Cugini's Pizza

Patrick

4.0

Good Pizza but way too expensive

Karine

5.0

One of the best pizzas I've eaten.

Great customer service

Dree

5.0

For our 22nd wedding anniversary, my husband & I wanted to try a restaurant we had never been to before. My husband is Italian & I'm Lebanese-Egyptian, & he was really hoping to find an authentic Italian pizza. Having both travelled to Italy, we knew exactly what we were looking for - & we had a hard time finding it in our borough.
I think we finally found it!
We ordered the Margherita & Vesuvio pizzas, along with the garlic knots, mini cannolis, & tiramisu. Everything was absolutely delicious!
I also want to say a special thank you to the entire staff for your kindness & wonderful service. You helped make our anniversary celebration even more special.
We're so happy we discovered you & look forward to coming back! 🇮🇹❤?

Emily

4.0

Pizza is delicious & staff is extremely kind. Totally glad we came here! Only critique is the garlic knots, while delicious in texture, have zero garlic flavor & no parmesan seasoning. Could use a serious injection of garlic then they would be perfect.

Julius

4.0

A decent pie but not worth $50+ for the 16' IMO.

Kenny

5.0

Grandma pizza is fantastic. I didnt take a picture, cause you go try it yourself - thats why lol

Angela

5.0

Unique & absolutely delicious

Charlotte

1.0

The pizza itself was good, & I don't have any major complaints about the food. While it wasn't the best pizza I've ever had, it was enjoyable.

Unfortunately, the dine-in experience was extremely disappointing. From the moment we arrived, it took a long time before anyone greeted us or took our order. Throughout the meal, no one came by to refill our water or check on us. After we finished eating, we sat with our empty plates for quite a while. Multiple staff members looked in our direction, but we were completely ignored.

When we finally asked for a box to take the remaining pizza home, it was simply tossed onto the table & we were told to pack it ourselves. Normally that wouldn't be a big issue, but after waiting over an hour for a meal consisting of just two medium pizzas, we were ready to leave & the lack of service was frustrating.

The dining area also felt very cramped. The tables were so close together that it was uncomfortable, & there wasn't even enough room for the server to properly place the pizza on our table.

To make matters worse, when I stood up to leave, I realized my white pants had been stained with honey sauce because there was sauce left on the chair from a previous customer. It was obvious the seating hadn't been properly cleaned.

The food was decent, but the poor service, disorganization, cramped seating, & lack of cleanliness completely overshadowed the meal. I wouldn't choose to dine in here again.

Giovannl

5.0

Great pizza & phenomenal sandwiches staff is great & the owner is really hands on to make sure every client is satisfied Great place strongly recommend you stop in

T

4.0

Amazing welcoming staff, very polite & friendly. It was particularly busy when we went but the staff stayed calm & all smiles, even if some of the other customers were a tad rude to them.

The food was fantastic. I absolutely love the Nona/grandmother square pizza. You could actually taste the natural sweetness of the tomatoes in that sauce. Their round pizzas were good as well. I will say, don't go there expecting a chewy dough. Their dough is crispy, it's not that typical chewy, sometimes bready pizza dough.

My only complaint or criticism (if I had to have one) is that it's a bit on the pricey side, especially if you get a square/sheet pizza, but the quality does show & sometimes good food is worth the price. This place definitely is worth it in my opinion.