Pub McCarold is described in reviews as a lively Irish pub with strong food and drinks, where the atmosphere and friendly service are consistently praised. The kitchen earns praise for hearty, well presented fare, from classic pub dishes to inventive burgers and regional favorites like poutine, with some calls that certain poutines are among Montreal's best. The beer selection is solid, featuring international classics and local options, though a few note it could be more extensive. The vibe is welcoming and convivial, often busy in the evenings, with outdoor seating in warmer weather and a layout that accommodates groups. Service is generally attentive and professional, though a few visits mention slower times or occasional missteps that can dampen the experience. Overall, Pub McCarold appears as a dependable go-to in the area for good food, good beer, and a lively pub atmosphere.
The drinks & food were great however the server dropped the fries & blamed it on us saying "I thought you were holding it". I've worked in the restaurant business for years & this is unacceptable, just say sorry & replace it. I would have given the fries free of charge as we also had to wait another 10 to 15 minutes.
Go for the beer & the burgers, the poutine messed me up for an entire day. Our waitress was divine !!!! Lovely as can be & for a pub on a Monday it was well packed.
Jun 16, 2024
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Repas délicieux (ils font la meilleure salade chèvre & poire), très bonne ambiance, excellente musique & service chaleureux & courtois. On a passé un excellent moment, comme toujours! C'est mon pub préféré
Très bon endroit pour manger de la nourriture typique de pub, faite maison. Délicieux fish & chips & onion rings. Les prix sont très abordables pour la qualité & la quantité. Service excellent.
Ambiance is still 5/5 Poutine bites/nuggets were still enjoyed but were much better last time I was here; it was nicely crunchy on the outside, this time they were not made with love so it seems No love from the Nachos either being plain & underseasoned Nachos 2.5 /5 Sweet potatoes were fantastic! Chicken wings were good Still hesitant to order a main dish again i.e. a burger or the ribs as they were very mediocre. Food used to be amazing here years ago. Always coming back here for the beer & good vibe though!
The food is very good, it was really fast but we didn't like the service, they were without patience with us because we asked them to speak English & they wanted to speak French
Super endroit, je recommande la poutine & la soupe à l'oignon! Le service est vraiment super, tout le monde est hyper sympathique & la déco est vraiment cool!
