Mandy's draws praise for absolutely delicious food and superb soups, with some diners even buying the cookbooks after tasting; but several reviews note smaller, pricier salads that undermine value, and the dining experience receives mixed marks with loud music, requests to wait outside, and plastic utensils in a small cardboard bowl for dine-in meals; while some describe healthy, tasty options, others express disappointment in portion size and overall consistency.
This Mandy's location is only okay. Please go to their other spots. Ordered The Wrangler because I remembered how good it was a few months ago as its seasonal - the meat I got was supposed to be pulled, it was all clumped together like they just defrosted it. Not worth the price at this location.
Used to live in Montreal years ago so was really looking forward to revisiting one of my favourite spots- was sad to see my favourite salad (the Superfood) is no longer on the menu :( Ordered the endless summer instead which was good too, but also sad there aren't pomegranate seeds anymore. Got my dressing on the side & the bowl was so full that it didn't mix in great. Miss the cup/deli container style packaging. & lastly, vibes in the place were pretty low. Still love my Mandy's, but just not quite the same as I remember!
Apr 30, 2026
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Mandy's would probably be able to give you more of the non-filler ingredients if they didn't use these these fancy custom paper bags & napkins with your $26 mediocre salad but that's a chain guess.
What a disappointment Mandy's has become . They've halved the size of their salads & upped the price . I never minded paying 30$ for a salad cause it was filling, but now it's just pathetic portion - i made my own salad- walnuts ( maybe there were 4 walnuts, cranberries , like 6 cranberries - tiny amount of lettuce / it's just a rip off - sorry - plus - why are they serving everything with Plastic forks in a tiny cardboard bowl? I was eating IN, not take out
I usually love Mandy's but today was a less-than-ideal experience for me. The staff was friendly but I wasn't asked for my take out (crunchy sesame) if my salad dressing should be separate or together with the salad. I also found that the whole salad had wilted lettuce leaves that affected the taste, & that there was very little salad dressing added. Rather disappointing for a $30 salad. I usually love Mandy's so I hope this branch can do better next time!
My favorite restaurant ever in Montreal. I highly recommend the pumpkin latte & all type of salads they have in their menu. I wish they have a Mandy restaurant in Colombia 🥹😍
Mandy has really downgraded in the past years & is not really worth their price range anymore. Ingredients quality & freshness is sometimes questionnable. They also made mistakes in my last orders & it's starting to be a recurrent issue. Ordered a cesar salad, confirm I want the dressing mixed in & lemon juice on the side. They gave us plain cesar salads no dressing at all... like am I just supposed to eat plain romaine leafs
Jul 23, 2024
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
At least a year ago, I would give Mandy's 5 stars, but something has changed, food isn't as fresh, chunks of stuff that are not mixed well & dressing tastes wierd, options on the menu & selections are limited now, taste not as great, very disappointed,
It's such an amazing salad! Absolutely loved it. Went in before close, & ordered the crunchy sesame, & it was absolutely awesome. Staff were good, & let us eat on the patio even right before close. A great experience, & I'll definitely be back to any Mandy's location.
Sadly, this Mandy's is super inconsistent. I always get a lightly-dressed mixed salad; sometimes, it's *drenched* in vinaigrette. Today, there was no vinaigrette at all. Sometimes the bowl is half full, sometimes it's overflowing. Some days it's amazing, other days I can barely eat it. It's like playing the lottery. I wish they would standardize things so that it was a reliable experience every time.
Da ich bei meinem letzten Besuch im Mandy`s in der Rue Saint-Nicolas so begeistert war wollte ich vor meiner Abreise gerne nochmal in einen Mandy`s. Allerdings gab es dieses Mal keine Sitzmöglichkeiten und den Salat nur zum Mitnehmen. In meinen Cesar war leider weder Mozzarella noch die gewünschte Avocado statt den Bacon. Sehr enttäuschend.
I LOVE Mandy's! This place is located in the heart on Montreal! My partner & I used to go there more often when we lived down town, but the other day I was craving Mandy's & so I went & got us a bowl of the Wolf. It has so much nutrients in it, very filling too! The flavours just all come together. I highly recommend Mandy's
I always been a salad person, but salads don’t always fill you up. Mandy’s salads are full of proteins & you have a big variety of salads for a good price. There salad are always amazing! When you walk inside the restaurant, the theme is so cute & you feel welcomed. The staff is ok, they are so busy that there costumer service is decent.
