Reviews paint Tuck Shop as a destination for exceptional food, warm attentive service, and a lively yet intimate atmosphere, with a consistently rotating, seasonal menu that highlights local ingredients and thoughtful pairing of elements; diners praise standout dishes such as hanger steak, pork belly, oysters, octopus, duck duo, and desserts, along with impressive plating and wine knowledge from the staff. The team is repeatedly described as friendly, professional, and genuinely caring, capable of accommodating private functions and offering experiences at the chef's counter or chalet, contributing to a sense of being welcomed into a modern kitchen. A few critiques surface about loud environments and occasional pacing or pricing concerns, and some guests note menu changes that can affect expectations, but these are outweighed by the overall impression of quality, consistency, and value for those celebrating special occasions or seeking a special night out. Overall, it is regarded as a Montreal gem with reliable excellence in both food and service that draws guests back again and again.
Went for Valentine's day. They had a set menu & sat us in the back'terrace' which was a little cabin with space heaters. I had been a couple time before & its always been great, but this time was exceptional. Everything we ate just melted in your mouth & blew us away!
When I landed in mtl about a year ago this is the first place I took my partner to celebrate our new start. To this day it stands out as the best meal I've had in the city & I think that says quite a bit.
Mar 28, 2025
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Came here for a girls night, very cute setting, with a small but yummy menu. Staff is attentive & friendly & happy to answer questions & provide recommendations. As someone with celiac, I wouldn't recommend due to cross contamination & the options were limited. However, for a regular person, definitely worth trying. The highlight of the dinner was the pork belly, absolutely delicious!
My husband & I had an absolutely delicious meal at Tuck Shop. We sat at the Chef's Table, which is always a fun experience for a restaurant to offer (I love an open kitchen). Gabriel, our server, was very attentive - as was the bartender & the rest of the staff. The food was incredible, & all was plated SO beautifully - Michelin star level plating. We started with oysters, & loved their specialty hot sauce that they had on the side. We then split the grilled octopus (which was so tender & not at all chewy like you sometimes get), the pork belly (which came in the most incredible sauce), the Duck Duo (yum!), & the Chocolate Nemesis dessert - which was the only thing I managed to take a picture of. We left with very happy stomachs. Highly recommend!
Tuck Shop used to be one of our favorite spots-we always loved the food, the ambiance, & the overall experience. Unfortunately, something has changed, & our recent visit left us extremely disappointed.
From the moment we sat down, we felt rushed through our entire three-course meal. Our $100 bottle of wine was repeatedly poured high, seemingly to encourage faster consumption. As we were slowly savoring our last glass, we were abruptly informed that we couldn't order a cocktail to finish our evening because we needed to vacate the table in five minutes & jackets were delivered to our chairs, which were quickly taken back when I asked to first finish my wine glass.
The worst part? We were only given 1 hour & 15 minutes to enjoy a full three-course meal & a bottle of wine-an experience that should have felt indulgent & enjoyable, not pressured & hurried. Meanwhile, two other couples were there before us & still enjoying a coffee & dessert while we had to go. For a pricy evening, it was one of the most dissatisfying dining experiences we've had in a long time.
If you value a relaxed & well-paced dining experience, I'd recommend looking elsewhere. We won't be returning anytime soon.
Mar 1, 2025
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
The service is nothing short of impeccable, making you feel truly welcomed from the moment you arrive. The culinary offerings are absolutely divine & will leave your taste buds dancing with delight.
The hanger steak is an essential choice-it's one of the best steaks I've ever savored, cooked to perfection with a rich, mouthwatering flavor that simply melts in your mouth!
& don't overlook the desserts; they are truly extraordinary, each one a sweet masterpiece that rounds off the meal beautifully.
The atmosphere is equally captivating, creating a vibrant & lively vibe that enhances the entire dining experience.
We really wanted to eat here & we didn't get to because of an unexpected delay. We were not able to make the reservations we made but they were understanding & helped us book for another time. Without even trying their food we can tell they care about the customer experience. Thank you.
The best restaurant in Montreal, hands down. Never never never fails, always the best food, great staff, great atmosphere. One of those establishments where you know you'll have a good time, no matter the day or time a year. I have come here so many times over the years, & it never fails. Better than many other high-end establishments of Montreal. Cannot recommend enough.
One of my favourite restaurants in Montreal! The dishes are amazing, & the ambiance is welcoming & warm. The service is also exceptional.
If you're looking for an upscale dining experience, without the stuffy interior that tends to come with fine dining, I highly recommend Tuckshop. Plus, they're open on Mondays.
This is the real deal. Pork belly was wonderful with a Gouda sauce. Duck with foir gras was nuts. Nice scallop crudo. Excellent creme brulee. Wonderful service. Great manager. Worth the trip to that part of town
Food was pretty good. The sommelier was trying to upsell me on getting the more expensive wine to "impress my clients" not knowing that it was just a company meal. Kinda weird!
Wonderful reunion, delicious food & really great service! Jonathan Metcalfe is creative & attentive towards his customers. A superb evening at the Tuck Shop make me happy!
Jan 29, 2025
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
TUCK SHOP is an absolute gem! The espresso martini here is simply the best I've ever had - perfectly crafted & absolutely delicious thanks Karly! Huge thanks to the staff for being so warm & attentive, Gabriel for his fantastic sense of humor that added a special touch to the evening, & Jérémie for the gallant & gracious welcome. The team truly goes above & beyond to create an amazing dining experience. I can't wait to come back!
Un délice du début à la fin. L'endroit est superbe, la nourriture est délicieuse & exécutée à la perfection, l'ambiance est chaleureuse & le staff est incroyablement attentionné. Un gros merci à notre serveur. Nous y retournerons!
Came here for a New Year's Eve dinner - amazing service & one of the best salads I've had in my life! However the focaccia was a total miss & $95 for a piece of mid-quality filet mignon was questionable - generally left feeling that it would have been an amazing meal if it had been 20% cheaper.
