Athena Pizzeria opened in December of 2013 in Pierrefonds-Roxboro. Brent, our chef and owner, puts his 10-year experience to good use to offer you a fresh, homemade menu.
He studied culinary arts and received his certification before working for a decade at the family restaurant, in L’Annonciation, Quebec. He now brings his expertise to the Montreal West-Island to stay closer to his wife and kids, family and friends.
Come meet our family in the warmth of a traditional pizzeria and enjoy our delicious pizza, pasta, salads and Greek souvlaki and gyro plates.
Overall, reviews portray Athena Pizzeria as a beloved neighborhood staple with generous pizzas, tasty subs, rich sauces, stretchy cheese, and fresh toppings, and praise fast, friendly service in a clean, welcoming setting that makes it a go-to for dine-in, pickup or delivery. Many call it one of the best pizzas in the area and a reliable place to share with friends, with long-standing patrons noting consistent quality over the years. A few criticisms mention variability in portions and occasional inconsistencies in temperature or item preparation, along with some declines in flavor noted by longtime customers. The pita gyro is singled out as outstanding by several reviews, and overall value and friendly staff are repeatedly highlighted. In short, Athena Pizzeria is seen as a dependable, comfort-driven option that delivers solid pizza and subs, even as callers acknowledge occasional inconsistencies.
If I could give Athena more than I would. Everything is always awesome & fresh. They tell me 30-45 mins for delivery but it's always here in 15 mins. 10/10 - will order again!
Feb 28, 2026
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Excellent sub the Special Athena sub mmmmm & their pizza 🍕 mmmmm my mouth is watering 💦 just thinking about it . Sorry I have to order it's donner time .
I recently had take-out from Athena Pizzeria in Pierrefonds-Roxboro. I had in my opinion one of the best pizzas on the West Island. I am surprised that it took me this long to find this gem of a pizzeria. This is one place you want to take your hunger to. The food will not disappoint. @mtlrestorap
Depuis 2 ans environ la qualité & le goût des produits se sont dégradées. Les frites ne sont que de petits bouts plein de pelure
La sauce à poutine était excellente maintenant un goût de ne revient plus & la pizza n'est jamais pareil. Je n'y vais plus
My favorite pizza in Montreal! The sauce is rich & flavorful, cheese nice & stretchy, & the toppings are fresh. The staff is very kind & the service is great. I've been going to this place for years & it never disappoints!
Un petit resto de quartier familial, rassurant, en tout temps. Malgré les Tempêtes de neige, verglas, pandémie...
Athena est resté un pilier pour notre quartier. Service rapide, impeccable, accueil chaleureux. Alex, le proprio, veille avec constance a la qualité.
Le pita gyro est, sans exagération, le meilleur au monde. Pizza délicieuse, portions généreuses, resto toujours propre, personnel gentil. Un vrai bijou du quartier !
Jul 29, 2025
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
