Reviews describe Tasty Food Pizza as more than a pizza place, with the pizzas described as a work of art and the service professional and friendly. The experience is praised for quality and craft, with some noting pizzas travel well, even home to PEI, and a desire to return for more. The restaurant is hailed by some as the best in Montreal, and the staff receives appreciation. Yet opinions are mixed, with some feeling gourmet expectations are not met and others criticizing aspects such as dough texture, flavor, cheese, and portion size. Overall, the reviews show a strong positive impression of care and artistry, tempered by occasional drawbacks.