Pizza Toni

Shashank

5.0

One of the best pizzarias I've been to. They have unique speciality slices every day, like mushroom & Parm Eggplant. Slices tastes amazing; feels like a NYC slice with its light crust plus the tomato sauce is tangy & fresh. The location also has a hand washing station inside, which is nice after finishing your food. Overall, Pizza Toni sells tasty pizza.

Sam

4.0

Had a very nice slice of pizza the first time. But this second time the pizza was dry & wasn't as good because it felt like the pizza was on the shelf for a while... Maybe it was a one time thing But def worth coming back since our first experience was really good. def recommended to come try here. could be hard to find because the sign outside isn't pizza Toni. it's like a gum commercial on top of the pizza place. I guess that's what gives it the charm. very popular place so be patient if you go in peak hours. pizzas are decently priced. more on the high side.

Navin

5.0

Legit pizza. It's real close to a New York slice. I had the pep. The sauce (which had a little bite to it), pepperoni & cheese were definitely quality ingredients. I found it a tiny bit too thin but incredible nonetheless. I ordered for pickup & even 45 minutes after the order I waited another 15. They get slammed & hammer out pizzas as fast as they can but do yourself a favor & show up even later than the estimate at peak times so you're not waiting around. Team making pizzas & Nolan running the cash move quick. What a great option...

Raghav

5.0

Best pizza slice in Montreal... NY STYLE!

Deanne

5.0

I happened upon Pizza Toni, & even though I just got jerk chicken down the street I came in for a slice... really well done ny style marg slice: thin, crispy bottom & a good level of acid on the sauce. After that I got a square to go, not usually my style but 10/10 would do again. Vibes are dope, hand washing sink...really thoughtful.

Alexander

4.0

Slow service at lunch times. Staff take order & not much else. Takeaway pizzas are a different size to those on display for single serve sale. Paying a margin for the novelty of big slices. Gets busy.

Dryden

4.0

Margherita slice was midlevel. On the dry side.

Brittany

5.0

You won't find a better slice in Montreal.

David

5.0

This pizza is really special. Super thin, crispy crust, with perfect pepperoni & cheese... But their CONSISTENCY is what's truly impressive: It's a quality slice, every single time. "10/10 would recommend" - don't trust the ridiculous 1-star reviews :)

Meeps

4.0

Solid slice, ill give it an 8.2. It's a little light on the sauce but the crust has a beautiful char on it. If you're looking for a NY style pizza in town, this is a great choice