. Sarah makes gibbys a wonderful experience & I appreciate her & her work.

Aurelie

1.0

je suis allée manger à votre restaurant, & à plusieurs reprise, j'ai eu la serveuse alicia. chaque fois que c'est elle, je n'ai pas un bon service. elle est très arrogante & ne semble pas aimer son travail

Sawdusty

2.0

Ambiance has certainly declined over the years. Filet Mignons (2) & salads were average at best. Service is above average. Prices are twice what they should be for the overall experience.

Evette

4.0

Atmosphere is good & food is pretty good. Unfortunately, there was a crying child crawling on the floor when we went but that's not Gibbys staff's fault.

Appetizers
The highlight to me was the pickle. Unfortunately, one of them was quite soft, but the other one was crunchy & delicious.

The fresh bread is great. The salad was great with lots of different flavors & the croutons & fresh.
The sorbet was a refreshing palate cleanser but honestly could have done without.

Mains
We ordered the 16 oz filet minion. It was cooked well & the meat was tender.

We also got the salmon filet. I found it to be quite salty & taste very heavy.

The vegetables were just okay & the twice baked potato was delicious.

Overall it was a nice time. I would consider coming back but I personally would probably order regular seasoning instead of the montreal steak spice.

Lorne

1.0

The food is not the same as when the Rosenbergs where operating.
the beef is LOW grade!

Natasha

4.0

Service excellence, food it's delicious
& experience too much