Cugini's Pizza offers an authentic Italian dining experience, specializing in classic pizzas crafted with premium ingredients and traditional techniques. Guests can savor a diverse menu featuring handcrafted pasta dishes, flavorful appetizers, and hearty main courses that showcase the rich tastes of Italian cuisine. The culinary team focuses on delivering fresh, quality flavors in every plate, ensuring a memorable meal. Beyond the savory selections, Cugini's Pizza presents a delightful array of desserts and sweets, perfect for concluding any repast with a touch of indulgence. This establishment is dedicated to providing a welcoming atmosphere where the vibrant spirit of Italian cooking comes alive.
Reviews describe Cugini's Pizza as gourmet with high quality ingredients, a tangy and slightly sweet sauce, and a dough that balances chew and crisp. The crust is thin and crunchy, with both classic round pies and Grandma style square pies that many find exceptional. Guests praise fresh toppings, bold flavors, garlic knots, and optional hot honey that elevates several pies. The owner and staff are frequently called warm, attentive, and welcoming, contributing to a homey atmosphere, though wait times can be long when busy. Some experiences note price being high for what is offered and occasional service hiccups such as requests beyond the menu or takeout packaging, but the overall sentiment is that the pizza is among the best in Montreal West Island and worth returning for, especially for shareable pies and specialty options.
We just had a family lunch at this fabulous restaurant. The staff & the owner were super kind. They brought us a couple slices of cheese on the house to try. & they even replaced an olive oil bottle that we purchased, but broke by accident.
Highly recommend. Amazing pizza. Especially the margarita pizza was phenomenal.
First time at Cugini's & wow! I had the grandma's pizza.. The flavors are pure harmony, you notice the care, you taste the intention! The rich tomatoes, parmesan & basil, everything balanced to perfection.This is pizza made with soul & with love... simple, honest, & unforgettable. If poetry had a flavor, this would be it. 🍕✨ Grazie Cugini's! Era tutto buonissimo!!!
It simply does not get any better than this pizza. As soon as you walk in, you feel the welcoming service. The design, the atmosphere.
Top quality from every angle.
Germano's concept is above & beyond & this is why we choose Cugini's.
I recommend to anyone who wants to live an experience .
Having moved from Montreal to Toronto over 25 years ago, whenever I come back to visit I do the rounds; Kojax, Lafleur's, & of course, TOMATO PIZZA! When I first moved & began my search for tomato pizza in Toronto, they didn't understand & thought I meant sliced tomatoes on top of a pizza lol! I've yet to find any even close to what we are used to here, & Cugini's tomato pizza is on a whole other level & by far the best tomato pizza I've EVER had, & trust me I've had them all! Not to mention the owners are the sweetest & make you feel right at home.. yes there is a piece missing as you can see in my pic, I couldn't wait 😂
Wow quelle belle découverte cet endroit la nourriture était délicieuse,le service excellent & se faire servir en français dans le West Island 😉😁 mais avoir la visite du chef à notre table & rendre notre première fois dans ce resto c'est exceptionnel ! Merci encore & à bientôt xxoo
Stopped in from NDG & it was love at first bite. The New York-style pizza was outstanding, with incredibly fresh ingredients that really stood out. The owner's passion is evident in everything-from the quality of the food to the excellent customer service. Both the owner & staff were so pleasant & genuinely enjoyable to talk to, making us feel welcome from the moment we walked in. Thank you, Cugini's, for reminding me that life is better with great pizza made by wonderful people.so happy to find this West Island gem!
Feb 1, 2026
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
If you're looking for a true taste of Italy without boarding a plane, this pizza place delivers exactly that-& more.
From the moment you walk in, you feel the heart behind the restaurant. The owner's story is woven into every detail, bringing a sense of purpose & passion that you don't often find. It's clear this isn't just a business; it's a craft, a tradition, & a dream brought to life.
The ingredients are impeccably clean & thoughtfully chosen, & you can taste the difference in every bite. The pizza is nothing short of extraordinary-perfectly balanced, fresh, & bursting with authentic flavor that transports you straight to Italy. Every slice feels like it was made with care & intention.
The atmosphere is warm, inviting, & perfect for any occasion-whether it's a family dinner, date night, or celebration. The service goes above & beyond, easily a 5-plus experience, with staff who genuinely care about making your visit memorable.
This is more than just a pizza restaurant. It's an experience, a story, & a slice of Italy you'll want to come back to again & again.
New Year's Day & stumbled upon Cugini's Pizza in Pierrefonds, Kirkland, Quebec. Wow what a gem 🤩. We ordered XL Veggie & it was delicious + gourmet - XL Nonna Pizza - no kidding it was a prize if can be awarded, even better than in Italy. Each bite melted in your mouth & full of fresh flavours. It was hot also when we got box open. We are 6 yrs away & I'm dreaming of this pizza!! Hopefully the chef is the owner as what a pizza!!!! No pics of pizza but there's plenty online. The service was great also. A friendly smiling girl greeted me & was very pleasant. The place had dine in also & was clean with a great vibe & folks watching the hockey game.
By far the best pizza in the west island, all 6 of us were blown away on how good it was the pizza! Super friendly staff & even the owner came to see us twice to talk to us, very nice guy! Would recommend that place to anyone that wants to have a good pizza!
Cugini's pizza is simply the best. Be prepared to wait though, with the understanding that the best pizza takes time to create & is lovingly prepared just for you. So enjoy the experience! Germano the owner is very welcoming & takes the time to greet his customers, giving this very modern & unique eatery a touch of old world charm. Very pleasant & helpful staff too! I'm a lifer❤?🍕👌
We've loved Cugini's for years & have been going since it first opened on Elm. The pizza, while a bit pricey, is consistently fresh & absolutely delicious - truly some of the best around. Service has also generally been good, which is why this experience was so disappointing.
Tonight, my grandmother went to pick up pizza on a very cold evening & brought her dog with her. After picking up the order, her car wouldn't start. The roadside assistance company told her it could take 1-2 hours to help her. Cold & understandably distressed, she went back inside to ask if she could sit quietly in a corner with her dog just until I could get there (20 minutes max) so she wouldn't freeze. She fully understood that animals aren't usually allowed & wasn't looking to stay long.
Disappointingly, the owners said no. One of the employees kindly offered to let my grandmother sit in her own car while I was on my way to pick her up - & we're very grateful for that act of compassion.
While I understand policies exist, the situation left us feeling that a bit more empathy could have gone a long way, especially given the circumstances. This experience has made us second-guess returning, which is really disappointing because we've always thought of Cugini's as a warm, community-oriented place.
