Pub McCarold
Bar/PubTop Pick

Pub McCarold

4.6$
11:30 am - Midnight
Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Saturday
Sunday
Pub McCarold Montreal - Menu, Reviews & More January 2026
Pub FoodBurgersPoutineIrish PubPubResto-Bar

Suggested Articles

Best Côte-des-Neiges RestaurantsMore

Ermitage

5024 Chemin de la Côte-des-Neiges
(661)

Reviews for Pub McCarold

Food
Service
Boost your reputation
on Google*as of 2026-01-014.4 (2400+)
5★
68%
4★
26%
3★
3%
2★
3%
1★
0%
Page 1 of 8 - 157 Reviews
James
1.0

Good place went there several times the food is good but service is lacking & every time I go there. I keep calling the waitress or waitor to refill my beer or to remove my plates, napkins, cutlery etc but I physically dumped in the basket by myself & anything related to service towards the client sucks! The waitor had the attitude'I'm watching if you're gonna tip me' very lame! Once I had to get rid my own plate. The service is non existent, waiters just take order & come back only to give you the bill??? Music very loud.

Dec 30, 2025
Report
on Google
Perrine
5.0

Très bonne poutine ! Service tres rapide & tres agréable, je recommande !

Dec 28, 2025
Report
on Google
Jeffrey
5.0

Meilleure poutine de Montréal !

Dec 28, 2025
Report
on Google
Ray
4.0

Good Food Irish Stew. Nice Selection of Beers. Comfortable Atmosphere.

Dec 23, 2025
Report
on Google
Matthew
5.0

Service with a smile? Great food, great friends. What else do you need?

Nov 26, 2025
Report
on Google
Vincent
5.0

Dla vraie Guinness & en plus super beau service & toit une embiance

Nov 14, 2025
Report
on Google
Pascal
4.0

Super cadre, belle offre de bières.
Ambiance pub, très bruyant il faut aimer. Service impeccable !

Nov 1, 2025
Report
on Google
Miss
5.0

Belle ambiance de pub avec télévision. Service rapide. Personnel gentil & courtois. Belle carte de bières & un beau menu pour accompagner tout cela.

Oct 30, 2025
Report
on Google
Stephan
5.0

My friends & myself were once part of the furniture at McCarold's. Our long evenings were then filled with long forgotten & unproven manly-man tales of conquests & fortunes. For the sake of a healthier liver & as family duties were calling upon, I had to abandon ship & ancre my safety boat in a distant suburb. I still go back every now & then, so to remember the good times & the better times. Set almost at the foot of Mount-Royal in the busy, eclectic & diversified district of Côtes-des-neiges, in Frenglish Montreal, the venue offers plenty of seats, with several rooms & 2 terrasses. The selection of beers & liquors is one of the best in Montréal. The kitchen offers a pretty good selection of meals based on pubs' culture. For example the ever Oh so popular Ballymore burger & Shepherd's pie. If one feels adventurous, the burger with peanut butter, the Edson, or the Japanese poutine, the Chuck Norris, are worth the try. If you're thinking « lean », you can opt for a fresh salad as a side. If you're thinking blood pressure annihilator & heart attack, side for a poutine along the burger & keep your meds at reach. Besides minding my nutrition, I just love to sit on the terasse on the side by the church when the lilacs are in bloom during spring or in the fall at peak folliage. If you come around, please do say Hi to Martine & Mathieu, the loveliest staff I've ever met around. They've hold clients in respect for as long as I can remember. I'm positive they can show you where the bar still shows signs of wear from my elbows, as years of indulging pints after pints required appropriate support & balance. Cheers to all beer lovers !

Oct 11, 2025
Report
on Google
Corentine
4.0

Service un peu lent mais très agréable & cuisine vraiment bonne!

Oct 11, 2025
Report
on Google
Guillaume
5.0

Super pub! Belle sélection de plats typiques irlandais & de bières internationales

Oct 8, 2025
Report
on Google
Mehdi
5.0

Belle ambiance, personnel super gentil & bonne bouffe.

Oct 6, 2025
Report
on Google
Ethan
5.0

Spent the evening there with a book & a few drinks. It was the perfect vibe.

Oct 6, 2025
Report
on Google
Anais
4.0

Super bonne ambiance de bar !! Les bières sont bonnes, ce pendant ils ne font pas de pichets… la nourriture est correct, nous avons essayé la poutine spicy, les frites sont bonnes.

Oct 4, 2025
Report
on Google
Brian
5.0

Great selection of beers, food is decent.

Oct 1, 2025
Report
on Google
Cisco
5.0

Nick did a great service. We loved it!
Chris the chef makes a great burger & awesome fried chicken! Thank you very much!

Sep 30, 2025
Report
on Google
El
5.0

Delicious burger, very friendly staff. Even have Saturday karaoke. Would highly recommend

Sep 29, 2025
Report
on Google
India
2.0

Food was nice. But at the end of tonight (27/09) the female server was stood over us when we were paying the bill & when half of us hadn't tipped (as young students) she said what is wrong with the service? Service was ok but very slow. & that if we didn't tip she wouldn't be paid (she only brought us our bill & didn't serve us).She then pushed by asking if we were local & understood how tipping culture works in restaurant. Ruined our evening at the restaurant & made my friends uncomfortable.

Sep 27, 2025
Report
on Google
Loïc
5.0

Beau menu, bières & bouffe, service sympathique & rapide. Un pub à visiter plus d'une fois...

Sep 24, 2025
Report
on Google
Yan
5.0

Great prices & food.

Sep 11, 2025
Report
on Google