Forno Pizza Frankie's draws strong praise for its thin, crispy crust, high quality ingredients and authentic New Haven style pizza, with many reviewers calling it among the best in Montreal and a hidden gem in Lachine. Signature pizzas and a pistachio mortadella sandwich, along with other mortadella offerings, get top marks for balance, flavor and freshness, and hot honey is frequently highlighted as a must-try. The family-run operation and friendly, welcoming staff are repeatedly noted as part of the appeal, while some mentions of price, occasional wait times, and a few mixed experiences with consistency remind diners this is a premium option best planned for. It is largely celebrated as a standout for takeout and the experience of dining in a compact, apartment-like space, with many urging others to order in advance and to try multiple items.
My friend told me about a sandwich with pistachios pesto, I knew it would be good, but I sure didn't know i'd fall in love with all the flavours & quality of the ingredients. Hands down best sandwich I've had. I went back for pizzas & I did not regret it at all! Cool place, nice owner & perfect food. Highly recommend
The best pizza I have EVER had. Does not disappoint. Highly recommend. You can taste the quality ingredients. Anyone who is not giving this spot 5 stars should not be trusted
Apr 10, 2026
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
I've ordered pickup from here many times, & it has never disappointed. The quality & consistency are impressive every single time.
The Mortadella sandwich is an absolute must-try - fresh, perfectly balanced, & full of flavor. The Figgy pizza is another standout, with an amazing sweet & savory combination that really works.
Can't wait to order again & try more from the menu. Highly recommend!
Easily one of the best pizzas in Montreal that's quickly become a staple in our household, & for good reason. The quality is always on point, super fresh ingredients (you don't feel awful after devouring it) & the dough is perfection. Can't recommend them enough (especially the Donny Brasco & Bosco). Staff is also great & super responsive via instagram. A not so hidden gem we tell all our friends about. 12/10
Jan 24, 2026
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Excellent pizza. Pepperoni slice was amazing . Thin, light & airy crust. Very good quality pepperoni. Wasn't a fan of the spinach slice but it was still good. Quality ingredients. Definitely MY top 3 pizzas in the city . I highly recommend. Outstanding! 9.2/10
A must try for all pizza lovers. Had their margherita, Pepperoni & their Demons Breath pizzas. 10/10.
The dough is spot on. No bloating after eating 4 slices. The sauce is perfect. & the cheese is high quality. Same for the toppings.
Highly recommended!
Certainly one of the best pizzas I have ever had in Montreal.
It's a pretty unique experience. Order was placed through their instagram page. The prices are pretty high 35-40$ per pizza. But it's a large pie, probably around 14-16 inches, comes with 8 slices. The crust is thin & perfectly charred, just the right amount of flop. Sauce & cheese were really good too, just the right amount. Both pepperoni & cheese pizza were great. I really enjoyed this New Haven style slice. I would recommend it to anyone looking for a proper pizza experience, but the price point is pretty high so I reserve it for special occasions.
Service was great, everyone in there is super nice. Atmosphere is pretty interesting. It basically seems like it's just someone's apartment converted into a pizza shop. Pretty cool.
Next time I definitely want to try the sandwiches which look amazing too.
Première fois, & meilleure pizza à vie!! J'ai pris la Margarita & wow!! Mon conjoint la Tony Brasco & j'y ai gouté & OMG!! C'est plus que supérieur à la moyenne, c'est fantastique!! Je recommande à 100%
Sep 27, 2025
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Found this place because it went viral.. showed up an hour before closing & there was a sold out sign on the door 😟
Decided to go upstairs anyways & was lucky enough to snatch a few slices & man was it goooooddddd!! The crust, the sauce the toppings.. if there was ever a perfect pizza this place got it! Possibly the best pizza I've ever had! Can't wait to try a whole many pies next time we're in town!! Highly recommended!!
J'ai découvert cet endroit pour la première fois aujourd'hui. J'ai commandé la pizza Donny Brasco en ligne mais une fois rendu sur place je n'ai pas pu m'empêcher d'essayer les sandwichs & autres pizza à la pointe. Tout était excellent & frais. De plus, le personnel est très amical ce qui rend l'expérience encore plus fantastique. J'y retournerai certainement & je le recommande à tous.
L'une des meilleures pizza style New Haven que j'ai mangé à l'extérieur du Connecticut ! La qualité, la fraîcheur & le goût est au rendez-vous ! Probablement dans mon top à Montréal. Ont est chanceux d'avoir cela à Lachine! Je recommande fortement au passionnés de pizza. Moi & ma conjointe ont est tombé en amour des notre première fois !
Yes, it's a tad pricey, but it's simply the best. Best pizza in Montreal & best sandwiches in Montreal. The bread is amazing too. & awesome people running the whole thing. Cannot recommend it enough.
