FR
Montreal Restaurants: RestoMontreal.caMontreal Restaurants: RestoMontreal.ca

Logo RestoMontreal.ca

0
×
Loading filters...
Restaurant Top Pick

Pizza Toni

Authentic New York style pizza slices reimagined in the heart of Mile End.

Mile-End
4.5$
OPEN11:30 am - 9 pm
Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Saturday
Sunday
Photo of Pizza Toni, Mile-End - Montreal
Pizza
Owner? Claim the listing Our Services
Loading suggestions...

About

Pizza Toni specializes in the authentic craft of hand-stretched dough and high-quality toppings prepared within a traditional stone oven. The menu focuses on the fundamental elements of artisanal pizza, utilizing fresh ingredients to create balanced flavor profiles across a variety of classic and contemporary styles. Each pie features a signature thin, blistered crust that provides a distinctively crispy texture while remaining light enough to highlight the house-made tomato sauce and premium mozzarella. The establishment maintains a streamlined kitchen workflow to ensure consistency and speed for every order produced on site. Patrons find a casual and efficient environment designed specifically for the appreciation of high-quality, straightforward pizza preparations. This focus on core culinary techniques ensures that the final product remains focused on texture, heat, and seasonal ingredient integrity.

Details

Amenities, services & more

Loading other locations...
Loading restaurants nearby...
Loading...
4.5785 ratings
5★
76%
4★
11%
3★
4%
2★
7%
1★
2%

Mentioned in:

Pizza Toni was featured in the article(s) below.

Restaurants in Mile-EndView More

India Rosa Plateau Restaurant
Brasserie Bernard Restaurant
Caribou Gourmand Restaurant
Nikkei MTL Restaurant
La Khaïma Cuisine Nomade Restaurant
Loading nearby events...
Loading related links...

Reviews for Pizza Toni

Food
Service
on Google4.5 (1600+)
*as of 2026-08-01
4.5785 ratings
5★
76%
4★
11%
3★
4%
2★
7%
1★
2%
Write your review

Reviews often mention

pizza(512) slice(104) sauce(68) crust(59) pepperoni(51) style(38) cheese(37) honey(36) recommend(35) crispy(26) vodka(24) ranch(17)

Review Summary

Pizza Toni is widely celebrated as one of the best spots in Montreal for New York style pizza, praised for its thin, crispy crust, high-quality ingredients, and perfect balance of sauce and cheese. Many diners highlight the pepperoni, spicy honey, and vodka-based slices as standouts, often pairing them with the highly recommended house dipping sauces. While the restaurant is frequently described as busy with a vibrant, welcoming atmosphere and efficient, friendly staff, the compact size of the space and occasional long wait times are noted by some. Despite a few mixed experiences regarding pricing, delivery consistency, or specific taste preferences, the vast majority of visitors consider the food a must-try staple and frequently return for the consistent quality and flavor.
Page 22 of 46 - 455 Reviews
Joanne
3.0

The pizzas are quite burnt & average tasting.

Jun 12, 2025
on Google
Alexander
3.0

I've only ever ordered their pizza for delivery & we just tried their website after they tucked a magnet into the last pizza we ordered through a deliver app (which came cold). The magnet says'order online it's cheaper' not only was it more expensive to order on their website, they still sent it out using Uber eats. Food is good but I'd just go pick it up-delivery leaves a lot to be desired & is likely to come cold.

Jun 10, 2025
on Google
Bo
4.0

Nice place for a quick slice of thin crust pizza. The sauce is what makes it worth the trip. It's pretty darn good.

Jun 7, 2025
on Google
Zachary
5.0

Fantastic vegan pizza with a rare dairy-free cheese, delicious sauce, proper crust. Great place.

Jun 7, 2025
on Google
Jade
5.0

My family's from Brooklyn so I'm always looking for that iconic type of pizza- this is it! My fiancé & I have tried several of their pizzas & they're all good honestly.

Jun 6, 2025
on Google
Vane
5.0

Amazing pizza. I always come back.

Jun 4, 2025
on Google
N
5.0

Pizza always made fresh this place is unreal

Jun 2, 2025
on Google
Brooklyn
5.0

This place has the best pizza I have ever had in my life. I've had dreams about this pizza honestly. If you're debating getting it, DO IT it's so so good.

May 31, 2025
on Google
SANTELI
2.0

Review: Pizza Toni

I tried a half Margherita & half pepperoni pizza for $40.

The dough was thin & crispy, but unfortunately, it tasted like a piece of cheap toasted bread. Actually, it was pretty similar to the dough you might find on certain frozen pizzas from your local IGA. Not a far stretch at all.

The pizza didn't have much sauce & was very dry. The little sauce that was there had almost no flavor.

The basil was fresh.

The cheese? Honestly, I don't even remember tasting any. I barely saw any cheese on the pizza either.

Overall, I'd give the Margherita a 6 out of 10. The one good thing was the oil they used, which did have a nice flavor.

Now for the pepperoni side. They used tiny pieces of pepperoni, & the dough had the same issue. It just tasted cheap. Again, barely any sauce & cheese, & what was there was bland.

This place is definitely overrated & overpriced for what you get. Overall, I'd rate this place a 6 out of 10. Rating this place a 6 is me being generous.

Would I go back? Definitely No.

May 30, 2025
on Google
Paskal666
4.0

Bonne pizza croustillante.3.6⭐

May 27, 2025
on Google
www.restomontreal.ca