Monday

11:30 am - 9 pm

Tuesday

11:30 am - 9 pm

Wednesday

11:30 am - 9 pm

Thursday

11:30 am - 9 pm

Friday

11:30 am - 10 pm

Saturday

11:30 am - 10 pm

Sunday

11:30 am - 9 pm

About

Pizza Toni specializes in the authentic craft of hand-stretched dough and high-quality toppings prepared within a traditional stone oven. The menu focuses on the fundamental elements of artisanal pizza, utilizing fresh ingredients to create balanced flavor profiles across a variety of classic and contemporary styles. Each pie features a signature thin, blistered crust that provides a distinctively crispy texture while remaining light enough to highlight the house-made tomato sauce and premium mozzarella. The establishment maintains a streamlined kitchen workflow to ensure consistency and speed for every order produced on site. Patrons find a casual and efficient environment designed specifically for the appreciation of high-quality, straightforward pizza preparations. This focus on core culinary techniques ensures that the final product remains focused on texture, heat, and seasonal ingredient integrity.

Reviews for Pizza Toni

Food

Service

on Google4.5 (1500+)

*as of 2026-07-15

4.5 776 ratings

5★

75%

4★

11%

3★

2★

1★

Write your review

Reviews often mention

pizza(504) slice(101) sauce(67) crust(59) pepperoni(51) cheese(37) honey(36) style(36) recommend(35) crispy(26) vodka(24) ranch(17)

Review Summary

Pizza Toni is widely celebrated as one of the best spots in Montreal for New York style pizza, praised for its thin, crispy crust, high-quality ingredients, and perfect balance of sauce and cheese. Many diners highlight the pepperoni, spicy honey, and vodka-based slices as standouts, often pairing them with the highly recommended house dipping sauces. While the restaurant is frequently described as busy with a vibrant, welcoming atmosphere and efficient, friendly staff, the compact size of the space and occasional long wait times are noted by some. Despite a few mixed experiences regarding pricing, delivery consistency, or specific taste preferences, the vast majority of visitors consider the food a must-try staple and frequently return for the consistent quality and flavor.

Page 14 of 45 - 448 Reviews

Honest

5.0

(This rating is based on someone who's been here couple of times)

One of our go to places for pizza since it's close to our home. We always have ours take away. We sat there once & the vibes were a bit uncomfortable but nonetheless, pizzas are fantastic.

One time low service: they were missing a slice of pizza & I informed them; the lady working by the cashier had a hard time to believe she forgot to put an extra slice so had to make other customers wait to really make sure we didn't lie. A bit ridiculous to accuse a repeating customer on cheating for a $5 pizza.

Dec 14, 2025

on Google

Ahmad

3.0

It was just an okay New York-style pizza.

Dec 9, 2025

on Google

Frederic

5.0

Je recommande sans hésiter

J'ai pris deux pointes. La croûte de la pizza est à la fois croustillante & moelleuse. Lorsqu'on plie la pointe en deux, tout se tiens 🍕👏🏻.

La pizza au fromage est délicieuse. Fromage fondant & décadent.

Accueil chaleureux, personnel easy going & sympathique.

Go Bills Go 🏈
ou plutôt
Go Habs Go 🏒🥅

5/5 🍕👏🏻👌🏼

Dec 6, 2025

on Google

René

3.0

It's a good take out place; which is kind of expensive, but good.

Dec 5, 2025

on Google

Dali

1.0

Amazing pizza but never, ever order delivery. They use Uber for delivery & the pizza comes about an hour after they've made it, so you'll always get cold pizza. Uber stacks orders so they'll pick up your pizza 15 minutes after it's made, make a stop along the way to deliver something else, & then show up with a $40 cold medium pizza. This happens no matter how you order, if you order on their website they don't tell you it's through Uber, but it is. Just don't bother. Love the pizza, but can't believe they have such terrible service. It should be a basic requirement of a pizza place to have decent delivery. What's the point of sending delivery of such good pizza & it always being cold? There's other reviews that have pointed this out & they haven't changed anything. They should care that people enjoy their food hot.

Nov 29, 2025

on Google

Giorgos

5.0

Top

Nov 18, 2025

on Google

Benoit

5.0

Rien à a dire. Je fais 90% du temps mes propre pizza car elles sont souvent mauvaises &/ou hors de prix dans la plupart des pizzeria de Montréal. & & je suis rendu à environ 90 places à pizza d'essayer.
Ici c'est chère, mais rien a dire pour le goût, la quantité de garniture & la sauce tomates. La pâtes fines & croustillantes à souhait. Bref allez y une valeur sûre!

Nov 16, 2025

on Google

Mujahid

5.0

The pizza is excellent

Nov 16, 2025

on Google

5.0

Perfect pizza (the taste, the crunch, the thin crust). You can taste every ingredients in the pizza. Everything is perfectly well balanced. Def best pizza in MTL!

Nov 15, 2025

on Google

Nilendri

5.0

Great food & great service

Nov 14, 2025

on Google

Pizza Toni

LocationError?

About

Details

Mentioned in:

The Best Pizza in Montreal

Where to Eat, Drink, and Cheer in Montreal's Mile End

Restaurants in Mile-EndView More

India Rosa Plateau

Brasserie Bernard

Caribou Gourmand

Nikkei MTL

La Khaïma Cuisine Nomade

Reviews for Pizza Toni

Review Summary