Reviews portray Pizzeria Magpie as a place with delicious pizza and daily specials that land well, featuring wood fired crusts, fresh ingredients, and creative toppings that make each visit feel special. The atmosphere is warm and cozy with friendly service and good wines and cocktails that elevate the evening. Standout items like meatballs, mortadella, and inventive pies are frequently mentioned, while some guests note changes to the dough that affected texture or flavor. A few experiences note slower service during peak times, but hospitality and overall quality remain highly regarded. Celebrations and gatherings with friends are often described as memorable, and many say they will return to explore more of the menu. There are occasional comments about temperature or timing issues and a desire for a bit more variety, yet the pizza and experience are consistently praised, and gluten-free options are regarded by some as among the best they've had.
Bon & chouette ambiance par contre la proximité avec les autres clients est insultante. Vous pourriez probablement enlever un bon 3 tables... pour cette raison je ne retournerai pas.
Oct 13, 2024
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
We came without reservation & they took us in , staff is welcoming & professional , service was fast , the pizza is delicious , the atmosphere is very nice & cozy, I definitely recommend this restaurant.
Une de mes pizzerias préférées! J'adore leurs choix de pizzas a saveurs parfois hors de l'ordinaire! La pâte est parfaite! L'atmosphère est très cozy. Le service aurait pu être plus attentif - jai parfois eu de la misère a faire de contacts visuels avec serveurs pour leur faire signe que javaos besoin de quelque chose (huile épicée, de l'eau etc). Malgré ce point je compte y retourner une 2e fois.
Everything was amazing the food, the atmosphere the staff!!! This was our first time eating here & we will definitely come again the next time we are in Montreal!!!! Such a great restaurant!!
Aug 24, 2024
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
True Neapolitan pizza. Ordered the Margherita. Ingredients used are too quality. Centre of pizza not liquidy/runny like some places do. Unfortunately, parts of crust were burnt. Some say charred & like this. My preference is for a well-cooked crust without black on either top or bottom. Perhaps pizzaiolo needs to pay bit more attention to turning the pizza? This is a small pizzeria. Gets very loud inside. Especially when children or toddlers around. Also, the A/C in the room did not seem to keep up with the heat coming from ovens. Sweltering inside & it wasn't a particularly hot day outside.
Glad they changed the chef there. Been there a few times in the past few months & had great pizza & surprisingly a few excellent pastas. Will definitely return
Les pizzas sont excellentes les vins rouges sont assez bon aussi, le service est impeccable les filles sont super attentionnées. La salle est magnifique, j'aime beaucoup ce décor. Cependant les anglophones qui fréquente ce lieu te crient à l'oreille toute la soirée, c'est insupportable de ne pas s'entendre à 30 cm de son conjoint. Nous ne reviendrons plus lorsque la salle est pleine.
Les pizzas sont vraiment excellentes ! Dommage que le restaurant mette trop de tables donc on est vraiment proche des autres & c'est extrêmement bruyant, ce n'est pas agréable.
I was super happy with Magpie. I normally hate tomato based sauce but the meatball appetizer is something out of heaven. The pizzas are also perfection!
The food itself is good. It's mainly pizza as you would except this little Italian restaurant. I find however that prices are a bit expensive in comparison to other restaurant around. For a basic margarita pizza at 20$, I feel like I could eat more & better elsewhere. However, price aside, it's still very good. It feels like a pizza from Naples, but here in Montreal. There are plently of options depending on how you feel.
Usually excellent, maybe my favorite, since I love Italian style pizza for the thick crust. But occasionally it seems they burn the heck out of the crust til it's black, which is unfortunate.
