Pub McCarold

Marit

3.0

I've been coming here for 5 years & i love this place & the employees! However, they recently made a lot of changes to the menu (& prices...) & i must say not for the better.

Fair enough with new owners to switch things up & raise the prices, but when the new menu description & pictures are very misleading it gets disappointing. I ordered a mini fish & chips, expecting a small serving of fries, fish & sauce (as shown on the picture). The waitress warned me the picture was not representative & the fish was small bites, but I was surprised when there wasn't even any fries. Don't have a dish named mini fish & chips if there's not even any chips :( ! Picture of the actual item for reference.

& also, please bring back the cheesy Jack poutine. We really miss it!!

Vincent

5.0

A classic neighborhood Irish pub in the heart of Cote des Neiges with a strong student & local crowd vibe. The place stands out for its solid beer selection (20+ taps) & a wide range of whiskies, making it a reliable spot for casual drinks.

Food is standard but well-executed pub fare-burgers, poutine, fish & chips-with a few standout comfort dishes like mac & cheese. The atmosphere is warm & lively, especially during games or evenings, though it can get noisy & service may slow down at peak times.

A dependable, no-frills pub with good energy & solid food/drinks-best for relaxed nights with friends rather than a refined dining experience. Be aware that children below 18 are not accepted, even babies!!

Serge

5.0

Moi & ma fiancée sommes aller manger a cette endroit magnifique, nous avons eu un service exceptionnel de la part de Nick! On reviendra autant pour la bonne nourriture que pour le bon service! Vous aimez le fish n' chips? Vous allez être gâté :D

Gundhalinu

4.0

Decent pub in Universite de Montréal / Cote des Neiges neighborhood. A bit limited in the selection of beer but they do have all the classics. The food is good but rather pricey. A pint + a plate of fish & chips cost around $42 taxes & tips included.

Anthony

5.0

We thoroughly enjoyed our meal & drinks. Only reason I'm not giving 5 is because my fish n chips were a tad cold because i sent back when they forgot I had replaced fries for sweet potato fries.

Mallory

5.0

Très bon endroit pour manger de la nourriture typique de pub, faite maison. Délicieux fish & chips & onion rings. Les prix sont très abordables pour la qualité & la quantité. Service excellent.

Laya

4.0

Tasty fish & chips, it wasn’t greasy at all nice place

It seemed that the waitress wasn’t comfortable enough with English!

Foodaddicted

9 Reviews

4.0

Vraiment sympathique, dépendamment l'achalandage le service est généralement très bon! J'aime bien ce pub ! Le fish & les burger sont excellent ! Hmmm & la biere, il y en a une tonne !

LeClient

10 Reviews

4.0

J'ai été à maintes reprises au Pub McCarold (& j'ai toujours apprécié).

J'aime l'ambiance & le look de ce pub.

Le service est correct & rapide (pour les boissons) & inconstant (pour la nourriture, dépendamment de l'achalandage).

La nourriture est très bonne (notamment le fish & chips & les (regrettées) côtés levées à la Guiness -qui ne font plus partie du menu-) & le choix de bières en fût est très bien (Guinness & Smithwicks, mmm).

Je recommande.