FR
Montreal Restaurants: RestoMontreal.caMontreal Restaurants: RestoMontreal.ca
RestaurantsReviewsArticlesWhat's On

Logo RestoMontreal.ca

Restaurant

Restaurant Siciliana

Downtown
4.1$$
CLOSEDOpens Today at 4 pm
Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Saturday
Sunday
Restaurant Siciliana Montreal Restaurant: Menu, Reviews & Reserve (2026)
ItalianPastaPizza

Suggested Articles

5★
58%
4★
17%
3★
8%
2★
17%
1★
1%

The 10 Best Downtown RestaurantsMore

Sésame

305 Rue Ste-Catherine O
(3622)

Siam

1325 Boulevard René-Lévesque O
(2436)

Events NearbyMore

Reviews for Restaurant Siciliana

Food
Service
on Google3.9 (1100+)
*as of 2026-02-15
5★
58%
4★
17%
3★
8%
2★
17%
1★
1%

Review Summary

Restaurant Siciliana is described as a warm, cozy spot with an authentic Italian vibe, known for wood-fired pizza, fresh bread, and comforting pasta dishes. Diners frequently praise standout items such as lasagna, chicken parmigiana, Alfredo pasta, and a well received pizza crust, with many calling the flavors delicious and the portions generous and good value. The atmosphere is often highlighted as welcoming and romantic, sometimes resembling a rustic Italian trattoria, though experiences vary with some reporting slow or inattentive service and timing issues between courses. Cleanliness and upkeep are raised in some reviews, including remarks about the dining room and a few mentions of oven smells or restrooms. Overall the consensus points to tasty, authentic Italian fare and a memorable visit, with many looking forward to returning, while a subset of visits left guests feeling the kitchen and service could use more polish.
Page 1 of 9 - 174 Reviews

Really upsetting service :( It took 10 minutes to even take our order (& we had to ask), & 45-50 minutes for them to serve us. They were friendly & kind to all tables except ours. There were people who came long after us & finished & left before we even got our food. Every table was getting complimentary dinner rolls/bread except us, & the man serving was actively avoiding looking at us. A very bizarre experience!

Food was just okay. When we were done, they took away our plates hurriedly & gave us the bill in under a minute. It was very strange after they made us wait so long but wanted to get us out the door ASAP.

We also had reservations, but got very crowded seats at the edge.

Very bad experience, would not recommend at all!

Feb 15, 2026
on Google

Had a really nice time here. The place is super cozy & feels very warm. Service was quick & polite, we didn't have to wait long for food at all. I loved my pizza (yum!), & even though my husband thought his was just okay, we both enjoyed the meal. Good option for a quiet, casual dinner.

Feb 10, 2026
on Google

Near one of Montreal's main avenues, you'll find this small Sicilian restaurant. I enjoyed a plate of spaghetti alle vongole, which was very flavourful & well prepared. I finished the meal with a glass of Frangelico over ice. Overall, a lovely experience with attentive service & a relaxed, pleasant atmosphere.

Feb 1, 2026
on Google

It is a small Sicilian restaurant in downtown Montreal. I was pleasantly surprised by how flavourful the food was & how friendly the service was. It was a warm, welcoming place where I could enjoy a good meal, warm up, & spend a very pleasant time.

Feb 1, 2026
on Google

L'une des meilleurs pizzas que j'ai mangé depuis longtemps. & excellent service.
Certain que je vais y retourner.

Jan 29, 2026
on Google

The staff was sweet, but the food super expensive & not up to par.... Really disappointed... The ceasar had rusty salad & the bloody Caesar tasted off

Jan 25, 2026
on Google

Absolutely love it here, it's the most cozy & sweet restaurant in downtown Montreal. The music & ambience make you feel like you're in a little Italian cafe. The pasta is delicious & made with fresh ingredients. The pizza was slightly hard, but still delightful! Wonderful service & atmosphere, we love coming here!

Jan 20, 2026
on Google
3.0

The service is great & has a classic retro vibe.

The food, however, is average but decently priced. It's a safe location to choose if you would like to stick to North American style Italian food.

Jan 19, 2026
on Google

Has the best pasta & pizza!

Jan 6, 2026
on Google

La pire pizza de MTL, service 0, ambiance étrange, on a pris les restes pour donner au chien !

Jan 3, 2026
on Google

Not bad at all. I just wished the dining room was cleaner & better heated during my visit. As other reviewers have reported, the dining room was FILTHY (I saw crumbs a used toothpicks on the carpet), & there were plenty of workers standing around at the counter area (not in the kitchen). But I enjoyed my salad, bread, & pasta.

Jan 2, 2026
on Google

Très bonne option de pâtes maison au centre ville, pas cher . L'ambiance était simple , mais la nourriture délicieuse.

Dec 28, 2025
on Google

Very lovely & quiet place to eat. Service was excellent; the workers are so kind. Food was tasty- garlic bread was fabulous

Dec 19, 2025
on Google
3.0

It's ok. Don't expect too much. However, the tiramisu is different from other places I tried.

Dec 8, 2025
on Google
5.0

The fresh baked bread is amazing. Food is delicious & service was attentive. Had a pizza the first night & liked it so much came back for the pasta another night.

Dec 4, 2025
on Google
5.0

Stopped in late, around 10:30 pm for a pizza, since many other places closed their kitchen already. I loved the older, authentic Italian vibe. Felt like the restaurant is straight out of the Godfather. Ordered a pizza. It was very good, just didn't like the dry crust. Employees were friendly. A very pretty Italian girl took my order. Seems like maybe it's family owned & operated.

Dec 3, 2025
on Google

Very happy we found this restaurant for a birthday dinner, group of 5. We made a last minute reservation & were able to secure a table.

Very cozy & lovely decor & atmosphere. We felt like we had flown to Italy for the evening.

Wonderful very reasonably priced table d'hote, very good portions & extremely tasty, from the soups, salads, to main dishes & desserts. Our group had veal, chicken, shrimp & pasta as main courses as well as pizza & everybody was very satisfied with their meals.

The only recommendation for the kitchen would be to time things better so that all appetizers & mains are served at the same time. There was a lag between the soups & salads & the pizza was served about 15 minutes before those having other main courses.

Great value & we all agreed that would gladly return ! Thanks

Nov 24, 2025
on Google

The restaurant was warm & cozy except whenever the outside door was opened. I looked forward to the authentic pizza oven 🍕. Ordered a Caesar salad to start & was surprised by the fake bacon bits & tiny store bought croutons. Lettuce was fresh though. The chef's pizza was good although missing the sausage that was advertised. Service was efficient but not friendly.

Nov 23, 2025
on Google

Has a wonderful dinner here with friends. The food was delicious, service was efficient & friendly. We lingered having great conversation & never felt pressured to go.

Nov 19, 2025
on Google

I had a wonderful experience at Restaurant Siciliana in Montreal. The atmosphere was warm & welcoming, & the service was friendly from start to finish. The pizza was outstanding-perfectly crisp crust, fresh ingredients, & full of flavor. The chicken parmigiana was equally delicious, tender & perfectly seasoned with a rich, comforting sauce. Overall, a fantastic meal. I'll definitely be returning & highly recommend it to anyone craving great Italian food in the city!

Nov 17, 2025
on Google