Reviews for Pizzeria Melrose consistently highlight phenomenal pizza, fresh ingredients, and a welcoming, elegant atmosphere with attentive staff. Diners note generous portions, good value for the quality, and helpful recommendations from servers when deciding on dishes. The menu is praised for variety, including salads, pastas, cannoli, and espresso, with wine often mentioned as decent value. Several experiences advise booking ahead due to the busy pace, and describe the service as friendly, efficient, and above average. A few critiques mention pricing on drinks and a dish note about a sauce being too salty, but these are outweighed by overall satisfaction and the sense of hospitality that makes guests want to return.
Tout était super bon ,peut-être qu'on aurait pris une sauce tomate un peu plus salée pour la pizza mais rien de trop dérangeant. La salade d'endives & le gâteau au chocolat était notre coup de coeur tout simplement incroyable. Le propriétaire était vraiment cool & super sympathique avec les enfants.
Tout est parfait! De la pizza, fine, croustillante, savoureuse, avec des ingrédients de première qualité au service excellent & super attentionné, gentil & accueillant à l'environnement vraiment élégant & chaleureux. Je me suis senti chez moi. En tant qu'Italien, j'ai été vraiment stupéfait. A essayer absolument ! La pizza N.D.G est fantastique, peut-être grâce au pizzaiolo italo-américain Guido qui a des mains féerées, des années & des années d'expérience & une sympathie & un accueil hors de la façon.
This place was & is absolutely incredible!! I actually wasn't keen on going at first as I noticed it was just pizza no fries no pasta no ice cream but my bf wanted to go so we went & wow!! Was I pleasantly surprised
Originally the owner turned us away for 45mins but then this incredible busboy asked how many we were & told the owner how he can make space for us & within 10mins we were at a table & this busboy went above & beyond. His service was so impressive. The food was also incredible! Portions were generous, &
Prices extremely fair. We had such an amazing experience we were trying to figure out when to go back
The tiramisu so fluffy
The cannoli hard with flavour & the chocolate cake .. wow! Was like fudge
The pizza …so good
Only thing I didn't love was the calamari …sauce.. too salty & very strong olive taste but really not a reason to give this place anything but 10/10
Cesar salad was amazing & this croutons .. wow!! Latte was also delicious!
We were too busy laughing & eating to take photos but had to come here to write a review as
When restaurants are suffering & pockets are tight this place is worth the night out & the wait staff deserve the all the tips
This was an Extremely refreshing restaurant experience
Sep 5, 2025
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Love Melrose Pizzeria! Fresh, high quality ingredients that brings up your pizza experience to another level. Where else can you find five cheese & spicy honey pizza 😋 Their veal meatballs & fennel salad is also delicious! Pablo, the owner is also an absolute star & always a pleasure to meet!
OMG!!!!!
it's not just the food, the atmosphere, the service ,the recommendations, it's everything.
I had the best pizza in a while, my girlfriend got the pasta.
Please do not think too much to come here, you will have a great time.
By the way there's also an outdoor tables.
Very Very expensive for what you get. An hour later we were hungry. The quality is really there ! But the quantity & the strength of the flavor, for what you pay ? It's not.
Looking at the other pictures.. our pizzas were pretty empty. Almost no sauce & no cheese & one slice of meat spread around .
