Mignon Steak

Samuel

2.0

Table ordered 2 steaks medium rare. The steaks were not the same sized & the smaller one was medium-well. The steak was covered in sauce so it took a few bites to realize it was overcooked. Brought it up to waitress, told us we would be charged extra because some of it was eaten (literally 2 pieces)...

We were served water & drinks at the beginning. Waitress never game back to fill our glasses up or to offer more drinks. Glasses were filled back up when she brought the bill.

Just an overall weird & negligent experience. I have friends who came here & had a great time, which is why we chose this place for our anniversary. I don't know if this was a one-off negative experience but I don't think I'll be coming back to find out, there are many steakhouses in old port that are better suited.

Pros : Burrata was amazing.

30 juin 2025

sur Google

Tia

3.0

We came in off the street for some apps & drinks before heading elsewhere for dinner, so we didn't get a chance to try their steak (which is their signature) so please keep that in mind with this review.
Our review: The cocktails were good, the oysters were fresh, & it is a very cute place, with nice interiors & a cozy vibe. Why only three stars? The service wasn't great. It wasn't busy or anything but our server seemed to forget about us. We would go back though to try the steak because the other reviews seem to say good things!

24 juin 2025

sur Google

Fatim

2.0

Expérience très moyenne au Mignon Steak / Negroni Room.

Nous y avons été en famille (6) pour célébrer deux anniversaires & la fête des mères. Nous avons fait la réservation au Mignon Steak mais, par manque de place semble-t-il, nous avons été assis au Negroni Room (le speakeasy/bar lounge au sous-sol). Ce n'était pas notre premier choix & cela a créé de la confusion, en plus de mal terminer le service.

Il suffirait de mettre une note sur la site de réservation afin de prévenir les clients qu'en cas de sur-booking au Mignon Steak, ils seraient placés au Negroni Room car ce n'était pas l'ambiance que nous recherchions pour ce repas familial & nous aurions pu choisir un autre restaurant.

En résumé, le service y était excellent jusqu'à l'arrivée d'un groupe d'une vingtaine de personnes. Dès lors, disparition du personnel, nos plats vides ont été retirés après au moins 30 minutes d'attente, & on ne pouvait plus s'entendre parler à cause de la musique.

On a pu être placés au Mignon Steak pour le dessert après s'être plaints. Toutefois, le manager a été plutôt condescendant & peu professionnel en ne reconnaissant pas le bien-fondé de notre déception & le fait que nos plaintes étaient fondées. Selon lui,'il ne pouvait pas refuser un aussi grand groupe', ce qui n'était pas le point. La serveuse qui a tenté de rattraper le coup a, par contre, été vraiment attentionnée & empathique afin que notre dessert se passe mieux malgré la mauvaise expérience.

Concernant le repas, pour ma part, les plats étaient bons & le chou à la crème était aérien & peu sucré, vraiment un plaisir. Pour ceux qui avaient pris le menu table d'hôte, le prix (49$) est imbattable pour 3 services mais ils ont déploré la salade un peu fade & les frites non faites maison.

28 mai 2025

sur Google

Colin

5.0

Got the $50 deal with soup or salad, steak & fries, & a dessert. Wife liked the salad, I liked the carrot/turnip soup , steaks cooked perfectly & fries were great. Curious about their poutine…

26 mai 2025

sur Google

Craig

4.0

Walked into the place off the street & was greeted by our server. Right from the start he made us feel like it was a choir or service us. Didn't like when we said we didn't like the wine & asked for an alternative which he reluctantly provided. Ordered the food which was extremely good, when presented with the bill we were charged for their premium steak which we didn't ask for. He was quite rude & said he would charge us for one of the original steaks. His comments were you ate it so you should pay. But anyway food was great service not so.

11 mai 2025

sur Google

Bikram

5.0

Great mignon steak, very soft & tender, great sauce, surprisingly the fries were much better then I thought. Very flavourful. The machine & cheese is very nice to try. Would recommend to come with a group. The basement is the Negroni lounge. Very comfortable seating, nice atmosphere 👌 no photo of the steak cause it's too good to leave anything left 😀 ordered a martini too. Very nicely done.

19 avr. 2025

sur Google

Roland

5.0

We came here to celebrate a friend's birthday here, & the food, server, & ambiance did not disappoint. We were seated in the lower level which had a dim-lighting, cozy vibe. We ordered the table d'hôte which included soup/salad, steak & fries, & dessert. Absolutely delicious & worth it! Our server Antoine was attentive & regularly checked in with us. A good place to check out & eat in Old Montreal.

31 mars 2025

sur Google

Barrington

4.0

Absolutely amazing time at this place. Our waiter was lively & informative, the atmosphere was welcoming but not boring, & the food was delicious.

The sweet potato soup is definitely on my top 5 list of best soups. Real cream was used, & that's a sign of a good soup.

The cream puff for dessert was was like creamy air covered in decadent chocolate. Worth the table d'hote just for this.

Now for the one negative thing I have to say about here. While my steak was cooked to perfection & flavourful, I am not used to having McCain style fries with a higher end steak frites. Especially in Montreal of all places, you would expect fresh fries? But maybe that's just me.

Worth a visit, & I will definitely go back. Especially after trying my friend's rack of lamb.

25 févr. 2025

sur Google

Anne

5.0

I high recommend the grilled shrimp, beef tartare, steak frites of course & truffle Mac & cheese. Also if you're a martini lover, the red velvet martini with blue cheese olive is insane 🔥🔥

21 févr. 2025

sur Google

Ryan

5.0

Unreal! Music & atmosphere is to die for. Service was fantastic. Food was literally the best - I have a new favourite poutine in Montreal! The gravy is supreme. Steak was undercooked but correct immediately. Cocktails are top notch & make me want to be young again. 10/10 bravo bravo bravo

1 févr. 2025

sur Google

Guillaume

3.0

I had a great experience at Mignon Steak Vieux-Montréal, overall. The service was attentive, & the atmosphere was on point. We sat in the Negroni Room, which was cozy with low lighting & great music. The food was enjoyable, for the most part. The onion soup was solid, & the mac & cheese stood out-it was cheesy & had a nice crunch from the breadcrumbs, which made it a little different from the usual versions I've had. Also had green peas. Definitely worth trying. As for the steak frites, the sirloin cut was tasty, but I'd recommend asking for the sauce on the side. While the sauce was flavorful, it completely covered the steak & masked its natural taste. The fries were a fun surprise-they were almost identical to McDonald's fries in both smell & taste, which I actually thought was kind of cool. That said, the biggest letdown was the steak being served cold. It's such a shame because steak is always best sizzling, & you'd expect that at a restaurant like this. It threw off the dish for me a bit, which was disappointing. All in all, the service, food, & vibes made it a good spot to visit. A little more attention to the details would make it even better.

30 déc. 2024

sur Google

A.

5.0

Mignon Steak in Old Port is my go-to for group events, & it never disappoints! The group menu 75 is absolutely to die for, with incredible flavors. The service is always impeccable, & the atmosphere is simply fantastic-elegant yet welcoming. Both the Negroni Room & the main dining area are perfectly suited for any occasion. Highly recommended-this place is a gem! --------- Mignon Steak dans le Vieux-Port est mon endroit préféré pour organiser des événements de groupe, & je n'ai jamais été déçu! Le menu de groupe 75 est absolument incroyable, avec des saveurs incroyables. Le service est toujours impeccable, & l'atmosphère est tout simplement fantastique-élégante & conviviale. La Negroni Room ainsi que la salle à manger principale sont parfaites pour toutes les occasions. Je recommande à 100 %-ce restaurant est une perle rare!

30 déc. 2024

sur Google

Stefano

5.0

As someone who loves exploring amazing culinary experiences, I can confidently say this restaurant in the Old Port is a gem! The atmosphere was absolutely perfect-cozy, chic, & filled with that unmistakable Old Montreal charm. From the moment I walked in, I felt like I was in for something special. A huge shoutout to Francesco, the owner of Felix Boutique, for helping me secure my reservation. His recommendation did not disappoint, & his assistance made the whole experience even more seamless. I started with a classic Negroni, & it was perfectly balanced-a great way to set the tone for the evening. For my entrée, I couldn't resist the oysters, which were fresh & beautifully presented. The main course, steak & frites, was hands down the best I've had in Montreal. The steak was cooked to absolute perfection, tender & flavorful, while the frites were crispy & addictive. As a serious foodie, I've tried my fair share of steakhouses in the city, & this place truly takes the crown. If you're looking for an unforgettable dining experience, this is the spot. I can't wait to come back & explore more of the menu!

28 déc. 2024

sur Google

Ali

5.0

Went here for an anniversary dinner & loved the whole experience. The staff were all great to interact with the whole night while the steak was fantastic. All around a great time & will love to visit again.

18 oct. 2024

sur Google

Chuck

5.0

It was my wife & I first time in Montreal & we were told to check out Old Port & stumbled into Mignon & had the experience of a lifetime! The hospitality, food, environment & courtesy made thr experience second-to-none. We ordered the Steak Frites which are arguably the best (coming from New York City). This restaurant is 10 out of 10 for the hospitality & intention alone - special thanks to Valentin, Pierre, & Danny for making this one for the ages. An incredible welcome to Montreal.

5 oct. 2024

sur Google

Oisín

2.0

My wife & I had dinner at Mignon Steak Vieux-Montréal, & unfortunately, our experience was far from satisfactory. Despite making a reservation at a steakhouse, we were bizarrely asked if we were vegetarians upon arrival. This felt out of place & left us wondering why that was necessary information when we'd clearly chosen a steakhouse. The service continued to disappoint. When we asked for salt for our fries, the waiter condescendingly asked if we had tasted them first - incredibly patronizing. We also ordered a side of mushrooms & onions, which was forgotten & only brought out well after our meals had been served. As a result, I had to watch my dinner get cold while waiting for the side dish. Adding insult to injury, we couldn't help but notice that the waiter was far more attentive to the table next to us, frequently checking on them & ensuring their dishes arrived in the order they preferred. This stark contrast in service made our experience even more frustrating. Though we were offered a free dessert as compensation, we declined, expecting that the mishandled side dish would be removed from our bill in lieu of the dessert. Unfortunately, it wasn't, which was a disappointing end to an already subpar dining experience. The entire evening felt condescending & strange, & we left feeling very unimpressed. We would not recommend this restaurant to others based on our experience.

18 août 2024

sur Google

Andrés

4.0

The place is really nice, the vibe, the music it was on point. Staff were super friendly & helpful. Food was good but not the greatest, my steak was a little overcooked, good flavour, the sauce is the star there. Fries were really nice specially with the steak sauce. I upgraded to be half salad half fries, not worth it. It ended up being 2 pieces of lettuce like you see in the picture. I got the Crème brûlée for dessert, the flavour & presentation were good, the crust on top needed more sugar for that classic initial crack. Food needs to improve a notch to align with the place & price you pay.

10 août 2024

sur Google

Frank

5.0

Mignon Steakhouse in Montreal is a real gem! The atmosphere is inviting, & their steak frites are to die for. Plus, they've got a great selection of fresh seafood. The staff is super attentive, making sure every moment is just perfect. & the best part? It's a bang for your buck! Whether you're into steak or seafood, Mignon is the place to be for an unforgettable dining experience!

14 juin 2024

sur Google

Nina

2.0

went with my family (4) for a graduation & heard a lot of good things about the steak frite so we wanted to try it out. We waited an hour for our food & when it was served, the steak was cold. The quality was below mediocre. Everything was kinda cold except for the fries. Felt as though everyone around was already getting their orders served within 20 minutes (people who came in after us) & we patiently waited for ours & we were dissatisfied. Nothing special to note except the fries. To note as well, the service was quite frankly not that good. Even though we waited for a long time, our server never came up to us to ask how we were doing & didn't come to tell us that our food would take some time. Hardly any friendly service compared to what customers were receiving. Could not properly enjoy our time at all. Finished our food within an hour & left.

12 juin 2024

sur Google

Jesi

4.0

Never had steak frites before this - now an incredibly high standard has been set. Came with a beautiful butter lettuce salad with fresh mint & tarragon. Could not have been more perfect for spring. Oysters were good but upstaged by the main. Wish I'd gone with the chocolate mousse vs. the crème brûlée (it was a bit odd).

28 mai 2024

sur Google