Reviews portray Pizzeria Magpie as a place with delicious pizza and daily specials that land well, featuring wood fired crusts, fresh ingredients, and creative toppings that make each visit feel special. The atmosphere is warm and cozy with friendly service and good wines and cocktails that elevate the evening. Standout items like meatballs, mortadella, and inventive pies are frequently mentioned, while some guests note changes to the dough that affected texture or flavor. A few experiences note slower service during peak times, but hospitality and overall quality remain highly regarded. Celebrations and gatherings with friends are often described as memorable, and many say they will return to explore more of the menu. There are occasional comments about temperature or timing issues and a desire for a bit more variety, yet the pizza and experience are consistently praised, and gluten-free options are regarded by some as among the best they've had.
One of my favourite neighbourhood places to bring my kids. The restaurant was not busy at all, my kids were hungry & it took close to an hour for the kitchen to produce 1 margarita pizza. I have worked in many restaurants in my life & can relate & sympathize when things are going wrong in the kitchen but our waiter was not transparent that our order was going to take longer than usual. The draft beer was not working, nor did they have the cookie & ice cream dessert on the menu available ( also not mentioned ) ~ Used to be an institution for my family...what happened ?
Aug 10, 2023
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Incredible pizza & the staff & service were even better - efficient, friendly & kind with a sense of humor. If I lived in Montreal, Magpie would be my go-to for a pie & glass of wine. The dum-dums were a fun touch! We had a great evening. Thanks for the memory!
Nous voulions une bonne vraie pizza italienne, un bon verre de vin & une ambiance cool. On a eu tout ça avec en plus le sourire & la gentillesse du personnel. Un délice & une parfaite soirée à 2 sans les enfants!
Jul 17, 2023
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Excellent service, excellentes pizzas. Décor agréable, rue tranquille. Boissons gazeuses excessivement chères étant donné qu'elles sont en fontaine & qu'il n'y a pas un seul remplissage gratuit.
Les pizzas étaient plus que délicieuses. Toute ma famille était ravie d'avoir découvert ce petit bijou de notre quartier. Un gros merci à toute l'équipe & à notre gentille serveuse Clara.
Waitress was knowledgeable, fully bilingual & very sweet! The drinks were amazing!! &, our food was fantastic!!! Bartender was just as good as our waitress & even came to our table to make sure we liked our drinks after a misunderstanding on an initial order 👌
