Pub McCarold provides a traditional pub environment focused on hearty staples and casual comfort food. The menu centers on substantial burgers crafted with seasoned beef patties, fresh vegetables, and artisan buns that define the core culinary offering. Patrons frequently select the house poutine, featuring crispy fries topped with authentic squeaky cheese curds and a rich, savory gravy. The beverage selection emphasizes cold draught beers and standard pub spirits served in a high-energy, wood-accented atmosphere. Booth seating and functional bar arrangements facilitate a straightforward experience centered on consistent, high-calorie classic fare. The kitchen maintains a focus on speed and volume to accommodate the steady influx of guests seeking reliable, filling meals in a robust social setting. This venue prioritizes the fundamental elements of a classic pub experience through focused, flavor-forward dishes.
Pub McCarold is widely regarded as a warm and welcoming neighborhood staple in the Côte des Neiges area, offering a cozy atmosphere that many describe as perfect for relaxing with friends or catching a game. Patrons consistently praise the extensive and high-quality selection of beers and spirits, complemented by a solid menu of comfort food including poutine, burgers, and pub classics that are generally described as fresh and tasty. The establishment is frequently highlighted for its friendly and attentive service, with many visitors noting that the staff goes above and beyond to create a positive experience. While individual experiences with menu changes or service consistency may vary, the overall consensus points to a reliable and lively venue that remains a go-to destination for those seeking good food, excellent drinks, and a consistent, inviting vibe.
Food was mid. Beer is nice & cold. I assume most people just come here for beer, not so much the food. (We were 3 people with different meals, same outcome).
Waiter did a disappearing act after taking our drink order. Service is friendly but not very attentive.
Awesome Place for Beer. Amazing Pub Food. It's a Pub, that is a Pub threw & threw. You can Not Have A Bad Beer, nor A Bad Meal Here. Nice to see the Menu Up it's Game with'Pub Creations'. & Beer Cocktails for the Adventurous crowd. Love 💕 it.
A classic neighborhood Irish pub in the heart of Cote des Neiges with a strong student & local crowd vibe. The place stands out for its solid beer selection (20+ taps) & a wide range of whiskies, making it a reliable spot for casual drinks.
Food is standard but well-executed pub fare-burgers, poutine, fish & chips-with a few standout comfort dishes like mac & cheese. The atmosphere is warm & lively, especially during games or evenings, though it can get noisy & service may slow down at peak times.
A dependable, no-frills pub with good energy & solid food/drinks-best for relaxed nights with friends rather than a refined dining experience. Be aware that children below 18 are not accepted, even babies!!
Decent pub in Universite de Montréal / Cote des Neiges neighborhood. A bit limited in the selection of beer but they do have all the classics. The food is good but rather pricey. A pint + a plate of fish & chips cost around $42 taxes & tips included.
Good place went there several times the food is good but service is lacking & every time I go there. I keep calling the waitress or waitor to refill my beer or to remove my plates, napkins, cutlery etc but I physically dumped in the basket by myself & anything related to service towards the client sucks! The waitor had the attitude'I'm watching if you're gonna tip me' very lame! Once I had to get rid my own plate. The service is non existent, waiters just take order & come back only to give you the bill??? Music very loud.
My friends & myself were once part of the furniture at McCarold's. Our long evenings were then filled with long forgotten & unproven manly-man tales of conquests & fortunes. For the sake of a healthier liver & as family duties were calling upon, I had to abandon ship & ancre my safety boat in a distant suburb. I still go back every now & then, so to remember the good times & the better times. Set almost at the foot of Mount-Royal in the busy, eclectic & diversified district of Côtes-des-neiges, in Frenglish Montreal, the venue offers plenty of seats, with several rooms & 2 terrasses. The selection of beers & liquors is one of the best in Montréal. The kitchen offers a pretty good selection of meals based on pubs' culture. For example the ever Oh so popular Ballymore burger & Shepherd's pie. If one feels adventurous, the burger with peanut butter, the Edson, or the Japanese poutine, the Chuck Norris, are worth the try. If you're thinking « lean », you can opt for a fresh salad as a side. If you're thinking blood pressure annihilator & heart attack, side for a poutine along the burger & keep your meds at reach. Besides minding my nutrition, I just love to sit on the terasse on the side by the church when the lilacs are in bloom during spring or in the fall at peak folliage. If you come around, please do say Hi to Martine & Mathieu, the loveliest staff I've ever met around. They've hold clients in respect for as long as I can remember. I'm positive they can show you where the bar still shows signs of wear from my elbows, as years of indulging pints after pints required appropriate support & balance. Cheers to all beer lovers !
