N sur Mackay is described as a warm, cozy bar with a classy old school vibe and a standout whiskey selection that attracts whisky lovers and cocktail fans alike. The cocktail program receives frequent praise for variety and quality, with weekly specials and creative options helping keep the offerings fresh. The space feels inviting with warm lighting, comfortable seating, and decor that blends modern touches with a classic feel, making it good for casual meetups or a quiet night out. Comedy nights on Tuesday are a highlight for many, though a few comments note the jokes vary and the room can feel uneven depending on the crowd. Service is described as friendly and personable by many, with some critiques about slower service during peak times, yet the overall vibe and value keep visitors returning. Overall the reviews sketch N sur Mackay as a one of a kind local gem with great drinks, a premium whisky selection, and a welcoming atmosphere despite occasional service hiccups.
Honestly disappointed... Cocktail were put meh she service was awful, even if we were the when it was practically empty. Place has a cool vibe & great menu, just don't expect anything close to good service
I met up with a friend at NsurMackay for a couple of beers, & it was my first time visiting, so I had no expectations going in. We arrived close to suppertime, & the place was quiet, which made for a calm & relaxed atmosphere. The space itself is quite inviting - the decor is a tasteful mix of modern & classic touches, with warm lighting & comfortable seating that makes it easy to settle in & enjoy a conversation.
The bartender was friendly, welcoming, & attentive without being intrusive, which added to the relaxed vibe. The beers were cold & refreshing, exactly what I was hoping for after a long day. It's the kind of place that feels low-pressure, where you can unwind, catch up with friends, & enjoy a few drinks without feeling rushed.
Overall, NsurMackay made a very good first impression. The combination of the inviting decor, attentive service, & quality drinks makes it a spot I'd happily return to. It's ideal for casual meetups or just a quiet evening out to enjoy a couple of cold beers & good company.
Oct 9, 2025
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Great vibe, good cocktails but the highlight was the service! T was our GAL. Made us feel so special & loved not to mention everything came out so speedy! Would totally recommend to anyone in the Montreal area
Atmosphere is nice & cozy & the first time I went, I had good service.
Unfortunately, the second time back with my gf wasnt the best. We didnt think it was big deal when a first server sat us in a reserved section, so another server had to ask us to move. Mistakes happen, its whatever.
But then that same first server, while taking our order, was lazy enough to tell us if we wanted to order food we had to go check ourselves what was available & then come show him. The bar was about 1/3 full & there were like 4 servers that night so its not like he didnt have time. We understood the menu might not be up to date with inventory but if you cant be arsed to check & tell us whats available, what are you doing as a server. Or you could at least offer to come with us & take our order on the spot… he probably saw we were not happy because a second server took care of us for the remaining 15 min we stayed lol
Will not be going back after this experience which is a shame because the vibe & cocktails were on-point otherwise.
Perfect place to go queerbaiting. Wait staff said they liked our vibe so had a great time. As much as I am comfortable in myself I do love external validation. Is that so wrong? Anyways drinks were sweet & cute & served in teacups & ambience was loud enough that pretentious conversation wasn't heard but quiet enough that I didn't have to scream. Good
Feb 20, 2025
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Great drinks - but the service was not good, sadly.
Very slow, very bored like we had interrupted their conversation by showing up. Quite uncomfortable unfortunately. Otherwise great vibe & decor...but this is the 3rd time we've come & the service was notably not good so i don't think we'll be back.
Super unique & intimate vibe for a bar in this neighborhood. The cocktails are awesome (i had a mule) & the servers are very sweet. Beautiful cozy autumn spot
