Overall, Tuck Shop earns praise for fresh, flavorful dishes across a versatile menu, with oysters and the housemade hot sauce often highlighted as memorable, and service described as attentive in a warm, welcoming atmosphere; some visits note the space can be loud at peak hours and a few dishes feel imbalanced or overfussy, but the fish and the duck regularly read as standouts and desserts like chocolate espresso cake and coconut cream pie are favorites. The kitchen is commended for thoughtful plating and seasonal changes that keep the menu exciting, while prices are sometimes considered high and a few guests felt certain meals did not fully land. Still, many leave inspired and eager to return, thanks to strong guidance from staff, a lively open kitchen vibe, and consistently high hospitality.
Très mauvaise expérience. On était six personnes & à l'unanimité on a été très déçu. Je suis une habituée des restaurants gastronomique & c'est la première fois que je vie ça. Pour le prix, la nourriture n'est pas satisfaisante. La côte de boeuf minuscule, les frites tellement salées qu'on n'a pu les manger. On voulait en commander sans sel mais ils ne sont jamais revenus nous voir après nous avoir servi. La truite ok mais sans plus. Si au moins l'expérience service avait été bien tu as un bon souvenir mais là épouvantable. Pas de bonjour, pas de sourire, vite vite on te sert & on ne revient plus. On était du 1er service alors on sait qu'on doit quitter à une certaine heure. Mais là on c'est fait carrément jeter dehors de façon cavalière. Sans désolé, sans merci…une table à 1500$. Le pire est qu'on a commandé un dernier verre de vin pour terminer la soirée, ils nous servent & nous mettent dehors, on n'a pas eu le temps de le boire, dehors, mais ils on eu le temps de le facturer 18$ le verre. Ouf on va s'en rappeler mais pas pour les bonnes raisons. On en a parlé au gérant mais honnêtement il avait l'air de s'en fouter complètement. A oublier & vite!
Great first experience at Tuck Shop - Amazing food backed by excellent service & atmosphere. Kudos to the chefs & team, will be back for the Pork Belly!
Feb 9, 2026
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Last night I, along with several friends, had the great pleasure of dining with you. Every aspect of our experience was exemplary & we enjoyed our meals immensely.
On leaving I realised that I had left my shirt/jacket at the table. Liam returned it too me at Honey Martin later in the evening. I cannot thank him enough for his kindness.
I have worked in the service industry my entire life & know that the service we received is not as commonplace as it once was.
Once again I thank you & I look forward to joining you on future visits to Montreal.
Incroyable du début à la fin!
Les plats étaient absolument délicieux & pleins de saveurs. On sent la qualité des ingrédients & le souci du détail dans chaque bouchée. Le service était chaleureux, attentionné, & l'ambiance vraiment agréable. Une expérience wow que je recommande sans hésiter!
An experience that stays with you long after the last bite. Absolute perfection.
Behind every great experience is a great leadership team!
You can feel the love & passion the moment you walk in, it's in the energy, the rhythm, the care.
The attention to detail is everywhere: plates arriving together like a perfectly timed choreography, each one beautifully composed. You want to taste everything on the menu.
The originality, the thoughtfulness, the pairing of ingredients, the assemblage, the visual presentation, each dish feels intentional, crafted, alive. DELICIOUS!
Thank you Johny for your impeccable service, Antoine for the heart you bring to your cooking, & the entire team for creating such a memorable experience. This is an experience to be lived & relived.
Une des meilleures expériences culinaires que j'ai eu le plaisir de vivre: les mets étaient exceptionnels, les vins proposés l'étaient tout autant & que dire du service!
Jan 25, 2026
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Un super resto! Les plats sont délicieux! Super ambiance ! Vraiment cool de voir les chefs dans la cuisine ;) Bravo à Antoine pour ton professionnalisme 🧑?🍳
This was my first visit & I was extremely impressed. Came out for dinner with my wife. The staff was extremely nice, polite , professional & efficient. The food was unbelievable. I don't usually rave about a place but everything we had was delicious. From the brioche bread. The oysters, tuna crudo & the beet salad as appetizers. Main dish was the duck & the bolognese pasta was incredible. Definitely recommend! My compliments to the chefs & the staff. Keep up the great work !
EXCELLENT! TOUT !!!
Un des meilleurs restos de Montréal. Nous étions 6 & nous sommes unanimes WOW.
Délicieux, portions généreuses, services chaleureux & professionnels !
Une équipe passionnée dans la cuisine! Mention spécial à Antoine qui nous a préparé des entrées exceptionnelles!
Impossible de résister au dessert;) Chaudement recommandé !
Simply amazing ! The food was delicious! Exceptional service as well by Johnny & the staff from the minute we walked in to when we left. The cozy vibe was just right to top it off!
Fantastic experience. The food was excellent. Wonderful ambience. & the service was next level. Would definitely recommend. Will most certainly come again.
This place is so underrated. Portions are generous so you don't end up spending as much as you think. Menu changes weekly. Such high quality service, prep & ingredients.
Jan 13, 2026
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Been a while since I was that impressed by a kitchen. The flavor profil is amazing, the service was one of the best i had in town & the all vibe was awsome.
We'd give it a 4.5 but this rating system doesn't allow for that. Tuck Shop was great. The service was amazing. We literally tried every appetizer, entree & dessert & everythwas delicious. It's a seasonal menu that seems to change every so often & everything was very fresh. We also loved the ambiance. While we requested the main dining room, we were out in the chalet section which was actually great & quieter than the other room. We'll be back!
J'ai longtemps apprécié ce restaurant mais mes 3 dernières visites ont été plutôt décevante & la dernière est simplement digne d'un review négatif. Le service est particulièrement en déclin; nous avons commandé des apéritifs qui ont mal été distribués à la table, lorsque nous avons (très poliment) demandé de revérifier si nous avions chacun le bon apéro on nous a invité à se lever & demander au bar tender s'il avait fait une erreur! Je n'ai jamais vu ce genre d'attitude dans un restaurant. S'en sont suivi des oublis de plats, aucune attention à la satisfaction des bouchées, on m'a enlevé mon verre de vin duquel je me gardais 2 gorgées pour terminer mon repas (sans me demander si j'avais terminé!) & la touche finale, les plats & sauces sont tellement riches (mais délicieux) que personne de mon groupe n'a digéré le repas & avons passé une nuit d'indigestions assez incommodantes. Dommage!
