Garde Manger is described as a vibrant seafood focused standout in Old Montreal with a warm, lively atmosphere and consistently attentive service; the tasting menu and chef's selections are repeatedly praised for creativity and generosity of seafood, with many dishes described as memorable, though a few guests note pacing issues and that portions can feel small for the price; the bar and wine program receive strong praise for thoughtful pairings, while a minority comment that wine by the glass options lean dry or lack off dry fruity choices; the front of house and kitchen staff are frequently singled out for their energy and hospitality, making the experience feel welcoming and celebratory, and many diners say that Garde Manger offers one of the best seafood experiences in the city and is worth returning to, even if some evenings feel busier or louder and a few reservations about value remain.
As others have mentioned, the move here is to go for one of the tasting menus to try multiple dishes (& trust me they do not skimp on the portions). We did the smallest 4 course tasting & still left absolutely stuffed. Our favorite was the seafood tower to start. I will say that the service was on the slower end so make sure you allocate a lot of time to finish your meal. Bonus points for a great playlist as well!
My partner & I don't really get the opportunity to go to nice restaurants much. We aim to go somewhere nice once a year. This year I chose this restaurant & we were both pleasantly surprised. The first thing we noticed when walking in was the really nice & dim restaurant with a gorgeous chandelier. The music was pretty much 10/10 the whole night as well. Our server, I believe her name was Taylor, was an absolute gem & made our whole experience even better. Frankly, even the bus boy was lovely! The food was like nothing I'd ever had before, so I'm really happy we opted for the tasting menu. Every dish was absolutely delicious & surprisingly filling. The platters were very unique, beautifully presented, & amazingly fresh. (Seriously, how did they get the shrimps to be so tender?) I've lived in Montreal my whole life & this easily takes the cake for the best restaurant I've ever been to with the best service both of us have ever experienced. I seriously wish it was an option for us to come here more frequently. 😂 All that said, it was worth every single penny. If you're wondering if you should go, do yourself a massive favour & go!
Oct 15, 2024
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Thank you to the team at Garde Manger. We celebrated our 20th anniversary with you this evening & it was so special. The food, the staff, the bartender, the atmosphere. Go on a dining journey & enjoy the trip!
Une cacophonie, une manque de raffinement, & un service très moyen. Pas du tout à la hauteur de nos attentes & de la réputation de l'établissement. Le lieu est EXTRÊMEMENT bruyant & l'insonorisation mal étudiée. Le menu surprise est mal conçu, un manque de raffinement & d'équilibre entre les plats. Le goût est exagéré. Le résultat est lourd. Le plateau de fruits de mer était par contre le seul point fort. Le service manque de bon suivi & les explications sont approximatives par rapport aux 4 niveaux de menus proposés, surtout au vu de la cacophonie... 5 personnes pour plus de $1,000 pour le niveau 1 (le moins cher!), incluant le vin. A ce prix, tout est à revoir!
Their food is very innovative. Something I have never had in other restaurants. Great atmosphere. The server who attended us was very attentive & patient. Great experience. Idk why there's no Michelin star restaurant in Montreal, but this place would be at least one star in my opinion.
Sep 30, 2024
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
If I could give 10 stars I would. Garde Manger has been on my food bucket list for a very long time & it was worth the wait. The food was incredible. The service impeccible
Hands down, the BEST culinary experience I've ever had! My friends & I had the chef's 4 course menu, & every single bite was absolutely exquisite. You can tell that every element of each dish was well perfected & treated with such care. The atmosphere was lively & joyful & the service was quick, highly attentive & detail oriented. 10/10 recommend & can't wait to go back the next time I'm in Montreal. It's a can't miss experience.
Great meal from start to finish. Service was excellent. Room was a little noisy at times & also a bit of smoke from the kitchen but it was part of the experience. Grilled octopus app was stellar. & the side dish of carrots with the entrees was perfection. Finished with a butter tart dessert that just sealed the deal!
The ingredients were all fresh & well-prepared, but the sauces on each dish were truly outstanding! We made a last-minute reservation, so only bar seats were left, & at first, we were a little disappointed. However, the bartender who prepared our seafood plate kept us entertained the whole time-he was quite the entertainer. He was very attentive to all the customers, & I'm sure he would be more discreet with groups having serious conversations. On top of that, every server & host was super friendly, making us fall in love with this place. We'll definitely be back!
Sep 25, 2024
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Le Garde-Manger est une adresse agréable pour une cuisine de style bistro. Le menu propose une variété de plats, des steaks aux plats de pâtes, avec des produits frais. L'ambiance est décontractée & le décor moderne. Le service est généralement rapide & sympathique. Un bon choix pour un repas décontracté mais de qualité.
Nous avons célèbre mon anniversaire dans ce restaurant. Le bartender & l equipe sont tres sympathiques. C est le meilleur cocktail de ma vie. J adore l ambiance & de la musique la bas. Tout est parfait
An exquisite meal in Montreal. My partner & I picked a handful of dishes to share so we could get a good sampling of what the restaurant had to offer. We loved every bite! Would highly recommend the albacore tuna with capers, the wild mushrooms & the focaccia is unbelievable.
Sep 15, 2024
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Absolutely amazing seafood! The cocktails were delicious, & the pricing was very reasonable. We left feeling completely satisfied. The bartender, Jihad, was not only funny but also great to chat with. Will definitely be coming back again.
I just can't say enough about this place. Amazing vibe, exceptional food (get the tasting menu!), dealt with my allergies exceptionally well, really awesome staff. One of the best dining experiences I've ever had.
Thank You David for helping me (in Australia) surprise my partner for his Birthday while visiting Montreal on holidays. The Strawberry Cheesecake Profiteroles were a hit & a welcome surprise. Merci Beaucoup!
