Reviews for Pizzeria Melrose consistently highlight phenomenal pizza, fresh ingredients, and a welcoming, elegant atmosphere with attentive staff. Diners note generous portions, good value for the quality, and helpful recommendations from servers when deciding on dishes. The menu is praised for variety, including salads, pastas, cannoli, and espresso, with wine often mentioned as decent value. Several experiences advise booking ahead due to the busy pace, and describe the service as friendly, efficient, and above average. A few critiques mention pricing on drinks and a dish note about a sauce being too salty, but these are outweighed by overall satisfaction and the sense of hospitality that makes guests want to return.
OMG!!!!!
it's not just the food, the atmosphere, the service ,the recommendations, it's everything.
I had the best pizza in a while, my girlfriend got the pasta.
Please do not think too much to come here, you will have a great time.
By the way there's also an outdoor tables.
Very Very expensive for what you get. An hour later we were hungry. The quality is really there ! But the quantity & the strength of the flavor, for what you pay ? It's not.
Looking at the other pictures.. our pizzas were pretty empty. Almost no sauce & no cheese & one slice of meat spread around .
Apr 25, 2025
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
We've been going to Melrose Pizza since it opened & we still love it all these years later! The pizza & salads are always absolutely delicious & we love the relaxed, homey ambiance. A consistent highlight for us is the staff. Paolo, Marc & Alex always make us feel so welcome & really add to the neighbourhood feel of the place. Excellent service, excellent food -what more could you want?! LOVE IT. Highly recommend.
If you're looking to host a family event or just a casual dinner with friends, this is the place to be. From the intimate atmosphere of the private room to the main dining area. No matter where you sit, the food & service is A+.
Based on how flattering the recent reviews were, we had such high hopes for this place... nothing memorable about their pizzas. Overall the dough lacked flavour, watered down tomato sauce, lacking texture & frankly quite bland tasting (we had the NDG & Margherita). Warm & cozy atmosphere inside on the plus side, contrasting with the staff (owner?) who was rather dry & unwelcoming.
The food, the ambiance & the staff were A+. Had a chance to meet the owner Paolo & he was right. It is one of the best pizzas in Montreal. If you're in the neighbourhood, give them a try. You won't be disappointed .
Nov 7, 2024
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
My husband & I have been trying different Pizza Restaurants when ever we travel to bitter cities. Now, we have decided to try one in our neighborhood. Pizzaria Melrose has been at its current location for over 10 years. They serve neopolitain style pizza, pasta, salads, & a few desserts. This time, we were 3, so we got to try 3 different pizzas. First, we started with the Cesar salad. The lettuce was crisp. The dressing was plentiful with a lot of grated cheese on top. Four small slices of bacon were decorativly placed on top. It was very good. We then ordered a Classic pizza, a Gigi pizza, & a Three Meat pizza. The undercarriage of the Classic & Gigi were perfectly cooked & held up to lifting & folding in half. The Tree Meat one, however, was wet & had to be eaten with a fork & knife. They will, for next time, if asked, cook it longer so it won't be soggy. The toppings on all 3 pizzas were very good, making them delicious. Overall, we enjoyed the pizza & will go back. The service was great. Parking was easy considering the location. The atmosphere was noisy, but it's expected for the type of restaurant.
Good Neapolitan pies with good quality ingredients . They definitely care about their product & it shows . Pie was a little underbaked for my taste but I assume most guests would not appreciate a char like I do . Cesar salad was tasty . Good dose of grated cheese & I was impressed that the romaine actually was chilled . Mark was a great host & he assured me that if I request well done next time , it will be looked after . Class act . We will certainly be back
In the 10+ years I have lived in the area, this was the first time my wife & I tried this place after many suggestions from friends. I share the bad experience others have had so far in terms of food quality & the manager. Don't waste your money here.
