Amelia's is a cozy, welcoming spot where the pizza is the main draw, made with fresh ingredients and offering a range of styles from classic cheese and pepperoni to Florentine and vegetarian options, and guests can bring their own wine. Friendly, attentive service and a warm, family owned vibe are frequently highlighted, making each visit feel like a gathering for both adults and kids. While most reviews rave about flavor and value, a few note slower service or a crust that is sometimes heavier and more bread like, and some portions or toppings may vary. The menu and atmosphere also draw praise for items like lasagna and tiramisu, and the new location is described as maintaining the same quality that fans love. All in all, Amelia's comes across as a beloved local pizzeria that delivers consistent pizza, good vibes, and a welcoming policy that allows guests to bring their own wine.
I haven't had pizza from here in years. We ordered on a whim, got our pizzas, there's barely anything on them, crust is 95% of the pizza, literally can't see the sauce if they put any at all on these. Garbage. How the mighty have fallen.
2.5 years looking for the cheesiest gooey pizza & I think Amelia's hit the mark. This one is cheese & pepperoni yummmmmy! Can't wait to try the 5 cheeses!
We used to be regulars at the previous milton location. Today we finally went to the new st. Laurent location. It was as good as ever. We loved the Florentine pizza, the vegetarian & the Hawaiian. Oh & you can bring your own wine! Highly recommend you try it. You will go back.
Cozy & charming restaurant with excellent food & a super welcoming staff. We had the french onion soup, a pizza & lasagna, as well as the tiramisu. Each dish was perfect. We were attended to by a lovely waitress who was kind & patient (we were with our son, very child friendly btw). Will absolutely return! Do recommend!
Amelias is one of those cozy, welcoming spots that make you feel right at home the moment you walk in, with the smell of fresh pizza coming out from the oven 🍕
Their pizzas are the true highlight. The ingredients are fresh, & every bite tastes absolutely yummilicious. The Pizza Caprese, this year's Pizza Fest feature, is pure heaven. It is made with Saputo Gold cheese, giving it that rich, creamy flavor that melts perfectly with every bite 🧀
What makes Amelia's extra special is the warm, family-owned vibe. Every visit feels like a gathering with new friends adults & kids alike 😍
P.S: I've been going to Amelia's since 2022, back when it was on Milton Street, & their French onion soup is to die for 🫕
The food was edible but not good, the pizza was a bit wet & heavy, less cheese would have helped. I got beef toppings which did not mix well with the heaviness of the pizza.
Took longer than expected for the pizza to come out.
The pizza was ok. We were a part of 10 & we ordered 5 large pizzaas. The pizza ratio of bread to sauce & toppings served to lean more heavily to the bread side. If that doesn't bother you then I think you will like this place. I personally prefer thin crust & felt I was eating more bread & didn't feel I got a good taste of the pizza toppings. We found the service a little slow & waited almost 45 min till our order was brought to our table. The prices are fair for the area being downtown. I have the food 3 stars but it is more a 3.5 than a 3 but not a 4.
Oct 4, 2025
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Une petite pizza signature végétarienne qui inclus une petite salade @ $23, plus taxe & pourboire totalise $30 plus $2,50 si vous n'avez pas l'argent comptant sur vous.
La vinaigrette de la salade manque de gout & manque de sel. Je n'ai pas apprécié la pate de la pizza trop dure comme si elle n'était pas assez aérée. La sauce est bonne mais la garniture insuffisante pour le prix demandée. On pourrait songer à ajouter avantageusement des champignons à la garniture.
Service 5/5
Waitress had good humour & we enjoyed the service a lot.
Atmosphere 5/5
Loved the decoration, they opened the windows so we could feel the breeze in the restaurant easily, which was really nice.
You can bring your alcoholic beverage to the restaurant, no problem at all which I found it really nice. Only take cash, but they have ATM inside the restaurant.
Food 3/5
Unfortunately the pasta was a little bit flavourless, I had to add lot of parmesan cheese to make it taste more balanced. Maybe it's just a one time thing but hope to see the change in the future. Pizza is nice.
Pizza ok, mais plus comme elle était à l'ancienne place. Boulettes de viande dégueux… trop salées & sauce acide… lasagne même chose. Aucune autre pâte. Très décevant.
This beloved pizzeria, formerly on Milton Street, has found a new home-& I couldn't be happier to see them still in business! The classic five cheese pizza is truly one of a kind: rich, perfectly balanced, & absolutely delicious. Their salads are fresh & flavorful, making a great pairing with any pie. Also amazing Lasagna!
You can bring your own wine! It's the perfect spot for a relaxed, tasty night out. A local gem that continues to deliver.
Jul 5, 2025
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
un apportez votre vin . Resto familial . Service attentionné. Une petite salade fraiche offerte avec la pizza. 3 tailles de pizza . Cash only attention. Il y a un GAB a l intérieur. La sauce de la pizza ainsi que celle de la lasagne & des boulettes est la même bizarrement & très très acide. Dommage. C est cher pour ce que c est ( update cette année dans la nouvelle localisation ) très déçus par la lasagne très petite portion pour 20$ , les boulettes servis dans un bol en pyrex, la pizza sauce acide & min de garniture .
Always my favorite pizza in Montréal
Best staff , fresh ingrédients, Been going there since forever.
The new restaurant is great . Not the corner pizza place vibe but nice.
The only objection is the Music … bring back the amelias soundtrack
