Antonietta has made an immediate impression in Rosemont-La Petite-Patrie, welcoming Montrealers with an authentic and refined approach to Italian cuisine. Named in honour of co-owners Anthony Bottazzi and Massimo Zuccheroso’s grandmother, Antonietta pays homage to tradition while embracing a fresh, modern feel.
Overall, reviewers describe Antonietta as a cozy, authentic Italian spot with a small, open kitchen and a menu that highlights fresh pasta, wood-fired pizza, and seafood. The dining experience is often praised for warm, attentive service and a thoughtful wine list, along with dishes that feel true to Italian tradition. Yet some visits mention hiccups like loud, busy nights, inconsistent pacing or service, and occasional price or addition issues. Taken together, Antonietta is viewed as a standout choice in Montreal and a reliable venue for memorable pasta and pizza, with reservations recommended and expectations shaped by how smoothly the service and value align on any given night.
What a great experience. A neighbourhood but much more than that. The service was top notch i felt right at home when I got in.
As for the food, the octopus salade with fennel & organe was a breath of fresh air followed with the lamb chops with an amazing sauce was a great way to start the evening.
We finished the night with a couple pastas that were very generous portion wise.
Overall i highly recommend this restaurant. Come by for the wine & stay for the food.
Très bonne nourriture & service impeccable
Sauf au moment des factures ou la serveuse a inversé nos factures & n'a pas voulu les ajuster donc j'ai payé 50% plus cher que ce que j'aurai dû…
C'est aussi tres bruyant & on sent l'urgence de vite manger & vite libérer la table c est dommage …
May 21, 2025
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
antonietta is an italian hidden gem! the restaurant is small but the seating arrangement, decor, & ambiance make the space feel cozy & inviting. with an open kitchen concept, you feel as though you're a guest having handmade dinner in someone's home. the service is impeccable as the staff is extremely informed about the ingredients & extensively know their wine list. the wine menu has your main options: red, white, orange & bubbly. if you have any questions or concerns they are there to guide you in having the best & most authentic italian experience in the city. now when it comes to the food - absolutely orgasmic! with a perfectly size menu (one page) you can taste the freshness & quality in each bite from appetizers to dessert. to add, i noticed that so much craft, passion, & creativity goes into every dish. we were fortunate to try an experimental dish made by their back of house legend, matteo, & of course it did not disappoint.
antonietta is absolutely gorgeous & checks all your culinary boxes! thank you to the amazing team, can't wait to come back during the summer!
Amazing experience as always. One of the best italian restaurants in Montreal, everyone should give it a try.
Everything is great from the wine selection, to the starters, the pizza, the pasta, the mains & the desserts. Menu is often changing so you can always try new things.
The grilled octopus that was on the special last night was one of the best I've had in a very long time. Super tender & moist.
Très bel accueil, nous n'avions pas de réservation & on nous a accommodé malgré l'achalandage. Tout ce qu'on a mangé était bon mis à part le tiramisu & la pizza, la pâte était molle & mouillée, sinon ce fut une belle soirée !
Si vous recherchez une expérience culinaire italienne qui sort de l ordinaire je vous recommande fortement Antonietta le chef/propriétaire Anthony est incroyable 10/10
J'ai tout simplement adoré mon expérience chez Antonietta ! Tout était parfait, du service à l'ambiance, sans oublier la nourriture, qui était un véritable délice. Je recommande ce restaurant sans hésitation, 10/10 !
What a gem! Simple plates exceptionally prepared in a simple yet comfortable room with wonderfully friendly staff at reasonable prices. Always enjoy dinner here. The pizzas are delicious, the pasta perfectly prepared & the appetizers are always a tasty start. Don't miss dessert - the new nougat dessert is hands down the best!!!!
Mar 30, 2025
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Food was OK at best (we had some apps, pizzas, & desserts). One of the pizzas was borderline gross which is inexcusable for a flagship item. Service was cold & disinterested & an afterthought. It was all just whatever.
It's a shame because we were there a few years & had a totally opposite experience, everything was great. I feel like what happened last night is representative of the food scene in Montreal now - degraded quality of food & service in exchange for heightened prices. I have no problem paying more to support our restaurants but I'm fed up with leaving these experiences feeling that I was taken advantage of as a customer.
Also, 18%-25% tip option range on payment machines is incredibly presumptuous.
Abbiamo mangiato un pasto fantastico da Antonietta. Tutto era buonissimo. La pasta all'agnello che abbiamo provato era un piatto memorabile. I sapori si amalgamavano perfettamente. E che dire della pizza, incredibile. Il posto è carinissimo, e il servizio è a 5 stelle, ti trattano come se fossi in famiglia. Era la nostra prima volta qui e non sarà l'ultima.
Back of the house is still great but the front has taken a nosedive. I've loved this restaurant every time I've been previously but the service was truly lacking at my most recent visit (slow, inattentive, impersonal). Gone is the Italian family vibe that I had loved so much.
We had heard that at least one of the former owners has left & unfortunately is shows.
Mar 8, 2025
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
One of Montreal's hidden gems! I was impressed by their attention to details & the quality they bring to all of their dishes! Every thing is made from scratch. A true Italian authentic restaurant where the staff truly take pride in their work. Worth the detour!
L'équipe est exceptionnelle, le service est impeccable. La pizza est délicieuse & les pâtes fraîches sont tout simplement incroyables. Nous y allons y retourner. Un vrai coup de coeur !
